"It was dark, and it was cold, and I was scared, then, then I saw him..." Jack and Hiccup have been best friends ever since childhood, even before Jack became an immortal, which is our timeline. Jackson Overland and Hiccup have been friends forever, always hang out, laugh, even just hang out together, and get along well with each other's families, but when that all crumbles down, by an accident, Hiccup starts feeling alone, like he doesn't matter to anyone, once his best friend is gone. Until the years pass and he becomes the pride of Berk, and has a girlfriend called Astrid now, the most ruthless and tough girl in the entire village. But what happens when Jack Frost appears in the picture again? When he hears his best friend's voice luring him there and when he feels the need to stay? Stay where he feels he's meant to stay at... And what when they start having feelings for each other but they don't know what it means? Will Berk allow it? Will Hiccup's father and Astrid be okay with it? Or will this never be permitted and they will have to finally forget each other, and go their separate ways? [Based on Troye Sivan's song, "Blue Neighbourhood"]