Criticism Stories

[OPEN] Astania's book club for those who wish to have a stress-free, non-structured environment. You can choose any member's book to read, and receive engagement on your own book in the process! See our profile for other book clubs!

[OPEN] Astania's book club for those in search of a structured format and constructive feedback. Sign up to be placed in bi-weekly pairings, where you'll read six chapters and exchange extensive comments! See our profile for other book clubs!

The Ultimate GameCube Tier List! None had tried to rank at least a great portion of the wonderous system's library, so I thought to do it! As of now the list will be at about 135 video games from instant classics to the worst of shovelware! Some will be focused on quite a bunch while others will be breezed through, as this list will consist of games I've both completed and have not finished as of yet, but when I have something to say, boy will I have something to say! These ranking are all my opinion, and there is bound to be hot takes, so no flames! Also, expect spoilers...

Looking for a safe space to get constructive feedback? A place where you're not just called out, but also given ways to improve? A place to grow and expand into the vast space of your creativity? Then you've found the right place. Here, I strive to give you the best review I possibly can-highlighting strong points, areas for improvement, and offering usable suggestions. I don't sugarcoat, so this isn't the place for you if you're looking for an ego boost. That said, I do my best to offer reviews with a calm, professional tone-a means to raise your confidence and morale. So-what are you waiting for?

oc reviews (CLOSED)

I'm temporarily closing this book, reopening it on summer maybe. School's getting hectic these days, I had to focus on those sheets (read it fast haha).

Do you want a book review. Just submit your form and follow the rules and I'll give it to you👍 Closed(🔒)

Do you want to read books and have people read your book, but can't find anybody to read your book honestly. Then head on over to my reading club where people are willing going to read your book and you are going to find exciting new books to read.

Armani and Trey are back and let's just say that these two go through a lot. There's going to be a lot of criticism towards they're relationship and its gonna get worse. It tests patience and that's a big thing in relationships. Will they stick together or lose each other ? Read to find out

REQUESTS ARE CLOSED Designed a new character but want to know others thoughts on it? Want to get some tips on how to make a good character or to be pointed in the right direction? Well, you're in the right place! I'm here to check your guys' OCS and see what I think. Don't worry, I'm not going out of my way to be brutally honest and mean just because I can because honestly, that's just painful. I will be as honest as I possibly can without tearing your character to shreds and giving ways you can improve. I will review characters from existing universes as well, there's a list on the first page of fan bases I'm apart of. This is all for fun and you don't have to follow my critiques, if you think I'm wrong then that's fine, nothing here is meant to cause offence and I am simply here to help you all improve.

Welcome to the Shut Up and Read Book Club. Only those who really desire feedback are welcome to participate in our most majestic of societies. So, reader, and you, writer, will you come and have fun here at SUAR? We are open for writers of all ages, genres, and abilities and we also extend our invitation to readers who may not have a book, but have a kind heart. Come on in...

📚✨ Hey, fellow Wattpad writers! 🎉 Are you ready to exchange stories and dive into new worlds? I'm looking to do a fun read-for-read! Let's support each other by swapping our tales and sharing those hidden gems that deserve a spotlight! 🌟

What do you need for your character outlines to encourage a productive character review? This guide answers it! The companion guide to Why I Hate (Most) Character Reviews.

This is a story that follows two childhood friends - Lily and Mason. Due to some misinterpreted words and doubts, their friendship now hangs on loose threads. As they live their high school lives, meeting friends and foe, what will the future lie in stall for them? Will their stupid hearts lead them to heartbreak, help them form lifelong connections, or will it even restore their friendship? Well, only time will tell.

(full description inside the story) cover by @soundthealarm banner by @fadedperfection

Throughout Riverdale, every living soul was abuzz at the big news that had just hit the papers. The wedding of Alice Smith and FP Jones. All sorts of crazy things were being said about the couple. All, of course, gossip from their past trying to taint their sweet hereafter. To unburden themselves from all the negative, the couple escaped to their secret haven.

ミ★𝘊𝘳𝘪𝘵𝘪𝘤𝘢𝘭 𝘰𝘣𝘴𝘦𝘳𝘷𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘰𝘳 𝘦𝘹𝘢𝘮𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 Criticism over the books/stories you submit! Just tag me on your story and I'll dedicate a chapter lmfao (I'll hide your name if wanted) Doesn't matter if it's smut, fluff, angst, fanfiction, fantasy or whatever, just tag me and I'll do the best I can to critique it.

Closed: Planned to Reopen December 2025

SPOILER ALERT Just watching movies and tv shows and then ranting about it. Give me sth you want me to talk about and I will try. Also ngl, this is more of character reviews rather than the overall film.

《《 CLOSED FOR CATCHUP》》 An opportunity to get feedback as an author and find new books as a reader! Feel free to check it out! :)