Masked Love (Masky x reader)

Chapter 5

(y/n)'s POV

I walk into the Living room. Masky, Hoodie, and Eyeless Jack looks up at me. Ben and Jeff are still focused on the videogame.

"So what is your punishment?" Masky asks. His mask is right above his mouth -so he can eat the cheesecake he has in his lap- so I could see that he is smirking. Oh how much I want to slap that smirk off of his face. I just smirk back.

"Well he is making it so that starting tomorrow, me and Masky are not going to be patrolling anymore. We will be going out killing instead until we could get along. Toby will be patrolling with Hoodie." Masky jumps up.

"What the hell?! I do NOT agree to this! There is no way in hell that I would be your hunting partner." I glare at him.

"Your options are to be my killing partner, or we could be locked in the basement until we get along. Which do you choose?" He growls and sits back down.

"Fucking damn it." He mutters. "Fine. I'll go kill with you." I smile.

"Good. We start tomorrow." I say, walking to Masky's room. 'Damn. I should've asked Slenderman when my room will be finished.' I wait for a response to see if Slender is reading my mind. Nothing. 'Slender!' I yell in my mind.

'Yes Child?' He asks through my mind.

'When is my room going to be finished?' I hear him chuckle nervously.

'Well, um.... You won't be getting your own room. No one wants to partner up so you could have a room. So now you have to choose what room you will stay in.' I groan. Who do I want to room with?

'Is it okay if I switch rooms? So I can give others a break from me?'

'Of course.' I smile. So I will spend a week in Masky's room, then a week in Hoodie's room, then in Ej's room, then Toby's room. And repeat. But if that is okay with Hoodie, Ej, and Toby. I walk to my bed and I lie down. After a moment or two of me staring at the ceiling, Masky walks in.

"Hey, (y/n). Are you sleeping?" I close my eyes and pretend I am. I am not in the mood to talk to this evil fuck. "I take that as a no. Well I just wanted to say that I don't know how to express my feelings with you. I want to tell you that I love you, but at the same time, I just really want to hurt you. I want to see you smile, but I also want to see you cry." He sighs and stands up.

"Which is it?" I say. He looks at me, surprised.

"W-what?"

"Which is it? Which one do you feel more? " I ask him. He looks at me surprised. He was about to answer me until we heard knocking on the door. We look over to see Jeff in the doorway, glaring at us.

"Sorry to interrupt you two, but you guys need to go talk to Slenderman." I chuckle at Jeff.

"Yes Jeffy. We will be there in a minute." He rolls his eyes and walks away. We get up and walk to Slender's office.

"Slender, you wanted to see us?" I ask, walking into his office.

"Yes child. You and Masky have a mission today." Masky and I look at each other.

"What is it Slender?" I ask.

"You will be going to (random address) to kill the 16 year old Ellie. She has been doing a lot of research about us and she knows too much information. You need to stop her. Before things get out of hand." We nod.

"Yes Sir. We will go do it now." I smile.

"Great." Masky mumbles. I glare at him. I understand he hates me but damn boy, you don't have to fucking show it. I roll my eyes at him. He notices and glares. "What the fuck are you looking at?"

"Dude! I understand you hate me but why the fuck are you being like this? It's getting annoying!" He grabs me by the collar of my hoodie.

"Look bitch, I didn't ask to do this. It's because you had to walk away like a pussy that we are now in this mess."

"If you guys are going to continue to fight, the basement is set up for you two. So stop arguing and go, or enjoy a long month together." Slenderman said to us, sounding really upset. Masky drops me and looks at him.

"Why am I being punished for her mistakes?" Masky shouts at Slenderman. I slowly back away. 'I will not get into any more trouble than I already am in.'

"If it wasn't for you being rude, she wouldn't have left her duties. Now I suggest that you lower your tone with me Timothy and get going." Masky sighs.

"Fine. Whatever. Let's go then so I can get back and enjoy myself." I nod. When I walk to the door, I look at Slenderman.

"Can I bring Eyeless Jack too please?" Slendy pauses for a minute before nodding.

"Sure child. But you do need to make sure it is okay with him. And same as last time, I will teleport you there but you have to walk home." I smile and look at EJ.

"So do you want to go with us?" He smiles at me.

"Sure." And as Slenderman says, he teleports us to the house of the victim. We sneak to every window, trying to find Ellie. Eventually we make our way to a window. Sprawled across the walls is Jeff's face. Here and there are little pictures of the others. I chuckle.f

"It's like Jeff's girlfriend. She's fucking insane." EJ laughs while Masky just rolls his eyes, clearly not appreciating my humor.

"Whatever, let's just kill her already." I open the girls window and sneak in. Next to the window was her bed. I see a girl with dark black hair sleeping in her bed. 'She wants to be like Jeff. I'll make her look like him.' I put on my gloves and grabbed one of her knives that were on the floor. I carefully grab her hand, sliding the knife in it, slitting open her mouth on the left side, she screams in pain. I hear her parents running down the hall towards her door. I quickly slice her neck open, blood gushing everywhere. Masky grabs me by the hips, causing me to let go of her hand, and pulls me out of the room. We make a run for it towards the woods. Once we were far enough, we started to walk. EJ looks at me.

"Why did you make her slice her own mouth open then stab herself?" I chuckle and look at him smiling.

"Well you see, I wanted it to look like a suicide. I wanted them to think she was insanely in love with Jeff that she slit her mouth. Then due to pain take her own life to end it. It is perfect since she had all those pictures of Jeff so it worked." Eyless nods.

"Not bad (y/n). Not bad." Eyeless says while patting my head. I hear Masky scoff. I looked at him sadly and so did EJ. "What? You didn't think she did good Masky?"

"It wasn't that smart or impressive. No one will believe it." Masky shakes his head while speaking. I glare and slap him.

"I did the best I could. Don't degrade me all the damn time. I'd like to see you do better Jackass." We start walking and make it home slowly. 

Next update: 1-3 days

Hello Lovlies! Thank you for reading my story. It has been awhile since I wrote this story. Half of it I just wrote today. So if I messed up a bit, I'm so sorry. I will be reading all my chapters over again so I can make sure the story makes since.  I do work and I am a senior in High School. I graduate in June so I am a little busy but I will try to write as much as I can. Thank you for your support. Please leave comments! They make me smile when I read them. And who knows. Depending on what you wrote, you might get a shout out :D. And if you want to see something happen in the story, you will get a shout out that chapter to show who gave me the idea. Thank you for your time and understanding! ~Author-Chan