Teen Wolf Imagines

Secrets Part 1 Peter

Pairing former Theo x reader end Peter x reader
Warning cheating, swearing,
Description reader catches Theo with Tracy, Peter finds her offering a shoulder to cry on but how will Theo take it
Part 2&3 coming soon

Story

 
You walked down the dark, damp and dirty tunnels of the dread doctors’ former lab. You hated it here and constantly question why Theo still stayed down here when you both shared a home. You hard a laugh as you got deeper into the tunnel. Rolling your eyes you knew that voice, Tracy Stewart. One of Theo’s  Chimera’s and one you hated most. She’s always flirting with him in front of you, hang on his every word, try to be the best little soldier she could for him.
 
You took a breath before opening the door ready to deal with her antics. As you opened the door you the sight made you freeze in place. Theo was sat on an old hospital gurney that had been left behind. Tracey naked over his lap laughing and moaning as Theo kissed down her neck to her boobs.
 
You didn’t move, frozen until the sound of your handbag hitting the floor, it was at the same sound Theo literally threw Tracy off him. She hit the ground hard about to moan at him for hurting her. He didn’t care, he watched you run back down the hall, shouting your name over and over.
 
With his heightened speed he could have easily caught up to you but when he seen you reach the door/hatch to get in and out, he stopped letting you run. Punching the wall he knew he’d screwed up. He hoped you’d run, cry and come back so he could apologise. Walking back to the room me smirked seeing the bag, you had to come back for. He looked at Tracy who was stood unsure what to do or say. Theo growled at her to get dressed and leave.
 
You ran for as long as you could once you stopped the tears ran down your face. You couldn’t believe he’d do that to you, after everything you’d given up to be with him like your friends, a home. You were more hurt it was with Tracey too, he knew your feelings about her and her flirting. No matter how much you told him she’s flirting he’d laugh and say there was nothing to worry about he only had eyes for you. That thought had you guessing how long had it been going on for, had they been sleeping with each other for the past 2 months.
 
You felt a buzz in your pocket. Looking at your phone it was Theo, you mute the call once the ringtone starts letting it continue to silently ring out. You didn’t want to hear his excuses, all you wanted to do was get in your car and drive as far away as possible, “fuck” you shout, your bag was still in the tunnels. You hadn’t picked it up when you ran. It had your car keys, credit cards, everything in. You wasn’t going back not yet at least. Fishing in your pocket you pull out some cash, wasn’t a lot but enough to get a drink and get out the cold.
 

You looked up at the bar, it looked a bit more expensive than your usual places but right now you didn’t care.
Inside it looked as fancy as the sign did. Theo would never take you somewhere like this, maybe that was a good thing you wouldn’t run into him here.
 
Ordering a drink you staying sat at the bar. You thought about where can you go after here, the bar wasn’t gonna stay open all night. You wanted to call Scott, Lydia even Stiles, who now seen you as sleeping with the enemy. But it was true you did choose Theo over them once and now regret not listening when they told you he was bad news or was using you to get to Scott and the pack.
 
“hello sweetheart” a smooth voice said behind but kind of to your left. You turned seeing Peter Hale next to, gesturing the barman over so he can order a drink. It wasn’t you didn’t like Peter, you just didn’t want to face anyone right now with the way you were feeling.
 
“Oh god, what are you doing here Peter, I thought you’d gone away?” you asked him with an eye roll. the last time you’d seen him was Mexico.
 
“After our last little group encounter I had a little business to attend to but I’m back and better than ever” he said then turned to the barman to order his drink. Something about being better than ever sounded strange and definitely not good but you didn’t care right now what plans he had, more about what plans you needed to make for the night.
 
Peter looked you up and down, you would of missed it if you wasn’t watching him out the corner of your eye. “what’s new with you? Never seen you in here before” he asked.
 
You sigh “nothing came for a quiet drink”. It was a lie and you knew he’d know you were lying too but right now you hoped he’d take the hint you didn’t wanna talk about it. Fat chance with the way he looked at you.
 
He chuckled “oh please something wrong, your here drinking a double of whatever the hell that is. Reeking of anger, and sadness” he said back, cocky. His flashes of micro smiles and smirks showed he loved being right and was proving it.
 
“fucking werewolves” you mutter annoyed with his attitude, just like Theo always thought they were better and smarter. Just because they had powers.
 
“what about werewolves” he challenged, not a threat but smugly ‘go on finish’
 
Turning in your seat to look him in the eyes “I said fucking werewolves, with your heightened senses, using your weird smell detector”. You scream at him.
 
He laughed almost spitting out his drink, “our what?” he asked finding it amusing. “smell detector” he repeated still with a laugh.
 
You knew it sounded stupid but it was the only thing you could think to call it “you know the way you sniff out emotions, always listening for a lie” you explain.
 
He leaned his head in closer “hmm do you want to lie to me, y/n” his tone, teasing and suggestive. You couldn’t lie, Peter was attractive. He’s older, dangerous and certainly someone who’d peeked your interest in the past but after Theo came to town you’d not paid much attention to the older wolf.
 
“nope not lie but can’t a girl have her secrets too”. You smirk back finishing the last of your drink. It wasn’t  like splitting with Theo was a secret but you didn’t want to talk about it too.
 
“now that sounds like a challenge”  his micro-expressions that smile/snarl. Lifting his upper lip showing of his teeth. The action was him all over and would normally send your heart racing. “why don’t you let me buy you another drink see if I can find out some of your secrets”
 
What was the harm? Wasn’t like you had anywhere or anyone to go to. Plus a bit of company was better than sulking on your own. You agreed, getting out your seat Peter asked the barman for another round to be brought over. Then led you to a table in the back corner. The barman was less than a minute behind you with a tray, he placed your drinks down telling Peter if he needed anything to signal him, before leaving you and Peter to your night.
 
You wasn’t sure what to say to him so picked your drink up and said thanks. Peter smirked copying picking up his glass “here’s to secrets. Keeping, making and telling” he joked tilting his glass forward in toast.
 
You giggled, mimicking his tilt before having a sip. “what about you Hale, wanna share any of your secrets” you ask, yes it was deflecting but you had to say something to change the subject from you.
 
“why, what do you wanna know sweetheart?” he asked, you wasn’t sure if it was just naturally the way he spoke or your imagination but his voice was like velvet, smooth, deep and very seductive.
 
You didn’t know how to answer, you wasn’t expecting a counter question. “anything! Your a man full of them, enough to fill a book or ten. Telling me one won’t hurt” you giggle. The alcohol giving you an added push to be a little flirty with him or maybe the need to get some confidence back after Theo’s betrayal. Maybe you just wanted to betray him back even if it was in the way of shameless flirting only, it felt good.
 
Peter’s voice dragged you from your mental questions. “well sweetheart if your lucky ill show you one of them later” he said, it sounded like a thrilling and dangerous promise. “that’s only if your a good girl” he added now thrilling sounded dirty and still dangerous as hell.
 
“I can be good, bad and everything in between” you sass back biting your lower lip, knowing he can probably hear your heart beat race at his words.
 
He had judging by the smug one sided smirk he had. He leaned in closer “does your chimera boy toy know your her being a naughty girl flirting with the enemy” he asked. He moves back when he seen your shoulders tense and face change. He was probably notice scent changes too.
 
You sigh “first, I wouldn’t call you the enemy, not anymore, and second” you paused looking down at your glass, swilling the liquid around inside. “my big ‘secret’ that the whole of Beacon Hills will know about by tomorrow is, we’re over, Theo cheated on me with that slag Tracy I walked in on them” you say a mix of pain and hate as you spoke
 
Peter gave a small chuckle “of cause he did” he said taking another sip of his drink, like he hadn’t just offended you. “it was only a matter of time” he added after swallowing his bourbon.
 
You sat there open-mouthed in shock, dumbfounded by his words. Was Tracy really better than you? Was it obvious to everyone but you their affair? “ex...excuse me” was all you managed to stutter out.
 
He noticed he offended you, reaching out his hand to touch your arm. You went to pull it away but he was too fast holding you in place. “it’s nothing against you y/n, It’s Theo, his cheating was inevitable and predictable, he’s  the type who’s never happy with what he’s got. He wants power and got it but wants more. Your amazing and he’ll soon be crawling back when he figures out he’s lost someone as incredible as you.” He said in a soft sweet tone different from the flirty one he’d been using all night.
 
You blushed and said thank you for the compliment, heck if anything your ego needed it. You didn’t know what to say next, you head was all over the place and Peter wasn’t helping. When you didn’t speak he removes his hand watching you trying to work out what you were thinking.
 
Peter finished his drink and waving to the barman for another round. “To be honest I’m not sure what the hell you saw in him anyway.” Peter said making you look up.
 
 You gave a small nervous chuckle thinking about it now you wonder the same. What did you see in Theo. First his looks, the guy looked like a fashion model, those green eyes, his dirty blonde hair and body that looked like it was chiselled out of stone. At first he was different, sweet caring made you feel like a princess. But after some time he’s attention and affection dimed he was always with his new pack or plotting new plans to hurt, maim and kill. “maybe I just have a thing for bad guys” you mumble not meaning it to come out aloud.
 
The waiter placed your drink in front of you dragging you out of your thoughts. “my good friend here has had a bad day. Can we also get a refill and a round of shots too” Peter asked him.
“Certainly Mr. Hale I will be one minute with them” the waiter answered walking away to get the shots.
 
You smirk at Peter  “trying to get me drunk are we?” you joked. Not like you didn’t like that idea.
 
“no, just helping you forget your pain sweetheart” he smiled back again this was different. There was no flirting, no sarcasm, no underling motives behind it.
 
The waiter came back placing two shot glasses down filling them both taking a bottle of bourbon and refilled Peter’s and pour you one with a new glass. “is this all you want or would like me to leave the bottle Mr. Hale?” he asked. Something about the way he spoke to Peter gave you the feeling he was a regular here and wasn’t the first time Peter had asked for the full bottle.
 
“well here to forgetting”  you say clinking your glass with his before drinking the shot in one. Peter mirrored your movement before refilling the glasses.
 
The bottles started to go down but your spirit and feelings rose. Peter hadn’t asked anything else about Theo. For the rest of the night you both sat laughing and talking reminiscing about the past “you still owe me for that night Hale, I have a gunshot scar because of you” you joked when Peter brought up past antics. He reached over the table his thumb lightly brush over your knuckles
 
“your the one who pushed me out the way sweetheart. I didn’t ask you to but I’m grateful you did” he sassed back. A few years ago before Theo even showed up in beacon hills you had been with Peter when hunters showed up. The bullet aimed for Peter was full of wolfsbane and wold have killed him. You pushed him taking the bullet to the shoulder, it was through and though not enough to kill you but you always enjoyed reminding him of it.
 
You look down at hand lifting your a little, so he can slide his fingers under your palm keeping his thumb where it was. You welcome his touch seeking comfort in it, trying to ignore the voice in the back of your head telling you to stop and move your hand.
 
“I thought Stiles was going to rip your head off that day”  you say back hoping to keep the conversation neutral.
 
Peter laughed “do you really think he could” he said it was true stiles was angry and Scott holding him back wasn’t to protect Peter but to protect stiles. Thinking back Peter had kept his distance after that you was going to question why but the sound of last orders bell stopped you.
 
You didn’t realises how much time you sat there for. Both you and Peter finish the last of your drinks and walk out together. He went in the direction of his car, you paused thinking where you was gonna go. You forgot about finding someone to crash with. You certainly wasn’t going back to Theo, or your car outside his hideout.
 
“y/n, where you staying tonight” he asked. You looked up at him with a blank expression it’s like he read your mind. “I’m guessing you not going home with Theo being there, have you got somewhere to go?”
 
Shaking your head no, “I guess a park bench can’t be too bad, plus I’ll get my keys and car at first light when he goes on his run” you try to sound as unfazed as possible, Kinda like the whole idea of it didn’t scare the hell out of you.
 
Peter gave a growl “you won’t do any such thing” he said. “you can use my guest room” this wasn’t an offer more of an order like he wasn’t gonna let you stay anywhere else.
 
You smile at him “are you sure?” you ask. Peter didn’t answer he just opened the passenger side door for you to get in. “Thank you” you say getting in the car thankful you wasn’t sleeping outdoors.