Benny Rodriguez/ Luis Mendoza

After Prom ⚠️

(This is two years after prom, your senior year) "all baseball players will now be released at this time" I hear the principal say on the intercom. Me and Benny were walking to our class when this happened. "Well, I better go. Wish me luck doll" he pulls me in with his arm. I giggled, pulled his head down and kissed him "good luck Jet" "thanks.. bye my love, i'll see you later". He gives me a quick hug and walks out with the other baseball players to the buses. I feel someone put their arm around my shoulders "what's up?" I look over and see Jada. "Hey J" I smiled "have you seen Kenn-yyy?!" she squealed. I turned around, see that Kenny picked her up from behind and spun her around. I smiled "lucky your boyfriend stuck around" I rolled my eyes and laughed. Jada smiles "you'll see yours after school!" "I know, I'm teasing!". The last bell of the day rang and I ran outside. I feel someone grab me from behind and spin me "who the-" they set me back on the ground. I turn around and see Benny "thanks for the good luck kiss, we won" he whispered in my ear. I wrapped my arms around his neck "good job babe!" He grabs the back of my thighs and picks me up. I wrapped my legs around his lower-waist and he spun me around. He stopped and looked into my eyes "god I love you" I cupped his face and he quickly pecked my lips. Benny puts me down, takes of his hat and puts it on me. He smiles "god, you're fucking beautiful" I looked down and blushed. I feel someone push me, hard, away from Benny. I turn around to see who the hell pushed me and see Amy, pulling Benny in by the collar of his shirt. "You look so good in this- baseball outfit of yours" Amy said in a flirtatious voice. "Amy no" I look up to hear Benny and see Amy about to kiss him. I went over to them and 'accidently' pushed Amy out of the way. "You bitch!" Amy yelled "I'm a bitch when someone is all up on my man!" I yelled back. Benny pulls me into his arms, smirks and kisses me "You ok if we make-out-? I kinda wanna see how she'll react and..." he goes to my ear "make her wish she was you. She'll maybe see that she makes me feel nothing but- with you..." he whispered the last part, very seductively and moaned at the end of his sentence. I felt myself get bright red "Benjamin!" He smirks "sooooo, is that a no-?" I rolled my eyes and started to walk away. I slowly opened my eyes, I sat up a bit and jumped to see someone's bare back. I went calm after I realized it was Benny and remembered we took a nap once we got to his place after school. I kissed the back off his neck, looked out of the window and saw that it was slowly going dark outside. I got out of bed and went into the bathroom. After I was done in the bathroom, I shut off the light- only for me to see Benny slowly sit up. "I'm sorry, did I wake you Benny?" He softly smiles and shakes his head "no, I've been awake for awhile now". I got back in bed "why?" "Nightmares are comin' back" he said as he grabs me and lays his head on my chest. I ran my nails, lightly, up and down his back. "God, your acrylic nails feel so nice" he sighed. I giggled "what was this nightmare about?". He wraps his arms around me "that big ass dog coming for me again, except, the dog was alot more freaky lookin' in my dream". I laughed "oh Ben, you did hop that dog's owner's fence. It was just trying to protect his family". I moved my hands up and started to softly scratch his head, also playing with his hair. He smiles "god, I'm in love with you" I smiled. He chuckles "what are you-" I squealed a little to him flipping us over so now, I was sitting in his lap. "You could've given me a heads up" "sorry". He moved my face a little closer to his. Benny looks into my eyes "I'm so happy you're my girl" I smiled and rolled my eyes. He puts a hand on my cheek, making me look at him again "I'm serious- I'm so lucky that you are still by my side after all these years but, I'm more lucky that I- finally- asked you to be mine, even if that was sophomore year" I smiled as I had tears in my eyes and cupped his face "Benny-". "Doll- are you tearing up?" I giggled as tears came down "oh doll... I didn't mean to make you cry-". He wipes my tears away "I-its ok- their happy ones" I smiled, He chuckles "still-" "I love you Benny" "I love you too" he smiled as he moved his face closer to mine and kisses my lips. The kiss turned into a makeout session, I feel Benny's lips form into a smirk and him puting his hands on my ass very gently. I took my lips off of his and looked at him "what was the smirk for-?" He bit his lip and chuckled "you felt me smirking? And because- NOW you make-out with me" I rolled my eyes, playfully smacked his chest and got off of him. He grabs me and placed me on top of him again "I'm teasing you babe" "I know and, if you're gonna be cocky like that i-" he rolls his eyes and chuckles, shuting me up. He pulls me closer to his face with his finger "babe-". He goes to my ear, quietly chuckles "we should do that again" and kisses below my ear, making shivers go down my spine. He gets on top of me, puts his hands on my hips. I watched him scan every inch of me with his eyes. I felt myself go red. He sees my face and smiles "what? I can't look at my girl's beauty?" "B-Benny-". His face goes concerned "wait- I'm I making you uncomfortable babe-?" I shook my head "n-no! Not at all!". He puts his hand on my cheek "you promise?" I nodded "I swear but you are making me kinda um..-" he stops me with him smirking. "I'm making you what, doll?" "I- um....". ●gEtS SmUtTy HeRe So, ThIs Is ThE WaRnInG ⚠️● He kisses my neck and a light moan left my lips. He immediately goes back and looks at me like 'Did- did you just moan?' . I slapped my hand over my mouth "i-im so sorry, i- I think I better g-" he takes my hand away from my lips, grabs my sides gently and moves his face closer to mine. "Don't apologize, it's ok" "i-im so embarr-" he lightly squeezed my side "seriously babe, it's ok". He looks into my eyes, making my heart go crazy. He moves his face closer to mine, puts his lips to my ear and whispers: "doll, did i... are you-?" Before he could finish his sentence, I knew what he was gonna say. I looked the opposite direction "i-i I'm sorry" he pushes my face to look at him "babe-". He lifts my face up, making eye contact with me "can I help you?" I hear Benny say as he puts his hands on my hips. "I- I don't wanna force you into anything you don't wanna-" "baby- I'm ready when ever you are and if you're not quite ready, that's ok". I took a deep breath, nodded and looked at him "be gentle with me. Th-this will be my first time and-" "don't worry doll, this will be my first time too". "Do you have...protection?" He opens his bedside table, pulls out a condom and puts it ontop of the table "You sure you're ready?" I nodded. He pulls me into a kiss but,quickly, it became another make-out session. He slowly goes to my neck and gives many kisses. Those turned into him giving me light hickeys which, made me slip another moan out. I arched my back a little and put my hand over my mouth "babe-" "i-" he pulls my chin a little to look at him "I wanna hear you" he whispered in my ear as he moved my hand away. He puts his hands underneath my shirt, stops and looks at me "can i-?" I nodded "yes". He takes off my shirt and stares at me, well- my body for a while. "B-benny" I covered my stomach and saw Benny's face change. "Babe just- stop covering. I know you feel concess about your stomach but-" he smiles, starts kissing my collarbone and worked his way down. "Benny.." he smiles "you, you're beautiful. Everything about you is beautiful. You're perfect" he keeps going down "b-baby" I moaned. He chuckles, grab the waistband of my leggings and looked at me. I nodded and he pulled them off. He kisses my thighs "I love you and everything about you" he groaned, I tilted my head back. He gently squeezed the inside of my thigh, getting my attention. He comes face to face with me "babe, can- can i-?" he lays next to me and puts his pinky on the top of my underwear. "Yes" he nodded and took my underwear off. He moved his hand down and slowly started rubbing my clit. "Fuck-" I sighed "come closer~" he said as he wrapped his other arm around my back and pulled me to his side. Without any warning, I feel him put two fingers inside of me "shit!". I gasped "I'm sorry doll, am I going to fa-?" "N-no, just...took me by s-surprise" he nodded and kept going "i love you baby" "i love you too Benny" . He grabs one of my hands "c-can you help me with...my problem?" I look down and see that he has a boner, I nodded. I sat down on his lap and traced his upper body, mostly his abs. "B-babe" Benny started but then stopped, due to me slowly starting to grind on him "god damn" he groaned and put his hands on my ass. "Fuck baby~" he groans and slowly lays his head back. I felt his bulge get bigger and got off him. I grabbed the top of his pants and looked at him, asking for permission. He smirks "go head" I took off his pants. He flips us over and started to make-out with me again. He takes off his boxers, i saw his member and how....big it was "s-shit" I whispered. He smirks and kisses my neck "it's not nice to stare babe" I looked at him "i-im sorry but, c-can you b-blame m-me? Y-your-". He bit his lip "I'm what, my dear?" Shivers went down my spine "b-big". He grabs my love handles "you ready-?" I took a deep breath "yeah just- go easy on me" he kisses my lips "don't worry doll, I promise". He puts the condom on and slowly puts it in. I groaned in pain for a second. Benny's face shot up "you ok-?" "Y-yeah just, hurts a little" "tell me if it's too much, ok?" I nodded. He started thrusting slowly. He looks at me "baby-" "i-its ok, it's gonna hurt for a couple of seconds" he cupped my cheek and kissed my lips, so every sweetly. I moaned in pleasure once the pain went away. "Feeling better?" Benny asked. I bit my lip and looked up "y-yeah". Benny giggled "can I go faster?" "Yes" Benny started going a little faster "oh, fuck Benny" I moaned. Benny's grip on my love handles tightened a bit "shit doll..." he grunted. He started going faster "b-benny" he looks at me and pecked my lips "I fucking love you- so God damn much" he moaned the last part. I whimpered as I started to feel my climax "babe I'm- c-close" "Me too doll, just hold it for a little longer baby" I cupped his cheek and kissed him. "Benny i don't...think I can h-hold it a-any-" he stopped me "I'm almost there, ready?" I nodded "go ahead then doll". Once we hit our climax, we were a panting, sweaty mess. Benny pulls out and throws away the condom. I started breathing heavily. Benny gets under the covers "come here" he said with open arms. I moved into his arms "i love you Y/n" "i love you too Benny". All of a sudden, we hear the front door being opened "just in time" Benny chuckled.

(Oh my god, I'm so sorry that this was so FREAKING long! Also!! If you have any requests on what I should write next, lmk!! I'm running out of ideas😅)