(The next morning, 9:00 am)
As you begin to wake up, you feel Erik rubbing your back softly. You rolled over to see him smiling at you. "Good morning baby" you whispered sleepily. You start to remember what Lyle did last night. Did he come home last night? What if he stayed with Heather? Erik snapped you out of your thoughts. "Are you hungry?" you asked as he got out of bed and stretched. "A little bit, are you?" he asked as he put on grey sweatpants. "I'll make us something" you said as you blushed. You put on one of Erik's oversized t-shirts on and head downstairs.
You start to make breakfast as Erik sits on the barstool at the counter. "Do you know if Lyle came home last night?" you asked him as you frowned. He looked at you confused. "I'm not sure, I don't remember hearing him come in. "I'll go look upstairs." you said as you sighed heavily. You start to walk upstairs to Lyle's room and open his door. You sighed in relief as you see him stretched out on his bed sleeping and snoring.
You kick the side of his bed a few times before he wakes up. "Hey, wake up" you said as you shook him. "What's wrong?" he asked sleepily as he rubbed his eyes. "You have fun last night?" you said sternly as you turned on his light. "Look i'm sorry about Heather she just-" Lyle tried to explain as you interrupted him. "Just what Lyle? She used you for your money and cheated on you!" you said as he got out of bed standing over you. "I know that y/n!" Lyle said annoyed that you woke him up like this.
"I saw you guys kiss." you admitted as you looked straight into his eyes. "I don't know what to say or think y/n okay?! we were drinking!" he yelled. Erik heard him yell from downstairs and he quickly ran upstairs to Lyle's room. "It doesn't matter Lyle! And then you were mean when I asked for the keys!" you yelled back at him. Erik entered the room.
"Hey! what's going on?" Erik said as he looked back and fourth at you and Lyle. "I want to know what happened with Heather last night, and he's not saying shit!" you yelled as you looked at Erik. "Okay both of you need to calm down." Erik said. "And you" he said getting in Lyle's face "Don't talk to my girlfriend like that, you got it?" Erik said sternly. "Your girlfriend or ours? If I remember correctly, she was screaming around my dick the other day, so I think she's OUR girlfriend" Lyle said getting in Erik's face too. Erik pushed him against the wall before you got in the middle.
"Just stop! look Lyle, do whatever you want, be with her" you said rolling your eyes as you grabbed Erik's hand and walked back downstairs. "I don't want to eat anymore" you said as you opened the side sliding door and slammed it shut. Erik sighed and ran after you. He sat next to you and put his arm around you. "I don't know what's going on with him, I didn't think they would get back together." Erik said as he looked down. "We don't know if they're together, but I don't know why he would even talk to her" you replied.
"Me either, let's just get out of here and go get breakfast" Erik said looking at you and smiled. You both go inside. Lyle was in the kitchen. You just walked past him and went upstairs. He sighed heavily and went outside. You and Erik get ready and leave to go eat.
(6:00 pm)
You and Erik were upstairs watching a movie in bed. You sigh and rub your eyes. "What's wrong baby?" Erik asked. "I don't know what to do about Lyle" you said. "Me either, I don't know why he's acting like that." Erik replied. "Should we go talk to him?" you asked as you looked over at him. "Let's go" Erik said as he got up out of bed and stretched. You sighed nervously as you followed Erik down the stairs.
You walk down the stairs to find Lyle sitting outside by himself smoking a cigarette. You slowly open the door. "Can we talk?" you ask quietly. "Sure" Lyle replied looking up at you. "Look before you say anything, I just wanted to say i'm sorry for how I talked to you. I shouldn't have." Lyle said as he looked at you with puppy dog eyes. "I forgive you, but I still don't know why you entertain Heather like that." you said as you looked down. "I don't know either, but I promise you, that was the last time. If she tries to talk to me or whatever, i'll just ignore her, okay baby?" Lyle said putting his hands around your waist.
"Okay. I just don't want you to get hurt again, that's all." you said smiling at him. "I know. And i'm sorry to you too, Erik, I shouldn't have yelled at you either." Lyle said. "Don't worry about it, you'll always be my brother." Erik smiled. "But, we did forget one thing." Lyle said looking at you. "What?" you asked as you smiled nervously. "If I remember correctly, you rolled your eyes and had an attitude to me too. And then you teased me when you sat on Erik's lap, knowing I could see you." Lyle said as he scooted closer to you, as did Erik. "Is that true baby girl?" Erik growled in your ear. You squirm nervously in your chair.
"Y-Yes but, you" you started to explain until Erik cut you off. "No but's babe. You know the rules." Lyle said as they both stood up and you looked up at both of them. "Stand up." Lyle commanded and you jumped up as he said. You start breathing heavier. Lyle quickly grabs your neck with his big hand, making you stand on your tip toes. "You don't roll your eyes at us." He grabbed your hand and led you inside.
They brought you into the den and Erik and Lyle sat down on the couch. "Come here" Erik said. You nervously walk over to them and Erik quickly grabs your waist, turns you around, and bends you over his lap. He pulls up his shirt that you're wearing. "Mmm, fuck." Lyle says as he looks over at you, softly rubbing your ass. You hear Erik sigh heavily.
You suddenly feel his big hand come down on your ass hard. You arch your back. They both take turns spanking you. "Good fucking girl" Erik said as he stood you up and laid you down on the couch. He took his big hands and massaged down your back, on your ass, and down to the back of your thighs, causing goosebumps all over your body.
"Arch that ass up bitch" Lyle said as he slapped your ass hard. You arch your back and feel him kneel behind you. You feel two long fingers enter your pussy and start pounding in and out of you. You throw your head back and moan loudly. "Shut her up" Lyle commands. Erik walks in front of you and roughly shoves his cock in your mouth. You moan around his cock as Lyle's fingers move faster and faster, in and out of you, making you closer and closer to coming.
He feels you tightening around him. "Don't you even fucking think about it" Lyle said as he removed his fingers. Erik takes his cock out of your mouth as you look up at him. He bites his lip as you look him in the eyes. "Fuck baby" he says as he chokes you and kisses you. "Turn over for him baby" Erik says. You quickly roll over onto your back as Lyle strokes himself, already rock hard. He spreads your legs open with his hands. He taps the tip of his cock on your clit a few times, making you jump.
"Please daddy, please" you whined as he rubbed the tip on your entrance. He slammed into you quickly, going as deep as he can. He starts thrusting hard as he grips your hips. "Fuuuuck daddyyyy" you moaned loudly as you looked at Erik. He put his cock in your mouth again and started pumping in and out, going deeper and deeper into your mouth, making his tip hit the back of your throat, causing you to gag. "That's it baby, fucking choke on my dick" Erik moaned as he threw his head back. "Mmm, i'm gonna cum baby" Erik growled. You nodded your head at him. A few more pumps into your mouth and he spills into your mouth. You swallow it all as he breathes heavily.
Lyle threw your right leg over his shoulder as he went harder and faster. You moan loudly as Erik chokes you. "Can I please cum?!" you said desperately, not being able to handle Lyle anymore. He kept fucking you hard as he felt you tighten around his cock. "I'm gonna cum, cum with me you little fucking bitch" Lyle growled into your ear as he quickly spilled into you, you came all over his cock as you both moaned loudly.
Lyle pulled out of you and his cum ran down your legs. "Fuck baby, you feel so good" Lyle said as he kissed you. Erik kissed you after. "Let's get cleaned up." Erik said picking you up and wrapping you around his waist. They brought you upstairs and you all took a shower, made dinner, and then cuddled until you fell asleep in Lyle's room together.
YOU ARE READING
Could we share?
FanfictionYou & Erik are dating, but something deep down really turns you on about Lyle, what is it? Will Erik find out? What will he think? What will happen?