ℐ𝓈𝓈𝓊ℯ𝓈 ✔︎

4

Heavily edited and added

"I can't believe you! You lied!" Jack yelled. He and Toby were having their first fight, and yeah, they had minor arguments before, but this time Jack had a point to be fighting about this, Jack hadnt heard from Toby for two days until just this morning.

"I didn't lie!"

"Yes, you did! And nothing's okay! You said The Slenderman had you out for a few hours!"

"I know, and I'm sorry."

Jack wanted to hit something, so he walked past Toby and punched the wall by their bed, even though Toby was used to this from what he's heard from Jeff. He hadn't seen this from Jack, and he flinched.

"Slenderman probably tested us, Jack." Toby said quietly, but loud enough for Jack to hear

"I would like to believe it, really I do. But you know what, Toby, I don't. You know why?"

Toby looked at him. He didn't say anything because he did know why. He knew why, but it would hurt him to say it out loud because to him, it wasn't true.

"Say it if you do. say it!"

"You don't trust me! I know!" Toby yelled. He never yelled. Jack was surprised to hear him yell, but he didn't say anything after that. He just walked out of the room, and he needed to take a walk.

"I had Toby gone for two days for a reason, Jack. It wasn't his fault."

"If it wasn't his fault, then why did you make him do it! I was fucking worried about him!" Jack exclaimed.

"Jack, I had to see if you trusted Toby."

"Well you did a pretty good job at it. You made me yell and think that I couldn't trust Toby! You leave us alone Slenderman! Or I'll take him away!" Jack said and walked out of the cabin, heading back to his own.

When he got back, he saw that Toby was still there when he entered his room, sitting on the window sill, but facing the other way.

"Jack..."

Jack looked at Toby, his back facing him. Yes, he forgives Toby, but he's still questioning himself.

"What."

"I know you forgive me, but do you? Do you really?"

Jack sighs and turns to him. "Toby, you know I've been questioning that for the past hour and you know fucking what? I - I don't give a fuck anymore."

"What does that mean?"

"It means fuck it, and I trust you, I always have until earlier today, fucking Slenderman messing with me because he wants to see me miserable." Jack said, "But you know what, fuck him, fuck everyone! It's just you and me!"

Toby blushed and Jack embraced Toby and kissed his face repeatedly.

"Promise me you won't hurt me?"

"I won't ever dare."