Murderer

Chapter 4

Noah, John, Ben, and Justin all begin to consult with one another about what they discovered.
"We found a note under a chest that George kicked." Said Noah. "It said, Hey Ashley, meet me by the banister. I just might help you win this thing.
"Well we found she had some broken bones, a bump on her head, and a huge gash under her arm." Said Ben. "The fall didn't kill her....... It was the gash." John and Justin report that they found a knife at the crime scene. That supported the gash theory.

The other contestants all have the same theories about how Ashley died.

The contestants are shuffled into the dining room where one by one they are called away to do a statement about how the killer committed the crime. It goes something like this. "First, you snuck into Ashley's room and placed the note in plain sight. When Ashley realized the note was there she immediately proceeded to the banister where she waited for you to show. When you finally did show, you would have probably engaged in small talk. Soon, Ashley became impatient and asked about the note. You then proceeded to quickly lift up her arm and slice the underside of her arm. And then pushed her over the side of the bannister. She screamed. Quickly you hid the knife and while everyone was so shocked about her death, you snuck back up into her room and hid the note under the chest. And finally you participated in investigating the crime."

Some of the theories were closer than others. But soon they will find out who's spared and scared.