Fairy Tail One Shots!

Two Loves are Better Than One AU (Jellal x Reader x Mystogan)

How can you tell identical twins apart? If Haruhi is able to tell the twins apart, which is really not that hard once she points out the difference in their voices, then so can you...

At your high school, a pair like the Hitachiin twins does actually exist!

Jellal Fernades and Mystogan are the most popular guys at (High School). They have short, dark blue hair with a unique red tattoo on one side of their faces. These two are exact carbon copies of each other. And these two even act like the Hitachiin twins, right down to their stupid game... which is conveniently called the 'Which One is Jellal?' game. How original! It didn't help how they were wearing the same school uniform. 

Another thing is how these two do not really  interact with other students. They prefer each other's company rather than socialize. Think of robots staring mindlessly into the screen of a Nintendo DS as they play Pokemon. Better yet, think of them as your everyday typical teenager staring into their cellphone, disconnecting themselves from the real world. 

Though they are anti-social, girls find them attractive. Every girl confesses to them, only to be flat-out rejected. There's that old saying that it won't be the end of the world it you get rejected. Whoever has the confidence to say that hasn't felt rejection like these poor girls. And how the mischievous twins reject them is harsh.

One day, a girl from your class asks to meet Jellal behind the school. When the bluenette arrives, the innocent girl starts pouring her heart out. However...

        "I'm sorry to say this, but I'm actually Mystogan. My brother told me to let you know he is not interested." the bluenette says. The girl looks like she was about to burst into tears. She is holding back to stay strong. 

        "Oh, I see." she meekly whispers. The bluenette places a hand onto her shoulder as she looks into his brown eyes. He smiles at her.

        "I don't understand why my brother would be so cruel to a sweet girl like you. Now that I think about it, you're pretty cute. I'd tell you what. Why don't you chose me instead? I mean, we both look alike. It wouldn't matter, right?" the bluenette asks. The girl nods her head like she receives her favorite electronic. 

        "Okay, I would love to Mystogan." the girl responds. The bluenette smirks as he looks to the pillar. 

        "Hear that, Mystogan. It seems like this one doesn't even care which one of she choses." the bluenette says as the girl is confused. Soon enough, the other half appears. The girl is baffled on what these twins were doing. Both of them smirk at how foolish this girl is.

        "I was kidding. I'm really Jellal. I just pretended to be my brother to see if you actually knew I was lying. It seems like you won't even care which one of us you would rather go out with. How disgusting!" Jellal mocks the girl. The girl's eyes widened as she figures out that she's been played.

        "And to think you were more into us because of our physical appearance. I could have taken you away from my brother, and you wouldn't care. Not like it matters anyway because you're so not our type." Mystogan further bullies the girl. She finally broke down in tears. She quickly wipes her tears and glares at them.

        "You two are disgusting! How could you play with my feelings like that?" she asks them. They both stare at her with dead expressions, not caring about her feelings whatsoever.

        "Feelings? You never truly loved us. If you did, you would have not accepted the offer when I pretended to be my brother." Jellal remarks to the girl. Her eyes widened again when she realizes how they figured her out. She weeped into the ground in defeat. The twins walk around her as they headed somewhere else. 

You heard everything that happened as the twins walked up to you. They smiled at their favorite little toy. You sigh in disappointment.

        "What am I going to do with you two? You know, you could have let down the poor girl more gently like you did to the others." you scold them. They both shrug as they walk down the hallway with you.

        "I'm surprised you would say that. According to Erza, that girl has been sleeping a lot with a lot of guys. She wanted to add us to her little collection." Jellal mentions. 

        "The girl tries to act all innocent to manipulate everyone. I'm sure once Erza blackmails the girl, she would think twice about hurting other guy's feelings. We just gave her a taste of her own medicine. Besides, why would we want any of those girls when we have you?" Mystogan asks as he takes one of your arms into his. Jellal does the same to the other. 

        "Erza doesn't blackmail. She's going to consult with the girl about her wrong doings since she is a peer mentor. You two, on the other hand, are the reason why you're going to die alone." you tell them. They smirk at how sassy you were. It's one of the things they like about you.

        "Alright then, can you guess which one of us is Jellal?" they both say in unison. They pulled away from you as they hid behind a pillar, did some switching around, and appeared before you smiling. "Now then, care to take a guess?" they said. You point to one of the twins. 

        "This one is Jellal." you say. You point to the other twin. "And this one is Mystogan." you finished. 

        "Uh-oh, you got it wrong." they said. You shake you head confidently. 

        "No. I know I'm right. You guys might be the same, but the two of you are unique in your own way." You replied. They stare at you for a few minutes before giving off one of their more precious gifts. You smiled at how they show their real selves to you and only you. "You two own me a drink. Let's go before Erza starts swinging a random pipe at us." you says as you merrily made you way back to the class. The twins follow you in tow, thinking about how you are one in a million.

Even though you find many flaws in these identical twins, you still love them. After all, two loves are better than one....