Carl x reader lemon oneshot🍋

A Hard Choice - carl x reader (lemon)

(This takes place in season 7 7th episode if you want to be specific, Sorry if some things are inaccurate)(also I'd like you to know negan auto corrected to Megan 😂)

(Elements of non consent)

Carl pov

Negan had just sent Olivia out to get some lemonade and had told me to show him around he had found Judith and shaved in the bathroom. He was talking about eating when we heard noise come from the one room he hadn't checked 'my room' " oh whoops I missed a room" he say starting to head towards it, he stops outside the door "so what's in here?" He says leaning against the wall his bat in hand "my room" I say quietly, as he goes to open the door I can't help but think of one thing 'what made that noise?' He pushes the door open and steps in me following behind.

Sitting on my bed was my girlfriend (y/n) she was laying back on my bed one of my comics in her hands, I can't help but notice she's wearing one of my flannel, she looks over as the door opens and quickly stands as she sees negan. "Well, well, well who do we have here" he says taking a few steps closer to her, I though him finding Judith was nerve racking but this is worse. He walks closer till he's face to face with her "what's your name darlin'" he says leaning close to her, (y/n) try stepping away but he just steps closer until she against the wall, I clench my fists wanting to yank him away from her "(y/n)" she says shakily "well that is a beautiful name it's fits you as you are a Beautiful young lady" he bites his lips as he looks up and down at her "man I would love to screw your brains out" (y/n) eyes widen with fear "I I I ha...have a boy...boyfriend" she stutters "oh pity who would that be?" He pouts, (y/n) shift from negan to me for a second before looking back at negan. Negan notices this and seems to catch on "oh you to" he points at (y/n) then to me then back again, we both nod. "Perfect" is all he say before leaving the room gesturing for us to follow.

We follow him back down stairs to the kitchen, when negan speaks up again "so Carl, have you popped her cherry yet?" He say swinging his bat a bit "what?" I say confused "have you fucked her yet? Played with what I'm guessing would be a nice tight pussy" he says with a straight face, I want to punch him for talking about (y/n) that way, I don't say anything and just look at the ground.

The truth is me and (y/n) have been intimate only once tho. "Oh come on tell me I'd hate to have to force the answer out" I still don't say anything "well if your not gonna tell me I'm just gonna assume not and I'll pop it myself" at this threat I speak up "we have" I say "now was that so hard, I wonder if it's as hard as you was" he laughs, he looks at (y/n) again and licks his lips. "Your one lucky guy for scoring a babe like that, now tell was it both your firsts?" Scared of what he might do if I didn't answer his questions I just decide to answer whatever question he asks 'I've got to keep (y/n) safe' "yes" I answer simply, he chuckles "you've been stuck with me for a bit I'm sure your dying for some pussy so go and have some" I look at him confused "what?" "I'm telling you to bend your little girlfriend over the counter and fuck that little pussy" I look at him angrily "no" he face shifts to one of anger "I'm not asking I'm telling, if you don't do it I will" he says seriously, my eyes widen at the threat 'no way is he touching (y/n) and I know Negan is a man of his word'.

He grabs (y/n)s arm and pulls her to the kitchen island "come 'ere" I walk over slowly. He pushed (y/n) so she's bent over the counter and then grabs me and pushes me so I'm standing behind her, I don't move. "Oh come on, either you do or I will and trust me I'd love to have a piece of that, making me hard just seeing her bent over like the, woo". I look at (y/n) wonder what to do. "What do you want girly, me or Carl" he says getting impatient. I could hear her swallow before speaking "I'd much rather it be you then him" she says holding hard eyes contact with me the whole time. I sigh and turn to her not sure what to do, negan seems to sense my confusion on what to do "come on you know how trouser work reach around her unbutton and unzip her trouser pull them and her panties down, then undo your belt undo your trouser pull them and your boxers then shove your dick in easy, you sure you done this before" he says shamelessly standing a few feet away watching us. I start doing what he says.

My hands shaking I start undoing (y/n)s leather trousers, I lean down to her ear and whisper "I'm sorry" quietly "it's okay I'd much prefer it be you then him" she replies back. I slowly start pulling her trouser down just enough so her butt is exposed still covered by her panties which were Lacy and kinda sexy, the only reason she wears these is it's all we could find. "Wow look at those sexy things now I really want a piece" negan comments. I stop and turn my attention to my belt and undo it and unzip and unbutton my trouser. I pause there embarrassed at the thought of negan seeing my member "come on your not embarrassed of me seeing your cock are you, it not small is it? come on I'm a man to you know" I swallow and suck it up and low my boxer so my member comes out, I glance over at negan quickly to see if he's still watching, which he is. I finally realise there no way around this, so I lower (y/n) panties as little as possible. I push my members head against her and feel she isn't very wet and since this is only are second time it's probably gonna hurt a lot, I hesitate again so negan speaks up again "come on boy you might want to hurry up before that girl comes back with the lemonade or your dad arrives, man that would be embarrassing" I look into (y/n) she gives a barely noticeable nod. I let out a sigh and push myself in her. I can feel and see her cringe I knew she was in pain, I lean over her and moved her hair out the way and gently kiss the back of her neck trying to comfort her "it...hurt" she says quietly through gritted teeth 'I don't care what negan says I'm not moving until it stops hurting her' "come on boy pound that pussy" negan says impatient "no it's hurting her" I say angrily at the fact he doesn't seem to care I'm forcing her to do this "oh ok, take your time then" he says a bit softer 'at least he has some sympathy.

I stay leant over her rubbing her shoulder and occasionally kissing her neck while I wait, at this point negan has dragged a chair over to sit on. After a bit of time waiting (y/n) whispers to me "it's stopped hurting now" I nod a little and slowly start moving. (Y/n) whimpers under me, as I try to hold my sounds cause negan was right about one thing she is tight. "Go faster" negan randomly says fiddling with his barbed wire baseball bat. I do as he says and speed up.

He continues to watch us as (y/n) whimpers and squirms under me letting out some moans. I try my best but can't stop some of my sounds escaping. Suddenly (y/n) says "I'm gonna cum" I think she was trying to say it quiet enough so negan wouldn't hear but he heard anyway "nice make her cum, and if you cum don't do it inside her you guys are to young for kids". I continue thrusting feeling myself get closer, suddenly (y/n) tightens around me, moans a bit louder and tenses up 'she came', I quickly pull out and cum on the floor and side of the island letting out a finally moan "nice job kid, you might want to clean the up tho" negan saying getting up and going upstairs. I quickly stuff myself back in my pants and pull (y/n) trousers and panties back up doing them back up then doing my trouser up and redoing my belt. (Y/n) shakily pushes herself off the counter and almost falls but I catch her in time and place her on the sofa. Once she's ok go back to the kitchen and gather stuff to clean the cum, when Olivia comes back in.

"What happened?" She says coming into the kitchen seeing the sticky white substance on the ground "I'll explain later" she just nods and starts making the lemonade and I start cleaning the cum up. Negan comes back down stairs with Judith and giver her to Olivia "let's make some spaghetti".

I know negan was kinda out of character but whatever.