Caught between two (Stu Macher x Y/N x Billy Loomis)

ᴄʜᴀᴘᴛᴇʀ 2

lil smexy stuff nothin intense-

The next day at school you head in as fast as you can for biology that afternoon. For some reason  you suddenly liked having friends, even if you had to leave them soon. You walk up Stu and smile. "Hey" He says waving his eyes on Billy. The smile on your face slowly melts away. "I don't know what you see in him." You start. "He's a jerk ass bastard."  You finish. "Not if you've known him for as long as I have." He rebuttals. You shake your head. "Still, it isn't fair for him to treat some people fairly and others poorly. I saw what he did to that poor kid." You argue on. He rolls his eyes as if there was nothing bad about what you were doing. He rests his head on his hand and continues to gaze at billy. 

"Hey!" You snap as Stu's eyes widen. "What? What is it?" You yell. Suddenly you feel the smoothness of Billy's arms on your waist. You squeak. "Calm down, you were just about to fall onto of Stu if I didn't catch you." He says and removes his arms. For some reason you wish they were still on you. You quickly push the thought away from your mind. "No no no! He's a bastard shut up!" You mean to scream in your mind but accidentally whisper it out loud. Billy leans in toward your ear and puts his hands back onto your waist. "Who's a bastard hmm?" He whispers into your ear grinning. Your cheeks heat up. "I didn't mean to say that aloud." You mumble, his hands still on your waist. You slowly push his hands away from your body. "You're really touchy for someone I just met." you murmur. His smile doesn't go away, it just becomes more sinister by the minute. "Oh, am I? I hadn't noticed." He says and backs away putting his hands in the air. 

Stu Gets a bit jealous I can tell. "Well, he does that to almost every hot girl he finds. It's how he got Sidney." Stu yaps under his breath. "Oh so you do have a girlfriend. Thought so." You ask Billy. "How did you know?" He asks wearing a serious poker face. "Do you think I'm hot?" he asks grinning a wicked grin. You shake your head almost immediately. You did it so fast that it was obviously a lie. He laughs as you roll your eyes. "Fine."  You admit. "You are hot, doesn't mean I like you." You lie. No, no. That wasn't a lie, it couldn't have been. You hate him. Stu sticks out his tongue at Billy as you finish that sentence. 

"You guys are so childish." You groan. "Correction: I'm childish, Billy is . . . what's the word? Adult-ish? Sexual!" Stu snorts dramatically. Billy smiles a flirty smile. You can't help but smile a little bit too. Billy and Stu are the perfect match, you would never want to get between that. You grab Stu's arms and drag him to the corner of the room and Billy lets out a teasing 'Ooh~' You and Stu both ignore it. "Yes?" Stu asks sticking out his tongue. "I'm gonna help you get Billy." You whisper. Stu's once goofy face has disappeared and he now wears a shocked look: Eyes wide open, jaw dropped to the ground, cheeks all flustered and red. You smile, but the happy effect soon wears off when Stu has a little frown creep onto his face. "But that's illegal. Plus he's already head over heels for y-" He starts as Billy gallops in and slaps his ass. A joke you presume. "You were saying?" You question him with a teasing tone as that shit eating smile slowly fades back onto your face. 

"Say, wanna come over to my house tonight?" Stu asks. "We can watch horror movies . . . and stuff." He says doing a little dance. "Gladly. Invite Billy." You respond."

"Oh, well we have to rent a movie from Blockbusters first, he'll be there for sure. I'll invite him then" He remarks. You nudge him lightly. "Sure you will." You respond grinning.

---------At Blockbusters 😩

You push open the doors of the store to spot Stu talking to Billy. He's doing it! Yes! you think to yourself. But for some reason you have some weird feeling of sadness or jealousy coming within you. You push the feeling away and walk up to Randy. "Hi, any good horror movie suggestions?" You ask. "Ah, your the new girl from our school right? 'The Quiet (gender)' always a good role to play." He blabs. "I don't 'play' anything." You snap back. "Okay, okay. Jeez. What's your favourite scary movie?" He interrogates. "Halloween, I guess" You shrug. "Then you'll like 'Primal Fear' for sure." You nod your head. "Thanks." You respond walking up to Billy and Stu.