This Side Of Paradise

Frat boy Eren x shy reader headcanons!!

This was requested by my online big sister and the person who gives me the best advice, maialawliet!

I hope you like this and if I made any mistakes, just tell me :)

(This was my first request ever and I'm so excited to see what you thinkkk~)

Attack on Titan (AOT)

How you met
You probably first met when he called you a GDI or when he got into a fight (with Jean, of course).

He seemed kind of spoiled to you at first and way too out-going so you naturally avoided him.

He made the first move and talked to you.

He was so loud at first, all like, "Sup you! Wanna grab some coffee?"

He most likely didn't learn your name till 2 weeks after.

You instantly got introduced to his friends and he speaks about them a lot (mainly Armin and he shit talks Mikasa but beats up anyone else who does it)

When you two got closer
Probably got into a fight and got badly injured. You helped him and decided to spend less time with him cause you imagined him being a troublemaker but quickly apologized after you learned why he was fighting (imagine it's a good reason).

You oftenly spend time with him and his friends though it's whenever he drags you around with him.

He doesn't cause fights when you're around.

He gave you the task of being his tutor (he cheats off you fr)

You never eat lunch alone when he's around or get bullied (mainly cause Mikasa is always watching).

You regularly go out on friendly dates.

(I feel like he'd game a lot, especially till morning so he'd just have you on late night calls with him till either of you fell asleep).

When feelings started developing
Gonna say you caught feelings first.

Eren has trouble expressing his emotions so he did have a crush on you but didn't know.

He makes it way too obvious that even Mikasa is sick of it.

Armin, Jean and Connie helps him with love advice cause they're 'experts'. (Really, Armin is the only one who actually gives sensible advice). Sometimes, these advices makes him do some crazy stuff that embarrasses you.

You get advice from Mikasa and Hange (Hange is surprisingly good at it. Mikasa's advices are...interesting to say the least.)

He asked you on a date first after you caught him and Armin 'confessing' to each other. (Jean and Connie thought it would be a good idea to put Armin in a school girl uniform and have Eren practice his confession on him).

Confession happened at least 3 months after going out on random dates.

When dating
Good God, he let's the entire world know.

You probably joined his 'sorority'.

He taught you how to fight.

His grades actually improved cause he wanted to make you proud.

He does not like PDA but wears your shirts in public and gets embarrassed when someone points it out.

He refuses to meet your parents but you pranked him once and had him talk to your parents. Eren actually gets along with them both.

He's one of those boyfriends who acts way too tough but melts as soon as you touch him.

He's good at boiling water and eggs so you get eggs anytime you have sleepovers.

He arrives at your house at 5 am and waits for you. (Even though you wake at 7)

*phone call* "Y/N, how do I add fractions?"

*you explain*

*2 minutes later* "Y/N, page 56 was the correct page for the homework right?*

Expect phone calls every second of the day.

He doesn't drive to school anymore cause he'd rather walk and enjoy his time with you. (and because it makes you feel uncomfortable with the eyes that watch you when you exit his car)

He can tell when you're down or in pain and does everything he can to make you feel better.

What is with him and couples challenges?

He tried to make you drink beer once when him, himself had no clue how to drink it and fainted after downing a whole bottle.

Your relationship: Pet master/pet.

When you two fight
To be very honest, Eren is a simp so you two rarely get into fights.

When you do though, he never apologizes first cause of his pride.

You can go days without speaking to him but his limit is maybe a couple hours to 3 days.

He always folds first and shows up at your door with your favorite stuff.

"We should keep the past in the past bae, it won't kill us~" he comes up with some very cringey ways to speak and that makes you laugh everytime.

Eventually you both apologize (using either words, letters or by servicing each other).

Fun facts
Servicing you is definitely his love language.

He sleeps with one of your shirts on his pillow case (ik it's supposed to be the other way around but he reminds me of a little puppy).

He smells like you as always.

As I said previously, he's a big simp so don't be surprised if he has a shirt with your name on it.

You both have matching shirts that says, "If Lost, Give Me To Them," and "If Found, Give Him To Me."

He loves playing with your hair so much. (If you don't have any, he just loves touching you.)

He knows you like the back of his hand.

He has regular fantasies of marrying you.

Whenever he has a bad day and sees you, his eyes sparkle and you see a huge grin on his face.

He can never stay too far from you.

His teachers moved him from beside you because he continuously stared at you during classes.

He likes teasing you because you always get flustered easily or hide your face in your hands.

You got used to him and his antics so much that you picked up some of his confidence and ways of thinking. (Surprised him once when you talked back to one of his sorority members for saying something mean about Mikasa and Armin.)

Oh man, I'm writing way too much-- I'll just leave this here and make a part two if requested!

-1048 words