Torn (A Matt Sturniolo x Reader story)

Choose

Y/n's Pov:

I was lost for words.. Matt just said that he loved me

What do I say to that....

I looked over at Chris and he was shocked

It was silent for a while until Nick walked into the room oblivious to what was happening

"Okay.. What the fuck is going on?"

"Nick... did you not hear Matt" Chris said quietly

"No? Why? What did he say?" Nick asked confused

"I said I loved Y/n" Matt spoke up

Nick's mouth dropped open

We all looked up at him and noticed his facial expression change into a quite frustrated one then he looked over at Chris and said "Chris come here"

Chris got up slowly and walked over to where Matt and Nick where standing a bit confused

Nick then turned to me "Y/n.. You have to choose"

Me being the stupid person I am asked "Choose what?"

"A person Y/n. You have to choose who you like. Matt or Chris"

I went silent again and thought 'How can he make me choose between brothers'

I got scared out of my thought by Nick raising his voice a little "Choose Y/n!"

"I-I can't.. I'm Torn"

Chris spoke up after him and Matt being quiet for a while "Y/n choose Matt.. I see the way you look at each other I know you like him"

"Oh Chris.." I got up and hugged him and whispered "Thank you" he whispered back "I love you bestie" I pulled away from the hug and smiled at Chris then turned to Matt

"Matt it's you it's always been you" He looked up at me and smiled and ran towards me and hugged me I hugged him back

Matt's Pov:

I did it. I told Y/n. I told her I loved her.. all I needed now was a reaction or something.. anything

She went silent for a while until Nick stormed in and told her to choose between me and Chris

I was so nervous for her answer I think I was more nervous than her and I wasn't even the one making the decision

I was in a world of my own so I wasn't really listening when I saw her go over to Chris and hugged him I put my head down. I thought well I guess that's it. It's Chris

Until I heard Chris say "I love you bestie"

She pulled away and smiled then turned to me and said "Matt it's you it's always been you" I looked up at her and I ran towards her and hugged her and she hugged me back

I thought 'The girl of my dreams is sort of mine' Yes sort of we are not official but it's a start that she chooses me

I smiled into her shoulder as she wrapped her arms around my neck

We eventually pulled apart and noticed Nick and Chris had gone I just shrugged and said

"How long were we hugging" Y/n just laughed

I just suddenly blurted out "You wanna go on a date with me?"

Y/n looked at me

I thought 'Great you've ruined it already Matt good going'

She suddenly jumped into my arms and wrapped her legs around my waist with her arms around my neck and said "I would love to"

I smiled and kissed her nose and she giggled

"When?"

"Tomorrow.. you are mine for the day"

She laughed and said "I guess I'm stuck with you all day"

I laughed with her and said "Yep" popping the p

"Well it's late we better get to bed" she said

I smirked "We?"

She blushed then got out of my arms while saying "Fine I'll go with Nick"

I grabbed her by the waist and picked her up before she walked out of the door and started walking to my room while saying "Oh no you don't your staying with me"

She laughed and said "Okayy"

We got to the bed and I put her down gently and then lay down next to her I felt her wrap her arm around my waist and I put my arm around her and we stayed like that all night

Before I went to sleep I thought 'This girl will be mine'