By The Horns (Yandere Cheating Girlfriend x Male Alistar Reader)

Chapter 3: Nightmares

The Same Day:

Lucy's POV:

Lucy: Yes, Carlos?

Carlos: Hey, Lucy, i thought since you are single now...would you like to go on a date with me?

Lucy: Why not? You are the one who opened my eyes, for me to get rid of that cheating motherfucking horse shit.

Carlos: How about i pick you up at 8?

Lucy: sounds good. See ya later.

Carlos: See ya. 

The whole day i was thinking of how (Y/N) bled on the floor. It made me happy knowing that i'm getting a revenge on him. I started getting ready for the date with Carlos. I have to admit he's a lot better than that little bitch (Y/N).

Lucy: Guess i'll just wear a skirt and a shirt.

TIMESKIP:

After their date, they went back to Lucy's house. She and (Y/N) used to live together. Lucy and Carlos where going wild in the bedroom, busy taking each other's virginities. After an hour of wild fucking, they colapsed on the bad panting.

Carlos: That was...wow.

Lucy: I know, you were like a wild animal in heat.

Carlos kissed Lucy on the lips and then they drifted off to sleep.
After a few hours Lucy woke up. She felt thirsty so she decided to go and get some water.
While she was drinking she saw (Y/N)'s phone under the couch. She hasn't noticed it until now.

Lucy: I still can't get his stench out of here.

She picked up the phone and decided to see the messages with the girl he was cheating with.
When Lucy turned on the phone it started playing a video of (Y/N) recording Carlos setting up (Y/N)'s cheating. Lucy was pale when she finished watching it. She knew that her lover told her the truth and Carlos made her do something horrible to him. She got furious. Lucy grabbed a glass of water and put some sleeping pills inside and went back to the bedroom. She woke up Carlos and started talking to him.

Lucy: Babe, I can't sleep.

Carlos: Why? What's wrong?

Lucy: I keep thinking about (Y/N).

Carlos: Why? That fucker cheated on you.

Lucy's mind: If you say something about my (Y/N) again i will make you feel unimaginable pain.

Lucy: Can you come with me?

Carlos: Umm...ok?

Lucy: But first, are you thirsty?

Carlos: Kinda.

Lucy: Here.

Lucy handed the drugged water to Carlos. He drank the whole thing and blacked out.
Then she dragged him into her basement where she tied him to a chair.
When he woke up he was confused as hell.

Carlos: Babe, why am i tied up?

Lucy: Don't you know? I know that you lied to me.

Carlos: What?

Lucy: Don't pretend you don't know. (Y/N) recorded how you talked to your crew about these.

She threw the photos and the camera in front of him,

Carlos: Do you still think about that garbage piece of human tra-

She punched him in the gut.

Lucy: Don't you dare talk about my Darling this way.

Lucy took out instruments and placed them on the table next to Carlos. He was panting and crying in fear.

Lucy: Let's have some fun shall we?

Lucy took out a scalpel and cutted off Carlos' left nipple. He was screaming in agony. After that she took a pair of pruning shears and cut off three of the fingers on his right hand. He kept screaming as never before. 

Carlos: PLEASE STO-

He was silenced by Lucy cutting off his tongue. Then she grabbed a hammer and smashed his knees breaking them. The last thing she had was a pair of pliers. She forced his mouth open and started pulling out his third molar teeth. 

Lucy: Wow, guess you won't be eating steak anytime soon.

Carlos didn't respond. He didn't even move. He died from too much blood loss.

Lucy: Darn it, i was just starting to have fun. Oh well.

Lucy cleaned up and went back to sleep but she couldn't, she thought she killed (Y/N). Her one loyal lover. She was having a nightmare.

Lucy's nightmare:

Lucy woke up in a dark void. She stood up and looked around but didn't see anything.

???: Why did you do it, Lucy?

Lucy turned around to see where the voice was comming from.

Lucy: (Y/N)?

(Y/N): Why did you kill me?

Lucy: I-I didn't kill you!

(Y/N): I suppose you didn't kill Carlos either.

Lucy: I thought you cheated on me i... i... i had no choice.

(Y/N): So you decide who lives and who dies? Is this why you killed Carlos too? Have i ever gave you a reason for you to think i'm cheating on you?

Lucy: Don't worry, Darling, he won't be in our way anymore. My heart needs only you.

(Y/N): Is it easier for you to kill an obsticle in your relationship? Easier than killing your boyfriend?

Lucy: You are better off not being here, seeing what i've done to him.

(Y/N): Fine, if that makes you feel better. Is Carlos better off now too?

Lucy stood in silence.

(Y/N): Careful, Lucy. You could grow to enjoy being a killer.

Lucy: I... ahh... i... i...

(Y/N): You said you loved me, and yet, you FUCKING SOLD ME AFTER NEARLY KILLING ME. Heh... talk about love. Look at me, LOOK AT WHAT YOU DID!

He showed her the scars she gave him. She was shocked.

Lucy: (Y/N), i'm so, so, so sorry.

(Y/N): That's funny. You didn't look like you were sorry when you were busy fucking Carlos. We never had a moment like that. And now i'm gone. You'll never see me again, and it's all your fault. I hope you find your supposed ''Darling'' in the future.

Lucy beagan to tear up.

(Y/N): What are you looking for, Lucy? Second chances? Well, you know me. I'll give you another chance...

(Y/N) put a gun on his head ready to shoot himself.

(Y/N): Can you save me this time?

He started pulling the trigger.

Lucy: (Y/N) NO!!!

BEEP BEEP BEEP

Lucy's alarm went off and she woke up sweating. She hugged her knees.

Lucy: What have i done? My (Y/N), my beautiful Darling, my angel. He's gone...i sold away the only person that loved me. WHY DID I BELIEVE THAT SCUM?! WHY?!

A yandere smile creeped on Lucy's face.

Lucy: Don't worry (Y/N). I'll find you. We will be together again. And this time, no one's gonna stop me.