Hayase Nagatoro x Male Reader

Chapter 4: Nipple Guessing Game

Y/N Pov

Art Club

I'm in the Art Club doing the usual before Nagatoro walks into the room.

"Hello, Senpai!" She greets.

I continue drawing and don't look at her while responding. "Good evening,". She then walks up to me and gets close to my face.

"Let's play a game," She suggests.

"I'm drawing," I tell her.

"You can draw after!" She yells while pouting. I sigh and agree, knowing I won't win this battle.

"What game is it?" I ask. 

"The nipple guessing game!" She says cheerfully.

"What?" I question, making sure I heard her correctly.

"The rules are simple. You have to guess where the other person's nipples are from over their clothes," She explains. 

She then points out her index fingers and looks at my chest. "There!" She yells while thrusting them towards my chest. 

I quickly move out of the way and question her. "What are you doing? I don't want to play this game,"

"You already agreed," She says with a grin.

"I don't care. I still don't wanna play," I respond.

She then reaches into her pockets and pulls out a handmade ticket. "Senpai, if you play, I'll give you this," She says.

"What's that?" I ask her.

"It's a you-can-ask-me-to-do-anything ticket," She replies. "Whenever I'm messing with you, you can use this; and I'll stop. Or you can make me do something crazier" She explains, flirting the last part.

I look at her while debating if I should play or not.

I can get her to easily stop messing with me whenever I want...

"Fine, I'll play," I tell her.

"That's the spirit, Senpai. That's what I wanted to hear," She says to me. 

We both stand up and get into a position to play. "I get to go first," She says.

"Okay," I respond.

"Here we go," She says while slowly moving her fingers towards my chest. Her fingers get closer and closer to where my nipples are and I tense up preparing for her to touch them, but she misses just barely.

"You miss-" I start saying before she starts rubbing around my nipples with a sadistic smile. 

"Hey stop! You got it!" I tell her. She doesn't listen and starts going even faster. I grab her hands and pull them away from me. "I told you to stop," I say to her.

She looks at me for a couple of seconds before looking down. "Sorry," She apologizes while looking embarrassed. I sigh and look at her feeling I went too far.

"It's my turn, right?" I ask, trying to change the subject. She agrees and we get into position again, just this time it's my turn.

I slowly move my fingers towards her breasts getting ready to guess where her nipples are before I see Nagatoro's face. Her face is entirely red, obviously embarrassed that I'm about to touch her breasts.

I realize what I'm doing and decide I don't want that ticket if it means I'm making her uncomfortable. I intentionally miss and she looks at me with a happy grin. 

"You suck, Senpai!" She cheers. "I guess the ticket is all mine. I wonder what I'll make you do," She says with a large smile.

I sigh and look at her with a small smile before Nagatoro's phone rings.