If I Fall, Would You Catch Me? {Sequel to Candy Coated Love} ~Laughing Jack X Reader~

Nightmares and Dreams

Laughing Jack's POV

After Y/n had left, I picked up the flower crowns she had made and studied them. The flowers mingled with each other as if in conversation. I let a small smile pass my lips as I set them back down. For a while I trained till the whole family went inside. We were lounging around when we all heard a feminine scream out in the lawn. MCP and I opened the door to see a crippled Y/n on her knees crying. We both ran out and rushed to her side. I began calling her name till she passed out in my arms. "She's unconscious."

"Let's bring her inside. Maybe Slender or EJ will know what to do." MCP replied.

I picked her up bridal style and we rushed into the house. "Slender! EJ! Come quick!" I yelled.

Both appeared in front of us and I hurriedly told them what was wrong. "Give her to us, LJ. We'll take a look at what's wrong." Slender replied.

EJ took Y/n from my arms and went downstairs into the medical room. A few minutes later Slender came upstairs. "Is Y/n alright?"

He sighed. "Y/n is still unconscious but we figured out what's wrong."

We all waited in anticipation and Slender granted the request of an answer. "Her wings were cut off. All that was left was some bone left in her back where they used to belong and lots of blood."

I couldn't believe it. I gripped the arms on the chair and I began to tremble. I ran downstairs to see Eyeless Jack putting gauze around my wife's back. I ran over and caressed her pale face. Sadness overtook my features as I stared down at her. "I'm so sorry, Y/n. If only I knew this would happen-I would then have kept you safe."

A tear trickled down my cheek and landed on her forehead. I held up the top half of her body close to mine. Her head dangled down as my tears fell onto her chest. "You can take her up to your room if you wish, Laughing Jack. I'm done with her here for now."

I nodded and picked up her body. The folds of her dirty white dress swished together as I began my tread upstairs. I opened the door to our bedroom and placed her under the covers. I began to leave when I felt something grab my claws. I turned to see Y/n weakishly clinging to my hand. "Jack?" She said barely above a whisper.

I sat on the edge of the bed, careful not to damage her further. "Yes, my lollipop. It's me."

"I'm in great pain."

"I know. I'll do everything in my power to make you feel better, my sweet."

"Jack, I think this was another part in breaking me."

Tears trickled down her face but I quickly wiped them away. "Don't cry, my sweet. I'll make everything better."

"Promise?"

"Promise. Now please get some rest. For me."

"Alright."

I took up her hand and kissed it. A small smile fell upon my wife's face as she drifted off into slumber. I watched as her chest lightly heaved up and down from her breathing. I brushed the hair out of her face and kissed her forehead before standing up. "Sleep well, my dear."

I shut the door behind me and walked back downstairs. I twiddled my claws together as I sat staring into the roaring fire. Everybody tried to comfort me but it wouldn't help. As I moped around, I had failed to notice MCP sneaking upstairs.

Mr. Creepypasta's POV

As soon as I made sure Jack wasn't paying attention, I snuck upstairs to see Y/n. She lay in her bed, blood drenching her white dress. I closed the door behind me and sat on the edge of the bed. Her eyes opened a bit to see me sitting there. "MCP? What are you doing here?"