(Y/N's PoV)
We all sat in the living room, trying to make a symmetrical circle. Guess how well that went? We eventually broke the circle and just sat wherever.
"Truth or dare, Jane?" Jeff started off without saying. Jane jumps a bit and hummed, thinking.
"Dare!" Jane shouted.
"Burn your face again!" Jeff laughed. "What?! Hell no! And plus, YOU were the one who burned not only my face but every inch of me, you jerk!" Jane snapped and the two began to wield their weapons. If it weren't for Slendy holding them back, those two would've fought and probably injured each other.
"I'm fine, Slendy! I'm calm, all right!?" She pulled away from Slendy's tendrils and took a deep breath after glaring at Jeff. "Truth or dare, Ben?" Jane asked after scanning the people in the room. "Truth!" Ben rolled his eyes and sighed out, Jane hummed whilst thinking of a question.
"Wimp!" Jeff taunted Ben and I roll my eyes. "Tsk. I don't want to get a dare where in I kill myself, you dumba-"
"What do you think of our newcomer?" Jane asked and Ben chuckled slightly, putting a hand on his chin and I gulp. "Huh...Let me find the right words! Annoying, Whiny and Dramatic." Each of his words dug under my skin as I cringed at his answer. "Gee! Thanks a lot." I furrowed my eyebrows. "Now, now, play nice you two." Prue said in a hushed tone, which was overpowed by everyone else's voices. Ben's gaze fell on me, hesitant, then he looked to Prue and pointed at her.
"Prue, Truth or dare?" Ben asked and Prue bit the inside of her cheek. "Uhm..Dare!"
"I dare you to-" Prue puts her hand up and Ben stops. "If you're gonna tell me, "I dare you to tell me who you like", don't try it man. I don't like anyone." She crossed her arms. "I was just gonna say "I dare you to impersonate Jeff here", you're quite defensive, don't you think?" Ben smirked and Prue shrugged, rolling her eyes. "Go to sleep, done." She said, her impersonation sloppy.
"Oh c'mon! That was just lazy!" I nudged her and she shrugged. "Isn't that how Jeff always is?" Jeff snaps his head at Prue. "Not true!" Jeff objected. "Oh, take the insult like a man." Jane said, crossing her arms and Jeff growls at her, trying to not kill her. Prue chuckled as she looked at me and I smile back under my mask.
"Truth or dare?" Prue pointed to Masky and Masky stammered out. "T-Truth!"
"What's your favorite day of the year?" She asked and I looked at her. "What? You think I have questions for these guys?" Prue stated and I shrugged. "You could've asked who he liked, you know?" I arched my eyebrows. "Nah. That question is so overused."
"I-I like the thirteenth of October." Masky fiddled with his fingers, looking down. "But that's her birthday." I pointed out, referring to Prue who was beside me and Masky did not reply. Masky dismissed the subject and looked to Hoodie. "Hoodie, Truth or Dare?" Masky asked, his energy rising as he leaned on Hoodie with a grin.
"Dare." Hoodie replied with no hesitation. "Sing and Dance Let It Go!" Hoodie gave a long sigh and stood up. "Let it go~ let it go~ blah blah blah blah~" Hoodie sang, lazily, as he didn't bother to put any effort in his dancing. Everyone laughed hysterically and I personally found it funny, too. "EJ, truth or dare?" Hoodie asked, grunting as he sat back down beside Masky. "Dare!"
"Don't eat kidneys for 2 days!" Hoodie said as he saw EJ grabbing a kidney from his pocket and was about to put it in his mouth. EJ freezes and looks at Hoodie then the kidney and back to the orange hooded man. "Ugh, fine!" EJ throws the kidney away and looks around. I didn't pay much attention as I exchanged jokes with Prue, silently laughing. "(C/P/N) truth or dare?" EJ asked me all of a sudden and I got startled. I hum for a bit and snap my fingers. "Truth."
"What did you tell Prue? Why do you seem close?" EJ asked and I bit the inside of my cheek. "Well, I'm her best friend!" I said, happily clinging on to Prue's arm. "I recognized her when she took her mask off and here I thought I was never going to see you!" Prue retaliates with a big bear hug and I squeak. Everyone looks at me when Prue lets me go. "What?" I asked.
"It's your turn." Jane informed and I see Jeff putting a hand on his chin as he looked at me. He must be thinking. "Sorry, I forgot." I admitted as I picked my person. "LJ truth-" I was interrupted by the man who cut a smile on his face. "So...you took your mask off?" He asked and I nod. "Yes, why?" I tilt my head and Jeff stands up to walk towards me. "Take off your mask." Jeff said, it didn't sound like a demand but rather more like a friendly request. Nevertheless, I'd rather hide it than create another scene. "No..." I grip Prue's hand and she noticed the strength of my grasp; I was uneasy. "Why not?" Jeff asked, starting to sound annoyed.
"Jeff, stop. She doesn't like you forcing her..." Prue defended and I shiver. "It's just a mask." Jeff stated and Jane scoffed. "Just leave it alone, Jeff!"
"Oh, admit it. We're all curious." Jeff rolled his eyes as he looked around as some people nodded, some shook their heads and some stayed silent. I felt my stomach churn as my heart started to pound with fear. "Please!" I stand up, raising my voice, taking no more of this nonsense. "Just...leave it be." I plead as I start to turn and walk away.
I gulp, anxiety in the midst of my mind. Would they hate me for raising my voice? They did...That's why they left me. Will these people leave me too? What if they kill me? I feel a presence behind me but before I could act, someone turns me around. I see Jeff's unrelenting eyes and I could feel his fingers start to rip my mask away. My heart stops for a second as fear fills my mind.
"No!" I screeched and I push Jeff away, burying my face with my hands and trying to replace the missing mask's presence on my face - for some reassurance. "Such...idiotic people." Insanity's voice booms in my ears and she laughs, whispering unclear words but knowing her...I knew what she wanted. She wanted me to do what was right.
"W-Why?" I stammered, beginning to list down multiple reasons they'd act so stubbornly. "Do you hate me that much? Do you hate me like they did?!" I screamed, my voice breaking as I rose my head up to their sight. I felt warm tears run down my cheeks and I start to feel my head grind as Insanity took over.
"Idiots." I could hear my own voice...but I knew it wasn't actually me speaking. Insanity takes out my knife from its holster around my thigh and flicked it towards the ceiling, admiring the blade. She glares at Jeff then the mask in his hand.
"You." She points the knife at him and at this point, I knew I couldn't do anything, I couldn't fight her. I had given up and she knows damn well that I don't have the guts to fight her. Prue stood in Insanity's way and clenched her fists, her knuckles beginning to turn white. "(C/P/N), stop this immediately!" Prue demands and Insanity lowers the knife, slowly cracking up a laugh. "You idiot!" She cackled. "It's already too late!" Insanity grabs a handful of my hair, tugging it a bit. "She's in here but I'm in control!" Insanity added and everyone starts to gather together. "What are you talking about, (C/P/N)?" Prue asked, her face looking so desperate to understand.
"Don't you get it?! She's gone! Your precious (C/P/N) is gone!" Insanity drags my hand against my face and hangs it over my mouth, making her prove the meaning of her name, and she lets out a giggle.
"It's me, Insanity!"
---------
A/N
Heyo guys and gals its me Ysa! Hope you enjoyed this chapter! I know everything is going too fast but I have an Idea for the next chapters. Till next time...
G00dby3 4nd P34c3 0u7
~★☆~ysa~♡♥~
HEYO GUYS AND GALS XD So...I'm done with this edit! Hope you enjoyed!
YOU ARE READING
Knives and Scars (CreepyPasta x Killer Reader) {EDITING IN PROGRESS}
Fanfiction(Y/N) becomes a killer known as (C/P/N) after she releases her anger out to her backstabbing parents. She goes alone and unstable until she comes across the creepypastas. She fights through pain and new relationships. Sooner than you think, she'll s...
