Like Strangers

BONUS: Alien Undercover

Some will find this cringe for sure, but I honestly don't care. I have so much fun writing these guys and making them be cute idiots together. Hope at least it makes you laugh!

---------------------------------------

The blankets felt cool against Cole's skin as the boy sat on the bed, only wearing his briefs. He stretched with a low whine and lay more comfortably, never losing sight of the door.

His boyfriend left the room a few minutes earlier to 'get ready'. Cole sighed and lazily palmed his crotch to keep up his erection. They had been making out so happily, working each other up with teasing caresses and lustful kisses. Then Jay had gone to the bathroom to prepare a 'surprise' for Cole. The boy was taking his time, though...

Cole repositioned the pillows and picked at the blanket folds. He was starting to grow irritated by the time the bedroom door clicked open.

"At last! I was thinking you'd never-" Cole's words died on his lips.

Jay stood by the threshold dressed up in a very strange outfit; a combination of a holographic jacket and very short shorts. A headpiece with three eye antennae rested atop of his head, and through the sweet brown locks on the sides, Cole spotted the tips of a pair of pointy plastic green ears. In a sort of fantasy make-up, the grassy color spread over Jay's face too.

The boy held up a fake gun with the same sort of funny appearance as him and smirked at Cole. The toy lit up with colorful beams accompanied by space-like shooting noises.

"Do you like it?" He giggled.

Cole blinked several times, dumbstruck at the sight before him. For a while he was confused. He had anticipated his boyfriend would come out with some sort of sexy attire to add fun to their lovemaking. And Jay did look sexy with his lean legs on full display and the shiny outfit, but...

Cole rubbed his mouth, covering a dorky smile. "When you said we could roleplay too... I wasn't exactly expecting that."

It wasn't news that Jay was an extra person, and he was always excited about the smallest things. After Cole told him about the conversation he'd had with Kai days ago, in which he suggested their friend and Zane roleplayed a fake first date, Jay manifested they could do something similar. No fake dates, just regular kinky acting while they went at it.

Cole could have perfectly imagined his boyfriend in a demon costume, perhaps even a cowboy or a cop. An alien, though? That didn't cross his mind for a second. Coming from a comic book nerd like him though, the choice made sense.

Jay gave a shy laugh. "Does that mean...?" He brought back his previous question.

"It means I... am impressed," Cole responded for the lack of a better statement.

He got up from the bed and pulled Jay further into the room. Cole stared at his boyfriend for a long moment, giving Jay's costume a more careful examination. Although the fabric had that the shiny look of a cheap Halloween costume, the seams looked delicately sewn and hugged Jay's body nicely. When his eyes went back up, Cole got lost in the beauty of his lover. Gosh, Jay had added glitter to the virid paint that decorated his cheeks, and even drawn little stars and planets here and there.

"You're crazy." Cole cupped Jay's head carefully and kissed his lips, trying not to ruin all that sparkly makeup. The other smiled, reassured that his idea had been welcomed. "So... are you gonna tell me what's this going to be about?"

The curve in Jay's mouth evolved into a sly grin. His usual shy behavior got replaced by a wave of confidence. The boy pushed Cole back slowly and cornered him against the bed. Cole sat down, following the unspoken order, and waited for Jay to straddle him.