I plan on writing a lemon and etc for these characters already:
Slender Man
Jeff the Killer
Ben Drowned
Eyeless jack
Ticci Toby
Masky
Hoodie
Dark link
Lost silver
Glitchy Red
Dr, Smiley
Puppeter
Jason the Toy Maker
I take recommendations for any creepypasta character EXCEPT SALLY! If you write Sally x reader in the comment section it will be deleted.