Out of Nowhere.. (Billy Loomis x m!reader x Stu Macher)

Talk Time

"Why are you pushing us away?"

The two killers had trapped y/n between them. Y/n didn't know what to do, so he pushed them back. "I-... I'm not. I just... uh..." Stu pulled him into his chest, Billy in front. "But you are. Literally. Why?" Stu asks, looking down at the smaller boy.

He pushed them away yet again. "You guys just murdered someone! I-I don't want to get involved! You guys are... are... dangerous!" Y/n exclaimed. He backed away from them. He told himself it was because he was mad. Angry at them. But he was scared...

"You... think we're going to hurt you?" Billy asks, basically reading his mind. Stu nods, standing beside Billy. "We would never..." Y/n interrupted. "I don't know that! You could... could... you could snap! A-and you could change your minds and kill me!"

Billy felt upset at that. So did Stu. Billy stalked over to y/n, backing him into a wall. He slammed his hand right beside the boy's head, looking down at him darkly. "We would never hurt you... never... you're too precious... too valuable..." He suddenly pulled him in by the waist, giving Stu time to get behind y/n. "We would never forgive ourselves if our precious little boy was hurt by our hands..." Stu cooed, caressing y/n's hair.

"Why would you think that we'd hurt you?" Billy asks, his hand going up to caress y/n's cheek. "Y-you killed an innocent man..." He said. Stu laughed. "He wasn't innocent! He touched our baby boy... and made him uncomfortable... we couldn't allow that..." Stu said, holding him tighter.

"What...?" Then he realized what he meant. The pizza guy. "But you didn't have to kill him!" Billy sighed. "We only wanted to give him a scare, but he was threatening to call the police. We couldn't have that. So we silenced him..." He said, with a psychotic grin.

"Y-you..." Y/n was speechless. "We what, doll?" Billy asks, holding him closer by the waist. "You're..." He didn't know what to say. He didn't know how to feel. Stu laughed. "He seems too stunned for words..." Billy rolled his eyes. "Clearly." He gave the smaller boy a kiss on the cheek, then pulled him into a hug. He picked y/n up and brought him to the couch, holding him close. Stu got right beside them.

"Don't leave me out!" He said, and Billy chuckled. "You big baby..." He mumbled, pulling Stu into the hug too. They all cuddled on the couch, until y/n spoke up. "You guys scare me... I don't know your true intentions. You swear to never hurt me yet you go out killing people, which makes me question if it's true or not..."

Billy sighs. "Baby, we'd never hurt you. We only killed him because he made you feel uncomfortable and unsafe. We'd never, ever, hurt you."

"Yeah, that's right. We'd never..."

"Ever... hurt our precious baby..."