When Did You Ever Love Me?

𝕐𝕠𝕦 ℍ𝕒𝕕 𝕄𝕖 𝕎𝕙𝕖𝕟 𝕐𝕠𝕦 𝕊𝕒𝕚𝕕 𝕐𝕠𝕦 𝓛𝓸𝓿𝓮𝓭 𝕄𝕖

It was March closer to April, Natalie and Jaden were a couple, calling each other everyday and involving Nagisa with all of her chaos and problems.

Natalie even made a chat where she could call with both Jaden and Nagisa, Nagisa would stare blankly in silence as Natalie tried to create a topic to start a conversation to try and make both Jaden and Nagisa to engage in it.

Sometimes Jaden would stay silent or talk to Natalie while Nagisa would sit there silently awkwardly being a third wheel for absolutely no reason.

Natalie's other classmates which were also in the friend group knew about this and would sometimes ask her questions.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A few days later Natalie logged in onto a call with Popee and Nagisa before online class started, saying how she was crying all night for a certain reason.

Natalie said how she used a computer, not just a computer but her aunt's, Natalie had told them how her aunt would come online during the evening to check on what she's been doing.

Turns out that she had found out the Natalie was in a relationship with some boy in her class, her aunt was furious knowing that her niece had gotten a boyfriend and how she was her responsibility.

She talked to Natalie about it and how wrong it was, Natalie was devastated at her aunt's statement.

She feared that this would've happened, so when she logged on she was scared to tell them what happened especially Jaden.

Hours into school Natalie had texted Jaden saying about how she couldn't be with him any longer not explaining why leaving Jaden dumbfounded when he went to check his messages.

When he opened up his private chats with her and felt confused and kind of nauseous at the one simple text that had been sent to him.

Was this a joke? or was she really being serious about this, the first thing he did was try to text her but she didn't reply to him. 

He moved to his next resort and texted Natalie's friend (which was also his friend) Nagisa.

He told them what had happened between Natalie and him saying how he was confused and worried because Natalie never told him why she broke up with him.

Nagisa understood on why and how Jaden's feelings were like that, they wanted to explain to him but had to ask permission from Natalie if it was okay.

When they go her approval Nagisa went ahead and texted Jaden, explaining to him why Natalie had broke up with him.

They explained that Natalie's aunt was a strict one and didn't allow Natalie to date.

Jaden got that Natalie's aunt was strict but he thought that this was not fair and tried to get Natalie to talk to him again so they can or could work things out again.

He explained to Nagisa that he could tell Natalie to at least keep their relationship secret and for Natalie to tell that they broke it off.

When he did tell her Natalie explained back to him that she couldn't because her aunt would check her messages every single night.

Jaden felt a bit heartbroken hearing Natalie say that to him.

He asked for Nagisa's help and they were willing to help him because they didn't want to see the sight of their friends upset.

Jaden tried to make a document explaining all his feelings and spilling information that he wanted Natalie to know, while Nagisa was helping him.

When Jaden was done setting the letter for Natalie he had asked Nagisa to share the document with her.

When Nagisa had sent it to her on their private messages, Natalie had  opened up the document after class had finished.

She was staring at the screen filled with words that had been spilled by Jaden, saying how much he loved and cared for her.

All he asked of her was to take him back saying how he will never let go of her.

After Natalie had read all that she was regretting what she was about to say to him, she didn't want to upset him but she had to say it or never tell him.

She said that she couldn't because she knew what her aunt would say if she say that specific document or even worse, if she accepted that letter.

When Natalie had turned down Jaden's letter, Jaden was confused at this and gave up on her because what was even worth trying anymore if she won't even accept?

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Weeks later Natalie had regretted her decision, turning Jaden down she wished that she didn't turn him down because she still loved him deep down in her heart.

She went to Nagisa for help because she didn't know what to do and how to make things right with Jaden.

Natalie tried to text Jaden but he didn't reply, She did the same thing he did on a document but it was more of an apology than a heart warming letter like Jaden made.

She at least tried to improvise on what she was saying or try to say the right words to him, not to hurt him and his feelings.

A few days later Jaden had seen the shared doc and clicked on it reading it, not feeling anything for it.

He went back to Natalie's old confession letter letting her know how he really felt about her, saying that he never knew how to work a relationship in other words actually be in one.

Jaden had sent a message saying to Natalie that he only ever wanted to accept her confession letter just because he didn't want to turn her down and how he was confused when she did confess to him.

He said to her that he didn't want to make her sad but to lie to her and stay with her to make her happy, doing things the way she wanted to but in the end he said to her that they were never meant for each other how they were complete opposites of each other and lie to say that he ever meant his words when he told her those three words "  I love you "

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1095 words (1098 including this)

Hi! Writer here and I hope you liked this true story and remake of a story my friend really made but I wanted to let you guys know the full story in detail.

Don't worry I got full permission from Natalie!

Should I add a part 2 to see what they're doing right not or should I put what happened a few months after Jaden's turn down?

Let me know!

Q and A!

Q1: What would you do in this situation?

Q2: Who would you side on in this story?

Write your A's (Answers) in the comment section below!