Island of the slaughtered

The mistake

Rule #7: Mind your business.

Duncan left Noah all alone, big, big mistake.

The killer has once again taken a break.
Owen is looking in their pantry
"Guys, we ran out of food!"
"No sh*t, all you do is eat" Duncan exclaims
"We need to send a group out for food or we'll all starve!"
"Yea, yea. I'll go, who's coming with me?" Duncan looks around, seeing who else is going
Noah raises his hand, along with Izzy and Eva
"Alright, let's go, I guess"

Eva, Izzy, Duncan and Noah head out to the forest to find more food, they probably should've gone in the morning, when it was bright outside, but Owen needed his food or he would explode, so they left in the afternoon, when it was getting dark.

After walking, walking and more walking, Duncan noticed something
"Uh guys, I think we're lost..."
"Great! Just Great!" Noah says, sarcastically
"The one time I listen to you, we're lost! Good going, green highlighter, now we're going by my directions!"
"Uhm, no, we're not! I only got us lost because YOU kept annoying me!" Duncan rolls his eyes and scoffs.

Noah and Duncan continue arguing for what felt like hours, til Duncan said something he could never take back...
"Y-know what Noah, we're leaving you! You can find your own way back to the campsite!"
"Wait WHAT?! How is this my fault?! Your not gonna leave me, you wouldn't"
"Oh, but we would, Cmon Eva, Cmon Izzy!"
Izzy and Eva are hesitant, but they go with Duncan
"W-Wait guys! Come back, Duncan, I'll let you lead us! Guys! Guys?"
Noah looks around for their footprints, but Duncan covered them all up.....

Noah can hear footsteps everywhere, he starts walking towards he thinks they came from. Suddenly, he feels something tight around his neck, the whole room begins to go black.
He feels a gut wrenching pain in his chest, is he dead...?

Cody is biting his nails nervously, when Duncan, Izzy and Eva emerge from the woods, without Noah.....
"Oh hey gu- wait...where's Noah?!" Cody says, still biting his nails
Duncan laughs slightly "I left him because he was being ignorant" he rolls his eyes
"You WHAT?!" Leshawna says, her eyes growing wider
"What if he's dead?!" Gwen concerns
"I'm sure he's fine" Duncan scoffs
"I'm going to find him!" Cody says, running off into the woods

Cody has been looking and looking, when finally, he gets to the lake. Exhausted, he sits on the dock, maybe a tear or two slip out, he couldn't help it.
He looks down and puts his hand in the water, swaying it from side to side when suddenly.....
"NOAH?!" Noah pops up from the water and Cody pulls him out, he can tell he's dead, but he's in denial.
"Are you ok?! S-Should I give you CPR?" He says after pulling him out of the water, he's freaking out, until he sees the knife in his chest.....
"W-What- What the fuck?!" He says, grabbing the knife, but he doesn't pull it out because of the blood that would flow out.

Later, Cody returns to the group, without Noah...
"Cody, where's Noah? Are you ok?! Why are you crying?" Leshawna says in a panic
"Oh, uhmm. About that......Noah's-" Cody says, as he gets cut off
"Well? Spit it out!" Duncan states, side eyeing him
"Hes dead, ok?! And it's all your fault!" Cody points at Duncan
"M-My fault?! Why is it my fault?!"
"You left him alone to rot and die!"  Cody rolls his eyes
"Well, he was a weakling if he didn't survive!" Duncan says, walking into his cabin since it was getting dark, along with everyone else.