Creepypastas x Reader (mlm & wlw)

☠️- Jeff x male!reader

Hi pookies, heres the oneshot and headcannon book i promised just for yall.
——————————
He's probably in denial, I've seen a few stories mention that Jeff's family was at least a little conservative so he'd probably feel really conflicted after bro realised he's crushing on a guy. Poor dude has at least a little religious trauma. It might not be cannon but the idea of that just makes sense for his character.

In my story i made him way to OOC and soft, he's aggressive and moat likely short tempered. He's the type to use the push and pull manipulation techniques on you to make sure you'll NEVER be able to leave and rat him out.

(Push and pull technique is where an abusive person is very affectionate for a certain amount of time before completely pulling away, making the victim want their attention even more. If you notice this is happening to you please seek help from family/ friends and break off the relationship, its not healthy babygirl 🙁🙁)

Lowkey ignoring the toxic stuff.. He'd make up lies like "I had a nightmare" "I can't sleep" and so on to have a reason to stay in your room.
His denial would make him be the worst when it comes to complimenting ANYTHING you do.

"oh Jeff did you like the food i made yesterday"
He'd probably respond with an 'it was alright' while knowing damn well it was the best fucking thing he ever tasted.

Talks about his victims in detail thinking it entertains and impresses you (poor idiot has no social skills).

After yall start dating not much honestly changes, he just becomes more possessive over you and finds it slightly easier to interact with you now that y'all have an established relationship.

After the fucker finally grows a pair and confesses it becomes pretty quiet for a while. He's suddenly very sweaty and nervous, basically stalking after you like a shadow.

Honestly I see him as the type to use gift giving as a way to show his affection. Since he was burned his skin is very sensitive so he's not too familiar with physical contact and he's still too much of a pussy to give you any type of praise.

I mean the dude kills people so when he breaks into their house and finishes them off he usually takes a few minutes to wander around, taking anything he finds interesting.

He'd see a random thing in his recent victim's house, remembering how you were talking about a similar item and your interest in it. The next morning when you'd wake up you'd probably find it on your bedside table (if its something bigger he'll probably place it on the floor). The item would most likely have small specks of blood still on it since he grabbed it without caring how messy his hands got from his 'work'.

You two go on almost nightly late night walks because he can't go out in the daytime for long periods of time or else the idiot would get caught 👍

I personality see him as a huge show off, no mater what he'll always find a way to flex his athleticism. The motherfucker is up in random trees, doing pull ups on the most sturdy branch he can reach while calling your name to catch your attention. (Tarzan ass motherfucker)

Speaking of his traits, being a skilled knife murderer he developed some neat cooking abilities so while you usually mix the ingredients together he's usually tasked with cutting them up into pieces. He's tried teaching you before but you nearly lost a finger so.....

He fucking despises his brother so anytime anything even related to him comes up he immediately shuts off, probably ignores you for the rest of the day maybe more or at least until he calms down.

He's such a baby so you'd have to constantly remind him that you love him but he'll almost never say it back normally.

Back to his sensitive skin, it took a while for him to walk around the house without his iconic while hoodie but it took even longer for you to ever even see him without a shirt.
He knows you aren't repulsed by the texture of the burned flesh all over his body but the idea of being so vulnerable makes him uneasy.

He'll let you slide a hand under his shirts/ hoodies to feel at the leathery texture but it'll probably be rare for him to actually take his shirt fully off no mater what stage your relationship is in.

Low-key i feel like he fucking sobbed a little when you first held hands, it's literally the smallest show of affection but his ass definitely cried. The differences in skin textures definitely interested him a lot, its been a while since he was able to touch someone so the texture of skin that wasn't filled with scars and burns was unfamiliar.

Thats why overtime he  would warm up to the idea of physical contact. Sure it would still be very limited due to his skin's sensitivity but instad of full body contact he'd always have a hand on you instead. It overtime became a subconscious thing. Like you'll be laying on the couch watching something and randomly his hand would slide under the edge of your shirt, he wouldn't move, his hand would just rest on your stomach.

Also popular idea, his hands are always freezing cold for no fucking reason.

Also the thing is, not his whole body is so sensitive. The most easily irritated areas are his face, his upper to the middle of his back and an upper part of his torso and shoulders. The rest of the spots are mostly numb, he can still feel touch in those areas every once in a while just not as much.

Also, he was very hesitant of kissing you, like ever. You had to initiate the first kiss you ever shared and even then he was as tense as a rock, too afraid of your reaction to so anything.
After you pulled away and smiled at him he literally started bawling his eyes out and when you tried comforting him he probably denied even crying, probably saying something like:
'Fuck off- what?! No, Im not cryin'! Youre seein' things..!"

The two of you have showered together before and it was a surprisingly domestic and sweet moment. You washed each other's hair and just basked in the presence of one another.
As toxic as he can be if Jeff loves someone he genuinely loves them. Overtime he'd warm up to the idea that he wasn't entirely straight and that he was literally dating a man and with that he'd also become more affectionate. He now knew you weren't opposed to the idea of him and he'd now happily seek you out every time he came home from a particularly shitty killing session.