ꜱᴄʀᴇᴀᴍ (1996) ᴏɴᴇꜱʜᴏᴛꜱ

Ocean Eyes | S.M

Stu Macher × Fem!Reader
[Background Ships: Billy × Sidney]
|Triggers|
Blood, Violence, Toxic Relationship(?)
_________________________________________________________

There was always something about him I couldn't quite wrap around my finger. His silly demeanor but those sweet and innocent eyes. He seemed like he couldn't harm a fly. Well at least that's what I wanted to believe. I guess I always knew there was something darker behind those ocean eyes.
_________________________________________________________

I was sitting at the fountain in front of the school waiting for my boyfriend to come out so we could go to his house so I could help him set up for his party. He has always had a habit of taking forever to the simplest of tasks, so this didn't feel all that weird. That's when I saw him hopping out of the school doors sliding down the stair railing to me. I chuckle and stand up as he walks over to me and wraps his arms around me, lifting me into the air. I let out a little squeal as he spun me around. He sat me down onto the ground and I grabbed one of his hands.
"We should be on our way mister." I say jokingly and we start walking in the direction of his house.

We got there and unlocked his door, opening it for me. I go inside and walk into the living room throwing my school bag onto the couch. I felt him wrap his arms around me from behind and rest his chin on my shoulder. I hummed and reached back resting my hand on his head. I turned around to face him and led back onto the back of the couch.
"Didn't you say you wanted to get that keg out for tonight?" His eyes light up for a moment.
"Ooo yeah, thank you for reminding me" He smiles and quickly kisses me before running to the garage. I smile and continue to lean on the couch as I watch him run off.

I looked down at the ground in front of me and saw where Stu was standing, a red smeared shoe print. I squinted my eyes a bit, confused when I heard Stu's voice yell for me in the garage. I looked up and saw him at the door waving me over. I stood up straight and walked over. I leant in the door, and he pointed a few cases of beer on the floor.
"Can you take those to the fridge?" he asks, and I nod completely forgetting about the red shoe print. 

We spent the next few hours setting up which was mostly keeping the beer cold when people started showing up. Stu had changed into his robe, and I just stole one of his t-shirts and had on a pair of shorts I was wearing before. I stood beside him at the door as he welcomed people in. He eventually left me to go and "entertain" his guest. I stood by the door and welcomed people I knew. I saw Randy, Tatum and Sidney already walk in and were wandering around. Sidney came over and stood beside me at the door. I was about to talk to her when I felt Stu wrap his arms around my shoulders. Sidney looked over at us.
"Have either of you seen Tatum?" I shake my head.
"Nah" Stu said, resting his chin on my forehead. That is when we all saw Billy come into view. I noticed he gave Stu a strange look as he leaned into the doorframe.
"Stu stood up straight and stood beside me wrapping his arm around my waist.
"You two need to talk this out..." he said to Billy and Sidney.
"How about you two go up to my parent's room and 'talk' it out" he had a large smirk on his face but Sidney just sort of agreed and we watched as Billy and her went up the stairs.

I looked over at Stu who had the stupidest smile on his face. I then saw Randy in the corner of my eye walking over, looking disappointed. He stood beside Stu and looked up the stairs.
"There goes my chance with Sid" Stu rolls his eyes and looks over at him.
"As if" Stu said as he pulled me closer to him.

Everyone started piling into the living room to watch TV. I sat on the couch, well in Stu's lap. He had his arms around me as we watched a horror movie. Randy started getting a bit rowdy and Stu looked at me before setting me beside him and him getting up. I watched as he walked to the door that led to the kitchen and looked over at Randy.
"...and never ever, under any circumstances say 'I'll be right back' because you won't be back" I hear Stu speak up right after that.
"I'm getting another beer, you want one?"
"Yeah sure" Randy says waving his hand and Stu starts slowly backing up.
"I'll be right back!" I shoved my face into my hands as Stu walked out the room. I giggled and listened to the rest of Randy's spill.

_________________________________________________________

It had been a little while since Stu left and everyone had run out of the house after finding out that the principal had been murdered and his body was hanging. Me and Randy stayed behind not wanting anything to do with that. The house was really quiet, and Randy seemed to be zoned into the TV, so I got up and started looking around for Stu. I looked around the ground floor with no one in sight, that's when I started going up the stairs. I didn't make it far when I heard a scream come from a bedroom. I jogged a bit before I saw Sidney running out of the bedroom and down the hall. She was chased by a guy in what people were calling the scream mask. I held my breath not wanting to draw attention to myself. All I could hear was the TV from downstairs mixed with Sidney's screams.

I wasn't totally sure what to do so I froze and just stood there watching this guy bang at the door trying to get to Sidney. I slowly grabbed the railing and tried to slowly walk backward down the stairs. That didn't work very well though because the guy quickly swung his head to look over at me. I was frozen staring at this person as they stared at me. It was a moment before they came running over at me. I almost fell backwards trying to get down, but I was too slow because this person already had hold of me. I didn't even scream; I just squeezed my eyes shut as the person had their hand around my wrist squeezing it. I felt my body shaking when the person loosened their grip on my wrist. I kept my eyes closed when the voice behind the mask sounded familiar. 

"Y/N..." The voice sounded soft yet stern and slightly muffled behind the mask. I still had my eyes squeezed shut when I felt someone's hand cup my face. I could feel the handle of what I could only think was a knife also squished onto my face. The person let go of my wrist and said something again, this time I could hear the voice clearer. I knew who was speaking to me.
"Open them for me please" I almost wanted to burst into tears as I opened my eyes to see Stu. Him holding the mask at the side of him, the bloody knife close to my head. All I could focus on was his eyes, oh how beautiful they were. I wanted to just melt into his arms. I could feel the blood from the knife running down my cheek, but I didn't care.

His face only had a slight smirk on it as he moved his hand and knife away from my face. He wiped the blood from my cheek and looked me into the eyes.
"How about you go to my room and wait until I come back to get you?" I almost immediately nodded, and he led me into his bedroom. He stood in the doorway as he put back on the mask and looked down at me.
"Now don't leave this room until I come to get you alright?" I nod and he lifts the mask to only show his mouth and softly gives me a kiss before closing the door. I turned my back to the door and stared down at the floor. With my back on the door, I slowly slid down to the ground. Where I waited and waited. Until I heard that knock on the door.

"You can come out baby~"