Mordecai
You just got out of dinner with Mordecai and were walking down the street together holding hands, he told one of his jokes and you laugh like you always do. He notices your hands starting to shake and pulls you close to him "You getting cold there beautiful?" He asked and you couldn't help but blush a little from the pet name. "No, I'm fine." You say pretty unconvincingly, he suddenly takes his hoodie off and hands it to you. "No you really don't have to.." you begin to say but he cuts you off "I want to, please come on Y/N it's pretty obvious that you're cold out here." You sigh in defeat and put on the hoodie. "There, ya happy now?" You can't help but crack a bit of a smile. He takes your hand in his again and replies "more than happy, as long as I'm with you that is." Your cheeks once again turn red as you say "You're so corny sometimes." He laughs "You know you love it." You keep quiet cause both of you know that he's right. The two of you finally reach your apartment as you go to give him his hoodie back. He puts his hand up "No you keep it, you look way better in it anyways." You roll your eyes playfully at him "Maybe, but you still have about a 15 minute walk home so you should take it." He pulls you in for a goodbye kiss and you melt into his arms, "he really is such an amazing kisser" you think to yourself. "I'll be fine, just maybe send me a selfie of you wearing it later if you feel comfortable and we'll call it even." You laugh a bit before replying "Fine, you've got yourself a deal." You settle into your place and send Mordecai a quick picture about 10 minutes later and he instantly replies "See? No way I could be cold out here with a girlfriend that's so hot." And a bunch of heart eye emojis You chuckle to yourself and settle in for the night, falling asleep in his hoodie. You'd never tell him, but you absolutely love how it smells like him.
Rigby
You were over at the house with Rigby having your regular date night, the two of you have been up playing "would you rather?" for longer then you would care to admit. When you notice the time you gasp in shock "Oh my god Rigby it's already 15 minutes past midnight." He looks over at the clock and seems just as surprised as you. "Oh wow, I'm sorry Y/N I know you wanted to leave around 11 at the latest." You shake your head "It's okay Rigby, it's both our faults. I just seem to lose track of time when I'm with you." He blushes and agrees "You know, you could always sleepover if you wanted to?" He says a little nervous but his eyes glimmering with hope. You smile back "I mean I could.." before you can even finish he says "Great! You can sleep on my bed by yourself if that makes you feel comfortable, or I could maybe sleep with you." He starts to blush at the last part and you can't help but to start too. "Yeah of course you can sleep by me, I wouldn't wanna steal your bed from you." He gets closer and puts his arm around you "Y/N there isn't anything you could steal from me, what's mine is yours. I don't want you to feel like you have to." You smile at his kindness but reply "Rigby I would really like it if you would sleep next to me tonight." You see his eyes fill with a mix of excitement and relief as the two of you run upstairs to sleep. "I just don't really have anything comfy to wear." You say looking down at your blouse. He hands you a t-shirt to change into and when you come back from the bathroom you swear his jaw almost drops. "Wow you look amazing.." You jokingly strike a little pose and ask "like what you see?" He replies "More like love what I see." He moves over so you can slip onto the bed/trampoline with him where the two of you sleep comfortably all night.
Benson
You and Benson were at his place cooking dinner together, this has become one of your favorite things to do after Benson gets home from work. Everything was going great until you got a glob of pizza sauce all over your white shirt. "Aww man!" You exclaim as you look at your now probably ruined shirt "I'll be back in a bit, just gotta change quick." Benson stops you before you can leave "I probably have something here you could wear, I mean you know not to leave me alone with the food. You'll come back and our pizza will be ruined." He jokes. You laugh and roll your eyes "How could you mess up pizza??" You ask as he heads to his room and starts looking through his drawers. He comes out with a plain white t shirt "How did I mess up a lot of the simple jobs you've given me while we cook?" You take the shirt and reply "Fair point, and you're gonna give me a white shirt again?? You trying to ruin your laundry or something?" He grins "Well maybe if you ruin that one I'll have to find something else and we can do a whole fashion show." You shake your head and giggle as you head to the bathroom to change. When you come out you could see something in Benson's eyes change "everything okay??" You ask starting to feel a bit self conscious. Suddenly Benson comes from behind and wraps his arms around your waist and whispers "more than okay..you look really gorgeous in my clothes you know that?" He whispers into your ear. Your face goes completely red "Thank you.." you let out with shaky breath. "Is this okay?" He asks making sure you are comfortable. "Definitely." You reply as he starts to kiss your neck gently. He slowly pulls away and jokes "maybe we should finish this pizza before I completely forget about it." You laugh and help him finish up your dinner.
Muscle Man
You sat in muscle man's trailer waiting for him to return, Benson sent him out to do a job with fives and you're already starting to miss him a lot. Some people would describe you and muscle man as "codependent" or "needy" but the two of you just truly loved spending every moment you could together as far as you were concerned. The hours seemed to drag on and on as you watched tv, tried to think of some pranks, even had a few wings but none of it felt the same without muscle man. It was starting to get late and you were starting to feel sleepy with still no sign of muscle man so you sent him a quick text. "Good night babe, I miss you :( <3" You tried to settled down to sleep but couldn't with the feeling of something missing. You suddenly decided to walk into muscle man's room and open up his drawer, you put on his blue long sleeve shirt that he always wears and cuddled into a ball pretending he was there and instantly fell asleep. You woke up the next morning to muscle man behind you and wrapped in his arms, you smile and cuddle deeper into him so glad that your man is finally back.
YOU ARE READING
Regular Show Boyfriend Scenarios
FanfictionCharacters include Mordecai, Rigby, Benson, and Muscle Man. I might add more later on in the story if there's a request for a certain character