The days following our walk through the Christmas lights felt lighter. Betty and I had settled into this new space between us—comfortable, relaxed, but with an undeniable undercurrent of something more. It wasn't forced, and it wasn't rushed. We just... *were*, and that was enough.
Christmas was around the corner, and the town buzzed with holiday excitement. School was out for winter break, and with it came the usual lull in everyone's lives. People moved slower, took time to enjoy the season, and for once, I felt like I could breathe.
Betty and I hadn't made any big plans for Christmas—just some vague mention of maybe seeing each other sometime between family celebrations. And honestly, I didn't want to push it. We were still navigating the balance between what we were and what we could be, and I didn't want to mess it up by trying to label it too soon.
But on Christmas Eve, as I was sitting by the fire with my parents, my phone buzzed with a message from her.
Are you around tonight?
It was unexpected, but the smile spread across my face instantly.
Yeah, I'm at home. What's up?
She replied quickly. Want to come over? My parents are out for a bit, and I could use some company.
I glanced at my parents, who were watching yet another Christmas movie on TV. They didn't seem to mind me heading out.
"Going to see Betty?" my mom asked with a knowing smile, not even bothering to look away from the screen.
"Yeah, just for a little while," I said, grabbing my coat and pulling it on. "I'll be back soon."
With a quick wave, I slipped out into the cold night, the crunch of snow beneath my boots and the smell of wood smoke in the air. It was the kind of quiet winter night that made everything feel still, like time had slowed down just for a moment. The streets were lit with glowing Christmas lights, the occasional house shining brighter than the rest, their windows filled with warmth and cheer.
By the time I reached Betty's house, the nerves had crept in. I wasn't sure why—I'd been to her house hundreds of times. But something about tonight felt different. Maybe it was the fact that it was Christmas Eve, or maybe it was because we'd been slowly inching our way toward something more.
I knocked lightly on the door, my breath visible in the cold air, and waited. A few seconds later, the door opened, and there she was, bundled in a cozy sweater, her hair loosely tied back. She smiled when she saw me, and for a second, the world felt like it was exactly as it should be.
"Hey," she said, stepping aside to let me in. "Come in, it's freezing out there."
I wiped my boots on the mat and followed her inside. Her house was warm, the scent of pine and cinnamon filling the air. The Christmas tree in the corner sparkled with lights, and there were gifts wrapped beneath it, their shiny paper reflecting the glow.
"Nice tree," I said, nodding toward it as I took off my coat.
She laughed softly. "Thanks. My mom's obsessed with making it perfect every year."
We moved to the living room, where a fire crackled in the fireplace. Betty sat on the couch, pulling her legs up under her, and I took a seat next to her. There was a comfortable silence between us for a moment, the soft sounds of the fire filling the room. It felt like a scene out of a holiday movie, everything glowing and peaceful.
"So," I said, leaning back against the cushions. "What made you want company tonight?"
Betty looked at the fire, her expression thoughtful. "I don't know. I guess I just didn't want to be alone. My parents are out at some Christmas party, and it felt weird, sitting here by myself on Christmas Eve."
I nodded, understanding what she meant. There was something about being alone during the holidays that felt heavier, like the quiet was louder than usual.
"Well, I'm glad you called," I said softly, glancing at her. "It's better being here with you than watching cheesy Christmas movies with my parents."
She smiled, but there was a flicker of something more serious in her eyes. "James, I've been thinking... about us."
The way she said it made my heart jump into my throat. I wasn't sure if it was a good thing or a bad thing, but the weight of her words settled in the room between us.
"I've been thinking about it too," I admitted, my voice quieter than I intended.
She shifted slightly on the couch, her gaze steady on mine. "I know we've been taking things slow, and I'm glad we have. But I think... I think I'm ready to try again. For real this time."
The words hit me like a punch, but in the best way possible. For a second, I wasn't sure I'd heard her right, but the look in her eyes told me she meant every word.
"Are you sure?" I asked, needing to know if she really felt ready, if this was what she wanted.
She nodded, her expression soft but certain. "I am. I think I needed time to figure out what I wanted, to make sure I wasn't rushing into anything because it was comfortable. But the truth is, I still care about you, James. I still want to be with you."
The relief that flooded through me was almost overwhelming. I'd spent months wondering if this moment would ever come, if we'd ever get back to a place where we could try again. And now, sitting here with her, on Christmas Eve, it felt like everything was finally falling into place.
"I care about you too," I said, my voice a little shaky with emotion. "I never stopped. I just didn't want to push you."
Betty smiled, and this time it reached her eyes, lighting up her whole face. "I know. That's why I trust you again. I needed to see that."
For a moment, neither of us said anything. The crackling fire was the only sound, and I couldn't help but feel like this moment was somehow perfect in its simplicity. It wasn't a grand gesture or some romantic declaration under the stars. It was just us, in the warmth of her living room, finally finding our way back to each other.
She leaned forward, and before I could second-guess it, I met her halfway. Our lips touched softly, and it was like all the tension, all the uncertainty, melted away in that single kiss. It wasn't rushed or desperate. It was gentle, careful—like we were both learning how to be together again.
When we pulled back, her eyes were soft, a little shy but happy. I couldn't help but grin, feeling like I'd just been handed the best Christmas gift I could ever ask for.
"I'm glad I came over tonight," I said, my voice light.
She laughed, the sound like music. "Me too."
And as we sat there, the warmth of the fire wrapping around us, I knew that whatever happened next, we'd figure it out. Together.
YOU ARE READING
The Way Things Change
Teen FictionEver wonder the details of Betty's and James's story. Here it is! The parties, the dances, the whole shabang. This is written based off my interpretation of Taylor Swifts song Betty, and has no connections to her.