Agatha all Along Preferences

When they found out they liked you

Agatha Harkness:

She knew she was fucked the second she started to care, you guys were walking on the road not even on a trial, you just tripped, she nearly rushed over to you before stopping herself, thankfully Teen and Alice helped you up. She spent the rest of the walk silent checking up on you every few meters while trying to figure out how this happened.

Teen:

You were both hanging out when it was dark, talking about witching traditions when you had a little competition about who could name more constellations, it was a classic cute and friendly competition after what seemed like a never ending list of constellations you were getting tired, your eyes were about to close when he asked you what one of the constellations were, you tired mind was so out of it you didn't answer properly you sleepily said 'the something, something' while not even trying to keep your eyes opened. He looked at you and laughed finding it cute how tired you were when he paused to look at you in the moonlight, smiling at you it seemed the world around him stopped he was shocked he hadn't noticed sooner. "Fuck," he muttered as he never swore, he was silent for the rest of the evening trying to figure out of this was real, before you both eventually went to your homes for sleep.

Lilia Calderu:

Lilia was never good with love, she could predict it for others, but feel it herself that was rare, she did however take a liking to you, it was hard to find a half decent witch especially a good one who wasn't boring, she never really followed a classic falling in love ark when it cam to you, she just sort of figured out that she liked you, she didn't want to rush things but she did put in effort to spend more time with you and hopefully you'd fall for her too.

Jenifer Kale:

You were both working on a potion, she was trying to remember it off the top of her head while you were insisting to get the book, after a while she gave in. You grabbed the book and sat on the counter turning the pages, peacefully and carefully reading, she realized how pretty you look, she just stared at you realizing that you were the closest thing she had to a relationship in a long time, she wondered what it'd be like to have you as more than a business partner, she'd like it she thought.

Alice Wu-Gulliver:

She had gotten in a argument with everyone else in the coven trying to justify taking a more humane approach to the trials when you stood up for her, a fiery, fierce, determined version of you she had forgotten all about was standing up for her despite everyone else being on the other side, she completely forgot about the argument simply letting you defend her, being a protection witch it was nice for her to feel protected herself, and you were someone who did that for her you both had such a loyal bond she knew she wanted it to evolve to something more.

Rio Vidal:

She knew she found you hot from the second she saw you, what she didn't expect was a simple attraction and a physical level to turn into something more, she found herself noticing your habits or little things you did, it was like you put a spell on her, but it wasn't she had a crush on you and it was getting worse the more time she spent with you