Chapter 6:
Shadows of the Past
—
Part 2:
A Tense Conversation
The diner was the kind of place you’d expect to find in the middle of nowhere—faded vinyl booths, flickering neon lights, and a perpetual smell of coffee mixed with grease. The sound of clattering dishes, the murmur of conversations, and the distant buzz of a cheap radio created an ambiance of normalcy, but Ethan felt far from calm.
He sat across from Sarah at a small booth, the laminated table between them sticky from years of neglect. The waitress had just set down two mugs of coffee, her smile brief and uninterested, before she disappeared to tend to another customer. The warm steam rising from the cup did little to thaw the icy tension between Ethan and Sarah.
For most of the bus ride, they had kept their silence, the unspoken rift between them growing wider with each passing mile. But now, with the bus parked outside and the quiet of the rural town surrounding them, Ethan couldn’t hold back any longer. He couldn’t keep pretending everything was fine when doubt gnawed at him, sharper with every secret Sarah refused to share.
His fingers tightened around the ceramic mug, the heat seeping into his palms. He stared at the swirling dark liquid, trying to find the right words to begin. His frustration was a coiled spring, tightly wound, threatening to snap at any moment.
“You’ve been hiding something from me,” he finally said, his voice low but steady. He didn’t look up, keeping his gaze fixed on the mug as if the truth might somehow lie at the bottom. “I need to know what it is, Sarah.”
Across the table, Sarah’s body tensed. She hadn’t touched her coffee, and she certainly wasn’t about to now. Her eyes darted around the diner, as if searching for an escape route or maybe just buying time. Ethan could see the flicker of hesitation in her expression, the subtle tightening of her lips as she weighed her options.
“Ethan, now’s not the time,” she said, her voice carefully controlled, a sharp contrast to the storm brewing in his chest. She glanced out the window, her fingers drumming lightly against the table. “We’re in the middle of something bigger than you realize. Pressing for details now could put us both in more danger.”
Ethan’s jaw clenched. The same vague, evasive answers. The same tired excuses. He wasn’t asking for the world; he just wanted the truth—or at least some part of it.
He leaned forward, his hands still gripping the mug, knuckles white. “Danger? We’re already in danger, Sarah! I’ve been dragged into this mess, risking everything, and you can’t even tell me why? You’re connected to all of this—my mother, the experiments, whatever the hell is going on. You owe me answers!”
His voice rose, drawing a glance from a nearby table where an older couple exchanged a concerned look. He didn’t care. The pressure had built too high, and it had to go somewhere.
Sarah’s eyes finally met his, her gaze hardening like steel. “It’s not that simple,” she said, her words clipped. “I’m trying to protect you. There are things—” She paused, inhaling sharply as if bracing herself. “There are things you don’t know yet, things you’re not ready to hear.”
“Protect me?” Ethan let out a harsh, incredulous laugh. He released his grip on the mug, running a hand through his hair in frustration. “You don’t think I can handle the truth? After everything we’ve been through? I’ve been shot at, chased, and nearly killed, and you still think I need protecting?”
Sarah shifted in her seat, her expression softening, but only slightly. “This isn’t just about you. There’s more at stake here than you realize. If I told you everything now, it could ruin everything we’re trying to do.”
Ethan’s temper flared again, his anger bubbling to the surface. “Then what are we trying to do, Sarah? What are you trying to do? Because right now, it feels like I’m just being dragged around like a pawn in a game I don’t even understand!”
Sarah remained silent, her face an impassive mask. It was that same guardedness, that same reluctance to let him in, that drove Ethan to the edge. He slammed his hand on the table, rattling the mugs and drawing more stares from the few other customers scattered throughout the diner.
“Damn it, Sarah! I deserve to know the truth. About you, about my mother, about all of this!” His voice was a harsh whisper now, laced with a desperation that surprised even him. He hadn’t realized how much he had been depending on her, how much he had needed her to be someone he could trust.
Sarah looked down, her fingers absently tracing the edge of the table. For a moment, Ethan thought he saw something—regret, maybe, or guilt—flash across her face. But when she spoke, her tone was flat, emotionless.
“I’m not the enemy, Ethan,” she said softly. “But I can’t give you all the answers you’re looking for. Not yet.”
Her refusal to open up, to even give him a sliver of honesty, hit Ethan like a punch to the gut. He felt the familiar weight of isolation settle over him, that cold, suffocating feeling that he was utterly alone in this.
“What are you so afraid of?” he asked, his voice quieter now, almost pleading. “I’m on your side, Sarah. But I can’t keep doing this if you won’t trust me.”
Sarah’s eyes flicked back up to meet his, and for the briefest of moments, her defenses cracked. “I don’t...I can’t...” She struggled to find the words, but before she could finish, she shut down again, shaking her head. “You’ll understand soon. I promise.”
Ethan leaned back in his seat, the frustration settling into a deep, aching exhaustion. He had pushed her as far as he could, but it wasn’t enough. It would never be enough. Sarah was a closed door, and no matter how hard he knocked, she wasn’t letting him in.
The silence between them was suffocating now, thick with everything they weren’t saying. Sarah reached for her coffee, taking a slow, deliberate sip, as if to signal the end of the conversation. Ethan glanced around the diner, at the people living their normal lives, oblivious to the tangled mess he was trapped in.
A waitress passed by, her tray clinking with dishes, and Ethan caught a glimpse of his reflection in the window. He barely recognized himself—tired, on edge, a shadow of the person he had been before all this began. And sitting across from him, the one person he thought he could rely on was just as much of a mystery as the forces they were running from.
He wanted to scream, to break through the wall Sarah had built around herself. But instead, he simply nodded, the fight leaving him all at once.
“Fine,” he muttered, his voice barely audible over the din of the diner. “But don’t think for a second that I’m done asking questions.”
Sarah didn’t respond. She just sat there, staring into her cup of coffee, as the distance between them stretched even wider, a chasm that neither of them seemed willing—or able—to cross.

YOU ARE READING
Is That Mom
Mystery / ThrillerEthan has always been haunted by the mysterious disappearance of his mother, a shadow over his life that no one, not even his grandmother, is willing to fully explain. Now, armed with his mother's forgotten journal and a determination to uncover the...