He lead me to the stairs and we went down to the very bottom. Then he made me follow him into a closet. He pushed a large box out of the way and uncovered a door. He grabbed my hand again and pulled me through the door, which by the way lead down some more stairs. This place wasn't even mapped out on the ship. When we were at the bottom of the steps, we went through yet again another door. Thankfully I think that was the last one. My eyes widened. I saw Slenderman standing in a corner, BEN sitting on a couch, playing video games with sonic.exe, Masky and Hoodie eating cheesecake in the kitchen, etc. What. Is. Happening. Everyone...or maybe it's everything was staring at me. Jeff the Killer walked up to me and held his knife up to my throat.
"Who's this.", he said in a rough voice.
"I-I'm (y/n).", I said still horrified, shocked, scared, and kinda excited.
Eyeless Jack explained to everyone that I was with him. I was surprised he actually wasn't going to kill me. Jeff lowered his knife and everyone didn't seem to really care I was there. Slenderman did make me swear not to tell anyone though....three times. He said make my self at home so I curled up on a chair watching BEN play Majora's Mask. Eyeless Jack was sitting on the floor in front of me. Grin cat jumped up on the arm of my chair, which almost gave me a heart attack, and curled up next to me. You know..they aren't that terrifying when they just ignore you. At least someone didn't ignore me though, Masky offered me a slice of cheesecake. I obviously took it, who rejects cheesecake?
"Soooo, when do I leave? My parents will be waking up in about an hour.", I said.
"I'll take you back if you'd like.", Eyeless Jack said.
"Thanks EJ.", I said.
He gave me a questioning look. I explained that since there were two Jacks he would be EJ. Slenderman ordered Masky and Hoodie to watch me during the day to make sure I kept my promise. Dude, I promised like three times! EJ lead me back to my room. Before he left he lifted up his mask slightly and kissed me on the cheek. I blushed and went under my covers, hiding my face when he left.
My parents woke me up not long after. I said I wanted to stay in bed but they said I already got a full night's rest. Heh, if only they knew. I got up to go to breakfast and I told my parents I would sit with a friend. I got the normal bacon, eggs, and toast with milk and sat with EJ. It wasn't only him though, Masky and Hoodie were there. I smirked in my head. Only I get to know what their faces look like. Masky had side burns and pretty blue/green eyes. Hoodie had messy black hair and black eyes. We sat at a booth, me next to EJ and Masky and Hoodie on the other side of the table. Hoodie apologized for having to stalk me and Masky explained that they were the only normal looking ones so it couldn't be helped.
After breakfast they followed me to the club. Jack asked if I was alright. I was kinda stumbling and had bags under my eyes. I replied with that I was fine but I fell asleep on him anyways when I was playing video games. Apparently I got carried back to the creepypasta base, or just really a house under a cruise. I woke up in a bedroom, and don't ask me who's, I don't know. I walked out into the living room and sat down next to BEN, who was still playing Majora's Mask. I had never played it before so I asked if I could. He said yes and taught me all the cool cheats. Time to impress my friends at home!
"Hey you're awake.", Masky (probably) smiled.
"I hope you don't mind but you slept in my room.", EJ said.
"Oh is that why it smelled like kidneys?", you smirked.
"W-what?! I didn't eat any in there I swear!', he said.
I laughed, "I was just kidding man."
"Haaaaaaaa-aaay! I'm back g-guys! You miss me Masky?", Ticci Toby said.
"No.", Masky said annoyed.
"H-hey there's a new girl! What's y-your name?", he ran over to me.
"I'm (y/n).", I said. This Toby guy seems nice.
EJ said he had to talk to me privately. I walked into his bedroom. He sniffed the air, and I chuckled. Whoops.
"You seem to be getting along with us "creepypastas" very well.", he said.
"Well..yeah. Why did this need to be private, you'd think you'd be proposing to me or something.", I said.
He turned his head the other way, probably flustered.
"Soooo, what's with your house being under a boat?", I asked.
"That's why I needed to talk to you privately.", he said, "You see, this isn't really under a boat. There was a portal at the bottom of the boat that only creepypastas can use, but I think maybe you might be able to. Not now but if you were to get most of us to like you.", he explained.
I smiled. I would be able to stay with him. Even though he's a killer, I still love him. I...wonder if he feels the same.
