Is This Just Fantasy (Sam Winchester x Reader)

Chapter 4

Still giddy over the news that you had just received, you almost floated up the stairs, and into your closet. In front of you was a bag, a sticky note with a smile on the front, and you knew this dress was meant for tonight.

Unzipping the bag, you gasped at the beautiful dress in front of you. It was sapphire blue, and flowed to knee length. The sleeveless dress had a deep V in the front, and you couldn't wait to slip it on. Throwing your tshirt off, and sliding out of your jeans, you almost moaned as the smooth material glided down your skin. Grabbing a pair of nude pumps, you slipped into them before making your way back into the room, stopping at the wondrous sight in front of you. Sam had his back to you, the muscles straining and moving as he pulled on his slacks over his tight black boxers. Standing up, he grabbed a dark blue shirt before facing you, his mouth dropping open in shock.

"Woah, you look amazing! How did I get such a beautiful woman to fall in love with me?" He asked, coming over to wrap his arms around you from behind.

"Just lucky, I guess." You replied, enjoying the feeling of Sam's warm body wrapping itself around you.

He placed a kiss on your neck, before standing up and pulling something out of his pocket. Moving your hair to the side, Sam placed a simple gold chain around your neck, kissing where it met your skin. In the front was a gold locket, and you reached up to open it. Inside was a small picture of you and Sam, hand in hand.

Turning to face him, you stood on tiptoes, kissing his cheek. "Sam, I love it, it's gorgeous. But it's your birthday, you're supposed to be getting the presents, not me."

Sam just shrugged his broad shoulders, before grabbing your hand and gently pulling you down the stairs. "It makes me happy to see you happy. Thats a good enough present for me."

He wrapped you in your coat, before turning to grab his. "Wow this Sam is such a cheesy romantic." You whispered to yourself.

"What was that?" Sam asked, as he returned with his coat on.

"Nothing," You answered, before you followed him out to his sensible, mid sized car.

The drive was quick, and before you knew it, Sam was pulling in front of a two story house, one that seemed vaguely familiar. Sam was looking at the house, his brows furrowed in confusion. "I know Mom said we were having dinner here. Why are the lights off?"

You shrugged your shoulders, acting innocent. "Why don't we go try the door. Maybe they're outside?"

Sam agreed, and slipped around the car, opening the door for you, before grasping your hand in his large smooth one. Sam rang the doorbell and no one answered.

"Weird." He muttered.

"Why don't you open it, we can call them from inside." You suggested.

Sam opened the door, and you watched with a smile on your face as he is at once bombarded with shouts of Surprise and Happy Birthday. A big grin covered his face as he was hugged and greeted by friends and family.

You watched as Dean strode over, a lovely brunette in a simple red dress holding his hand. He slapped Sam on the shoulder. "Happy Birthday old man."

Sam gave Dean a look before replying. "If I'm an old man, what does that make you? Jerk."

"Bitch." Dean replied, earning a slap on the shoulder from the brunette. She then gave Sam a big hug.

"Happy Birthday Sam. Don't let your idiot brother ruin it for you."

Sam chuckled. "Don't worry Elizabeth, your fiance won't be able to ruin today. I have my friends, and family, and the love of my life here. What more could I want?"

Elizabeth wrapped her arm around yours. "Well, I'm stealing one part of that for a while. You two men can entertain yourselves, we're going to help Mary."

You blindly followed Elizabeth, shocked that you would finally be meeting Mary. According to Sam and Dean, she was amazing, and you were suddenly nervous, afraid she wouldn't like you.

Once inside the kitchen, you stood and watched as a beautiful, blonde, older woman rushed around the kitchen, putting the finishing touches on the food. As she turned to grab an item from the fridge, she noticed you and Elizabeth standing there.

"There you two are! My two favorite women!" She said, rushing over to give each of you a hug. "My, don't you two look pretty."

Blushing, you quickly explained to each woman, that you had news you wanted to deliver during the party.

She then handed each of you a tray. "Please take these to the table." She requested. "Then, before cake, you can deliver your news."

The rest of the evening went smoothly. Sam had found you helping his mom, and stole you away, keeping a possessive arm around your waist. Mary came back over, this time with an older man holding her hand. Immediately you knew it was John, Sam and Dean's dad. He had passed before you had joined the brothers, but you had seen pictures and heard stories. You stood there nervously, unsure how he was going to act.

Ignoring his son, John came right over to you and gave you a hug. "Is my son treating you right?" He whispered in your ear, loud enough that Sam could hear.

"Dad." Sam grumbled.

"What, can't I make sure my son doesn't lose the best thing that's ever happened to him?" John teased, and you could automatically tell that their relationship was strong, and loving, and you breathed a sigh of relief.

Before you knew it, Mary was pulling you towards the front of the room, where a triple layered chocolate cake was proudly on display.

"Excuse me!" Mary exclaimed loudly, quickly quieting the room. "My wonderful daughter in law has something she would like to say."

All eyes turned towards you, and you searched the crowd for a familiar hazel pair. They were moving closer, and soon Sam was standing in the front of the room.

"Thank you all for coming and sharing Sam's special evening with us, it means a lot. I have something else I want to share. Today I received some news. Sam, I'm sorry I didn't get you a present, but I hope this makes up for it. I love you so very much, and I'm proud to say I'm going to have your baby."

The room was quiet for just a moment as everyone processed what you had just said. Then at once, everyone started cheering. Sam rushed forward, and picked you up, swinging you around, a huge smile on his face. Setting you down, he kissed you soundly on the lips.

"A baby? I'm going to be a Dad? That's the best present ever!" He exclaimed, before peppering you with more kisses. Dean strode over, and pulled you from his brothers embrace. "Congratulations! I can't believe it! I'm going to be an uncle!"

The rest of the evening was a blur of hugs, and well wishes, and before you knew it, Sam was pulling you out of the house, and towards his car. Before opening the door, he took you in his arms once again, pressing his head to the top of yours.

"Thank you Y/N. This has been the best birthday ever. I'm going to be a dad!"

Smiling at Sam's glee, you couldn't help but hear the nagging voice, telling you to wake up, that this was just a dream.