Omaha Squad Preferences and Imagines

#29- you dated one of his friends in the past - part 2

Nate
"Your place or mine ?" Nate asked as you walked out of the studio .
"You should come to mine ," you smiled.
"Meet you the-" he started, but was cut of by a jogging Gilinsky catching up to you .
"Hey, babe, I'm going to come over later so we can talk about us ," he stated.
"Babe ? Us ?" Nate asked you , but Jack figured the questions were directed to him.
"Yep," Jack said, throwing an arm around you ." We're getting back together ."
"You are ?" Nate asked you again .
"No, Jack, I told you we'll talk . I never said anything about is getting back together ," you stated .
"I know, but we were going to anyways , right?" Jack asked.
"No, Jack ," you said .
"Why?" He asked .
"Yeah, (Y/N), why ?" Nate asked .
Jack gave Nate a dismissing look, probably wanting him to go away.
"Because I'm seeing someone else," you said .
"Who ?" Jack asked .
"Yeah, who?" Nate chuckled .
"Dude , why are you still here ?" Jack asked Nate .
"Because I can ," Nate shrugged .
"Can you leave us alone ?" Jack asked.
"Not unless she wants me to ," Nate said pointing at you .
"Tell him to leave ," Jack said to you.
"Yeah, tell me to leave, (Y/N)," Nate smirked .
"I won't tell Nate to leave and I won't get back together with you because Nate and I are dating now ," you exclaimed .
You let out a sigh because you finally got to get this off your chest .
"Oh," Jack said .
"Look, we broke up for a reason and we ended on good terms . I didn't know I was going to end up falling for Nate ," you said .
"Do you love him ?" Jack asked.
Nate looked at you awaiting your answer .
"What does have to do with anything ?" You asked.
"Because if you love him I'll leave the idea of us alone ," Jack said .
You sighed and looked at Nate and back to Jack again.
"I do love him ," you said .
"Okay , " Jack said and walked away .
"So, your place," Nate smiled while putting his arm around me .

Gilinsky
"It's time to talk ," Jack stated when he pulled up to your apartment .
The rest of the night had gone by fine and now you would have to face this long conversation about your past with Sammy .
"Okay," you sighed.
"So, why didn't you tell me ? I mean you knew he was my friend ," Jack questioned .
"I didn't tell you because you didn't ask ," you joked .
"(Y/N), I'm serious ," he stated .
"Okay, you're right ," you said ," I should have told you because I did know he was your friend ."
"How come no one knew about the relationship ? We're pretty tight I think I would have known about you ."
"What me and Sam had was a private relationship, Jack . We wanted to keep it to ourselves and enjoy it . I met his family like once ," you explained .
"That still doesn't explain why you didn't tell me that you dated him ," Jack said .
"I didn't feel like it was information that you should know ," you shrugged." We dated years ago, broke up, I forgot about him then met you and fell for you  now here we are ."
Jack sighed and nodded his head .
"Fell for me huh ?" He smirked.
"Yeah," you shrugged.
"Well, I fell for you too, so I guess that's why I was so worried about you and Sam. I'll drop it though."
"Thank you."

Sam
Your knee bounced up and down with nervousness as Sam pulled up to his old home. You knew his friends were going to be there and you knew Jack was going to be there .
"You okay ?" Sammy asked.
"Fine ,"you lied .
"Are you sure ?"
"Yeah," you smiled.
"Good because we're here ," he grinned .
He parked the car in the driveway and you helped him carry the bags .
As soon as he opened the door he was greeted by loud rowdy boys .
"Sam my man ," one yelled, hugging him.
"Aye , Sammy boy is back," another exclaimed .
Sam grinned ear to ear, glad to finally be back home .
"Hey, hey . There's someone I want you all to meet ," Sam said as all attention went to you . "This is (Y/N) my girlfriend . (Y/N) that's Nate, Jack Gilinsky, Swazz, Mike, and where's -"
"Ahh," Sam was cut off by someone jumping on his back .
"What up, boy ?!"
"That's Jack Johnson," Sam chuckled as Jack hopped off of him .
You got a good look at Jack now and it was the same Jack who was your first love.
"Oh, J, I think you two know each other ; we were talking about it on the way up here," Sam stated as everyone begin to calm down .
Jack looked at you and furrowed his eyebrows .
"I don't think so ," he said. "How do we know each other ?"
"Dated in high school and I took you to my homecoming ?" You questioned seeing if anything would click.
"I think I would remember dating someone like you , I mean you seem like a great girl; maybe it was someone else," he shrugged .
"Maybe ," you smiled , but you knew he was the Jack you dated and it hurt you that he had forgotten about you because you couldn't forget about him.

Jack J
"Call him ," Jack stated the next morning while tossing you his phone .
"Who?" You yawned .
"Swazz," Jack said in a duh tone.
Frankly you forgot about that . You hadn't thought Jack was serious about you calling him .
"You were serious . Jack, I haven't talked to him in forever and you want me to call him this early in the morning and "break up" with him?" you said with an eyebrow raised .
"I just need you to do it for me ," he sighed .
"Fine, but this is really childish and stupid; I hope you know that ," you said , grabbing his phone and finding Swazz's number .
"What J ?"
"Not J," you giggled through the phone .
"(Y/N) ? Is that you ?" John asked .
"Wow, I can't believe you remember my voice ," you said .
"How could I forget ?" He laughed .
Jack cleared his throat and eyed you.
"Well, your probably wondering why I'm calling off of one of your friend's phones and at this time of the morning," you started.
"Yeah , I was wondering about that ," he chuckled .
"I have to break up with you . I told Jack about how we dated when we were like five and that we never broke up, so I have to break up with you now, so Jack and I can live happily we after  ," you stated .
"So, you're breaking up with me ? Okay," he laughed .
"Yep, that's all."
"Well, bye (Y/N)," he said .
"Bye, John."
You hung up and threw Jack his phone .
"Are you happy cupcake ?" You giggled.
"Sure am."

John
He had been distant with you and Nate since he had found out about the two of you and it was making you no only upset, but angry because it had been weeks .
"Hey, babe , what do you want for dinner ?" You asked him.
No answer .
"John, what do you want for dinner ?" You asked again.
Still no answer .
"John!"you exclaimed .
"Not hungry ," he finally mumbled while moving from where he sat and going into another room .
You rolled your eyes because you were tired of this childishness . You followed his path, stomping your way to him.
"I get that I didn't tell you something that maybe you should have known, but I didn't think it was a big deal and I apologize for the way you found out, but I'm tired of you acting like a big baby ," you exclaimed .
He looked at you and shrugged .
"Fine , throw away years of a friendship and a relationship away," you surrendered and turned around to leave .
He heard your voice crack and it hurt him to know he was hurting you, but you had hurt him also . He thought he knew everything about you and he knew you knew everything about him because he told you everything.
John sighed and followed you, grabbing your arm to stop you from going further away.
"Why didn't you just tell me ?" He asked while pulling you close .
You clung to him and shook your head .
"Honestly , you made me forget about him," you said.
John nodded his head and gave you a kiss .
"I love you , " you mumble into his chest .
"I love you, too, baby."

••••
Long af .