I'm hallucinating ((Creepypasta x reader))

Chapter 5: Gain her trust

"So how'd things go- oh..." Masky greeted and luckily his mask hid a look of surprise seeing Eyeless Jack carrying Jeff who still had golden duct tape on over his mouth, having helped remove the tape from him along the way. "She's good I'll give her that..." Hoodie murmured quietly, watching the masked teen and fuming killer sit on the couch; it was amusing for the others who could see that they finally had their wish come true for once. For Jeff to be silent or quiet and the teen who did that had granted that wish, if only it could stay that way but alas he needed to speak. "Alright Jeff hold still, this is gonna hurt like hell..." Eyeless warned grasping the ends of the golden tape that were on his mouth which was on the smile that was cut into him. 'Don't you dare Jack!' He shouted from the golden gag, his eyes dark with anger at the (y/h/c) girl who had done this to him.

"Wait!" BEN said grasping Eyeless' hand to stop him earning a thankful look from Jeff. Of course it was gone when BEN pulled out his phone and activated the camera to record the moment so he and the others had something to laugh at. "Okay go!" 'BEN you di-!' Jeff shouted through the ductape and screamed so many curse words when the tape was ripped off his face and it also hurt like hell from how fast it was ripped off him. Sally stared at them with her bright green eyes with an innocent look on her face before walking over to Slenderman who was in the kitchen. "Daddy?" She asked tugging on his black pants to get his attention since he was looking at something else currently. "Yes child?" the tall man without a face asked 'staring' down at the brown haired girl who had not let go of his pants. "What does-" She began repeating what she heard Jeff say with ease and if his face could turn any whiter it did. "Sally, where exactly did you hear those words?" He asked her kneeling down to her level to look her in the eye, and the brunette knew he was being serious cause he only called her by her real name if it was important or something serious. "Jeff said it when Jack removed the tape from his mouth." She answered innocently as she looked at his 'face'. "Which Jack dear?" He asked wanting to be sure, though doubting it was the clown seeing how close he was with the child that he could tolerate. "Eyeless." She answered again receiving a sigh from the man as he stood back up to his height, thankfully not hitting the ceiling when he did. "Stay here child, it shouldn't be long." Slenderman instructed walking to the living room to where he could hear the yelling from the pale skinned yelling teen, smacking Jeff repeatedly with his tentacles.

"I told you to watch your mouth around Sally!" he scolded as he smacked the pale boy repeatedly with his black tendrils. "Jeff moan! Do it for the vine!" BEN demanded earning what seemed to be a glare from Jeff, hard to do with no eyelids. "Fu-!" he began to shout till Slenderman snapped at him, "Don't you dare!" he snapped making Jeff shut up. "Now. Where were you? You're later than you usually are." He sighed. "He got his butt handed to him by the girl you sent them to retrieve." Eyeless Jack answered for the sore pale boy who had a problem sitting down. "Not just me! BEN got beat too! The elf left me behind after he got his eyes sprayed with pepper!" Jeff growled throwing the blonde under the bus. "I'm not an elf you f-!" He began shouting as his eyes turned black, held down quickly by Hoodie and Masky. "Now now. Calm down." Slenderman sighed then looked at EJ who was taking his time with the kidney he had achieved. "What did you learn about her?"

Now having the others attention, EJ began telling them what he learned of the teen female that they had taken interest in. He didn't immediately go for her kidneys, he got information like he was supposed to. "Her name is (y/f/n) (y/l/n), she's (y/a), and lives with just her mother. She's in (y/school/grade) at (y/hs/n), she likes (y/f/thing) and her hobby is (y/h). She leaves the house around (y/t) and gets back at (y/t). She's pretty skilled with a yoyo as a weapon." he informed, gaining curious looks about that last part. "She managed to hit me with her yoyo." he sighed, thankfully his mask didn't crack from the impact. "Why is she so important?" Jeff demanded to know despite the irritated look on Slenderman's 'face'. "I will tell you in due time, now isn't that time. For now try to get close to her in her 'normal' life. All I can say now is that 'he' has taken interest in the girl, do whatever you need to do if it means gaining her trust." he ordered ignoring the grumbles from a few of the killers. He noticed that EJ seemed fine with the idea, after all (y/n) did let him have her kidney. All Slenderman needed was to get (y/n) as soon as possible and make the girl one of them. She showed a bit of potential.