Avery and Tew battle inside the former's ship, but the pirates eventually killed each other in combat. Dying of their wounds, the bodies were never discovered, rotting alongside the treasure. Samuel and Nathan Drake's search for Avery's treasure, eventually finding against their rival, Rafe Adler. Nathan, Samuel, and Rafe found the ship alongside the treasure room with Avery and Tew's body. Rafe's ally, Nadine Ross leaves the trio to die, as Rafe and Nate battle in a dual, leading to Rafe's death.
Avery's ship eventually was destroyed, leaving his body alongside Tew's in the ocean. However, Sam Drake was able to collect some of Avery's treasure, giving some of it to Elena Fisher.
