The Amityville Horror (Billy Love Story)

The Bad Babysitter

Time skip

The door to my room opened and I saw Billy walk in. "Hey, what's up?" I asked. "Mom and George got a babysitter." He says and sits on my bed.

"Don't worry okay? I'm here, isn't that good enough?" I asked. "Yeah, but Mom thinks you should rest with the headaches." He answered and we heard a knock on the door.

"Well, let's go meet the sitter." I said and drag him with me. She walked in and Billy was speechless. "I'm Lisa. Hi." She said.

"I'm Billy." He says and I growl, then go to Chelsea's room. I even heard him introduce himself again. "Hi Chelsea, hi Jodie." I said and they smiled.

"Hi Lizzy." They said. "So, the sitter's here and Billy seems to like her." I tell them. "Is her name Lisa?" Jodie asked.

"Yup." I asked. "She's a bad babysitter." She tells me. "I couldn't agree more. She dresses like no woman should and I could've sworn I smelt smoke." I tell them.

We go downstairs and play with Michael, then he goes upstairs. We walk upstairs and see them in her room. "Jodie says you're a bad babysitter." Chelsea says. "Yeah? Well Jodie's... What's the word? Dead." Lisa says and I gasped.

"Is not." Chelsea says and I kneel in front of her. "That little shit got me fired." She said.

"No, you got yourself fired. Have you looked in a mirror or smelled yourself lately? Chelsea, she is dead, but I didn't want to tell you, because you're too young. I'm sorry, but she's a nice girl." I said the last part to Lisa.

"You knew about them, Liz?" Billy asks. "Yes, I didn't say anything because your mom asked not to." I said and put Chelsea on my lap, as we sat on her bed. "You're not one of their kids, so who are you?" The 'babysitter' asks.

"Names Elizabeth and I've been living with the Lutz family for a while now." I say with a glare. "You're a bad sitter. With the way you dress and, um, yeah, I smelt the smoke. Also, no babysitter would swear in front of young children." I started to play with Chelsea's hair.

"Dare you to go in there." Billy says and I scoff. "You give me your Kiss poster if I do it?" She asked. "Okay." He said and my eyes widen.

"Billy, I gave you that poster. Why would you give it away?" I asked, with hurt in my eyes. "'Cause its mine." He says and I leave the room.

"Lizzy, please stay." I look at Chelsea, then leave and I come back with a book, as well as my sketchbook. Once I sat down, I got a headache and start drawing without looking at the page. I look down to see Jodie putting Lisa's finger into her bullet hole.

"You're going to make her mad." Chelsea said and I nodded, then the door suddenly closed. I slide the sketchbook under the door and she screams. "Told ya so." I said, then it comes back out.

"Look Chelsea." I show her the picture. "Is that Jodie?" She asked and I nodded.

"That's what she did to the mean sitter." Then I leave and go downstairs. "Eliza, did you tell them?" Kathy asked.

"No, the babysitter did." Billy says. I go upstairs and I see Chelsea in bed, then Kathy goes in. I go to my room, then Kathy walks in.

"Eliza, what happened?" She asked and I show her my sketchbook. "That's what Jodie did to Lisa." I said and she gave it back.

"Why would you draw that?" She asked. "Because I saw it before it happened." I said.

"How could you do that?" She asked. "I told you there was something wrong with me." I look through my sketches.

Then I show her the one of my parents. "This ring any bells?" I asked and she gasped. "Saw it before it happened." I said, then put it away.