Your Not Really A Date First Date:
Jack: You both got drunk and danced at a pub.
Will: He taught you the basics of sword fighting.
James: You got to know each other over tea.
Ragetti: You taught him how to read and write.
Pintel: He took you to a small pub and you tried a very unique but very good pastry!
Hector: He taught you how to fire a pistol with good aim.