Rachel showed up at the gym, where Jesse was waiting. "Ok, you ready to go?" Jesse asked. "After I sing the song I practice to sing to you." Rachel said. "Oh, ok." Jesse said. Rachel looked around. Where are they, Rachel thought. She saw them hiding. Rachel than sung the song that her and Finn sung, pretending. When she was finished she looked at Jesse. "Why did you sing that to me?" Jesse and everyone else wondered. "Because I realized that dating you was a mistake and I was only 'pretending' to believe that we were meant to be." Rachel said. Everyone was shocked including Rachel. Jesse got mad grabbed Rachel's arm. "What are you doing!" Rachel yelled. Jesse kissed her, but Rachel pulled away. "What the heck!" Rachel said feeling nothing. "You didn't feel anything?" Jesse said. Everyone leaned in to hear her answer. "No, sorry Jesse, but leave me alone." Rachel said. Jesse looked down and walked off. Someone walked up to Rachel and tapped her shoulder. Rachel turned around and smiled. "It's done Coop, thanks for the help." Rachel said and hugged him. "Who is that?" Everyone asked Blaine and Puck. They looked down. "Our older brother." Puck said. "Why didn't she trust you guys enough to tell you guys?" Max asked. "Don't know." Blaine said. "Ok guys, you can come out now!" Rachel yelled at them. They came out. Finn ran up to Rachel and hugged her. Rachel pulled away. Finn was confused. "I am sorry Finn, but I did mean that I was breaking up with you." Rachel said. "You don't need to keep up with the act." Finn said. "I am not acting about this." Rachel said. Everyone looked at her. "Rach, why are you breaking up with him?" Max asked. "Because, he said past on our past 20 dates because he is hanging out with the cheerleaders." Rachel said. "I just don't want to deal with that." Rachel said and walked off. Puck turned to Finn. "You past up the last 20 times to hang out with those cheerleaders and not our sister!" Puck said mad. Blaine, Coop, and Puck looked mad at him. "Yeah, but it was because I didn't know what to do." Finn said. Crash. "What was that?" Santana asked. They all looked at each and ran towards the noise. When they got there they saw Rachel looking at a poster. They all looked at the poster to see Santana and Finn kissing on it. Everyone looked at them. "Guess I was right all along, my heart can be broken 3 times in a row!" Rachel yelled and ran into the glee room. "How did these get out?" Santana asked. Everyone gasped. "So they aren't photoshopped!" Blaine said. Finn didn't know what to say. "Rachel stop!" Someone yelled. Everyone ran over to the glee room and saw Rachel sitting there destroying the song sheets. "What are you doing!" Puck yelled and got Rachel to stop. "Nothing, thanks, but now I am going home." Rachel said. "Not by yourself your not, Blaine, Coop watch her." Puck said. Rachel rolled her eyes. "Weird People!" Rachel yelled. Everyone was confused. Rachel got up. "Band hit it!" Rachel said to the band. Rachel sung the song and freaked everyone out. "What is going on with you!" Blaine yelled. "Just take me home." Rachel said. They left. "What just happened?" Max asked. "When you left and Jesse hurt Rachel, she wasn't as bad as that, but she changed in like another person." Puck said. "So your saying we created a monster?" Finn asked. Puck nodded. "Great." Everyone said.
The next day
"Have you seen Rachel today?" Puck asked. "No why?" Everyone asked. "She didn't show up to her last 3 classes." Blaine said. "Don't worry, I just didn't like those classes." Rachel said. Everyone turned around. "But you could have said something." Puck said. "I was getting people to join glee club." Rachel said and rolled her eyes. Finn looked at Rachel. "So I would like to introduce Sam, Sugar, and Unique!" Rachel said. They all walked in. Rachel sat down. "Rachel can we please talk." Finn said. "No, and since you said something, I will too, Mr. Shue can I sing something with the help of Santana, Quinn, and Brittney, I need some divas." "Rachel said. "Sure I guess." Mr. Shue said. "This is people that well can't take a hint." Rachel said looking at Finn and Max. They sung the song, Take A Hint. They finished the song and sat down but Rachel stayed up there. "I, umm also have some news." Rachel said nervously. "What?" Everyone asked. "I...." Rachel got cut off. "Is this the glee room?" Someone asked. They looked at the door to see a guy. "Yeah, and you are?" Puck said. "Brody." Brody said. Rachel looked at him. "I know you." Rachel said. "Sorry?" Brody asked. "Did you know someone as their nickname as Rae?" Rachel asked. Brody looked her curiosity. "Yeah, why?" Brody asked. "And did she call you Brody the biker?" Rachel asked. "Yeah, how did you know that?" Brody asked. "Yeah, how did you know that?" Everyone asked. Rachel smiled and turned around to Puck and Blaine. "You guys know and man did he get hot." Rachel said making Brody blush. Puck and Blaine were lost. "Oh come on, you guys called him Bro the toad!" Rachel yelled. This got their memories back in order including Brody's. "Bro the toad?" Finn asked. Rachel turned to Max. "Do you remember him?" Rachel asked. Max smiled because she was talking to him. "Yeah I do." Max said. Brody finally remembered. "Max the class pets!" Brody said making everyone laugh. "Why were you named that?" Quinn asked. "I loved to bring in stray animals into class and that's how I got the nickname." Max said. Puck and Blaine finally remembered and got up and punched him. "What are you guys doing!" Rachel yelled. "He is a criminal, Rachel, he is on the news." Puck yelled back. Rachel looked around. "So everyone I know are bad people." Rachel said making everyone stop. "What?" Puck asked. "Maybe I am not supposed to be good, if everyone I know is bad then what is the point of being good?" Rachel asked. Puck walked over to her. "No don't, I know my faith and the world is telling me to wake up and stop trying to help people your just making it worse." Rachel said. Everyone was shocked to hear her say this. "No it was just their decision to do what they did." Puck said. "I, I got to go." Rachel said and left to the stage. "What is getting her to act like this?" Kurt asked. Blaine looked around. "Us." Blaine said. "What." Everyone said. "We are making her feel this way,we are always fighting or showing up and messing things up." Blaine said. Finn got up and walked to the door. "Where are you going?" Puck asked. Finn stopped. "To get my girlfriend back." Finn said and went to find Rachel.
The stage
Rachel walked up to the stage and looked around. "Hey band, can you play the new song I wrote?" Rachel said as Finn walked in. The band nodded. They started up. Rachel started sing with dance moves she made. Wow, Finn thought about the song and dance moves. Rachel finished the song and Finn clapped making Rachel to jump. "Great job with that, was that your song?" Finn asked. "Yeah, I thought we could use it with loser like me." Rachel said. Finn looked confused. "You know for nationals." Rachel said. "Oh yeah." "What are you doing here?" "To talk to you a about what's going on." Rachel looked down. "I guess I am just upset that all the guys I care about turn on me." "But I never did that." "What about the picture on the wall?" "That was from your party when we all played spin the bottle." "Oh, I wondered why the floor looked like mine." Finn laughed. "So why did you always turned down my offer all the time?" "I don't know, nervous I guess." "About what?" "That you would break up with me." "Finn, why would I break up with you about that?" "I don't know, I am sorry." "It's fine, I am just happy you told me." "I am too." Rachel smiled and kissed him. "Does that mean we are back together?" Finn asked. "Yeah, we are." Rachel replied. "Come on." Finn said and grabbed Rachel's hand. "Where are we going?" Rachel asked. "To show everyone the amazing song you wrote for Nationals." Rachel smiled and went back into the glee room. Everyone looked up. "I have been writing a song for Nationals and would like it if you give me your feedback so we could sing it at Nationals." Rachel said. Everyone nodded happy to see her back to her normal self. Rachel started singing Light Up The World with the dance moves and they loved it. When she was done everyone clapped. Rachel smiled and looked out the window and her smile turned to a frown. "Oh my god!" Rachel yelled and ran outside. Everyone followed Rachel outside. When they got outside they saw a whole band there. "Rachel Berry?" Someone said. "Yeah?" Rachel said. "We are here to give you a little surprise." Another person said. "Ok?" Rachel said and looked at everyone and they shrugged. The band started doing the song Marry You. Rachel was laughing and was dragged into the middle of it all. She kept looking at Finn and he looked confused. "Did you do this?" Puck asked. "No." Finn said. Rachel was grabbed by her arm and onto the one float. "Finn, what's going on?" Everyone asked. "I don't know!" Finn yelled. They song ended and Rachel screamed. "Jesse stop!" Rachel yelled. "I don't love you!" Everyone looked up and ran to the float. "Marry me Rachel!" Jesse said. "Or Finn won't be around to see the age of 20." Then some of the band grabbed Finn and started taking him to deheader thing. "No please!" Rachel said. "We could also do it to everyone else is that what you want?" Jesse said. "Ok fine!" Rachel yelled. "No don't do it Rachel!" Everyone yelled. "Yes Jesse I will marry you." Rachel yelled and started crying. The band people let go of Finn and he ran up Rachel. "Don't do it please don't do it!" Finn said to Rachel. Everyone else ran up. Rachel cried harder. "I have to, I am sorry, I love you guys!" Rachel said. The band people started pushing the glee people off the float. "Rachel don't do it!" Everyone was yelling. "I will find you guys!" Rachel yelled back. "Don't count on it." Jesse said and pulled her into a car.
