Playing a game with killers in the closet (BEN & Jeff x Male! Reader)

Who knew killers could be humane? (Male Version)

(Y/N)s POV

I fell asleep at some point last night. How I know this is because I woke up groggily as the sun's annoying rays hit my face through the blinds that covered my windows and I was on the floor of my room. Last night was hectic to say the least. I wondered if those intruders were still downstairs. But.. Did I really wonder to the extent where I'd get up off the floor? I'm so comfy here and I'm tired.

I closed my eyes again to just think over a few things or possibly go to sleep again. That didn't stay long when I started to hear shouting from downstairs and it wasn't (f/n) name. By far. It sounded like two guys. And they kept saying 'hey what gives!?' And 'untie us!?'. I checked the clock and it was about eleven. (F/n) must be out doing whatever she does by now. Can't believe I slept that late? Damn. Good thing I didn't intend on going to school today.

Picking myself off the ground, the decision to go see the two boys downstairs was made. I really didn't want to but what else is there? I can't leave them screaming down there. So I didn't even bother to put on some clothes since at some point in the night, I kicked off my pants and tore off my shirt. Bare chested and lazy as fuck, I walked downstairs to see the two who were screaming. I looked like I just had sex, my hair was a mess and I didn't look one bit happy.

"Can you two shut the hell up? Please? I pretty damn tired you know" I scolded softly, walking over to the two and bending down to meet their level. Since (f/n) dumped them on the floor, they were laying down.

"Now explain yourselves to me" I said as I sat right in front of the black haired one criss-cross style.

"Yeah I would if your dick wasn't right in my face, move away from me!" He said grumpily. Clearly he didn't like being tied up but I didn't like intruders so we were even. I did move though, moved away from his face at least. A small blush dusted his cheeks as i did and I decided to just dismiss it.

"Well? What? Why are you in my home?" I repeated simply. The other one decided to speak up. The blond short elf.

"We were told to check this place out. A weird energy has been sensed here. At least it was yesterday it was. We needed to investigate." He explained to me. That sounded dumb. What 'energy' were they talking about? I was trying to think of what they could possibly mean before the elf boy spoke up again. "Do you even know who we are?"

I blinked. Why would I know who they are? A bunch of weirdo fantasy enthusiast? Cosplayers that take roleplaying way too seriously?

"No I don't. Why would I?" I asked and the black hair one scoffed. The blond one chuckled a bit. Where they some kind of famous thing in some offshoot show or something. Like a prank show. Cuz if they think I'll let them go for that, I won't.

"Go get a device with wifi on it then" The taller one told me in a gruff, commanding voice. I didn't want to listen just because he thinks he can tell me what to do but I decide to do it anyway because I was curious. I scowled and got up, coming back with my phone.

"Alright now look up 'BEN drowned' and 'Jeff the Killer'." The elf instructed. I hesitantly typed that into the search bar and looked through the results. Curiously I put images and started to laugh.

"W-what's so funny!?" Jeff shouted. I showed him a cute picture of him and Ben kissing (Above). His pale skin was soon cherry red and BEN as well. I assumed that the one with the blood stained hoodie was Jeff since he had killer as a title and BEN was the elf because of the water from the tv thing.

"DONT LOOK US UP TOGETHER, I MEANT SEPARATELY" BEN yelled and I decided to just comply since I already flustered them enough. It took a little while but I found the original back story and bio for both. Also how much they were wanted for.