Creepypasta x Proxy!Reader one-shots (requests open)

Forgotten Birthday

♤ Note: don't know your birthday or sally's so it's just gonna be 3days after yours that's sally's b-day♤

Sally's birthday was today, even though some creepypasta are immortal they still celebrate birthdays as a day for them. Everyone decorated and got presents for the immortal 8 year old, you made the cake. Everyone loved your food, sally was super happy food, soda (BEN and Jeff sneaked it in) and sally had many more toys to play with. Birthday's were the ONLY day nobody went killing, soon it was dark and sally went to sleep, everyone cleaned up and went to bed.

♡~Time skip by Sally with cake~♡

The next morning you woke up and started making breakfast for everyone, kidneys for EJ, Waffles for Toby, cheesecake for Masky and Hoodie, Candy for LJ, Coffee for slender and French Toast for everyone else. Soon all were eating and talking when sally got a thinking face slender saw and asked "what is wrong my child?" Sally looked at slender "when is (y/n)'s birthday?" Slenderman look suprised and thought, everyone look suprised and all thought "Its......I don't know" slenderman sighed and looked at you, everyone then turned to you.  "....what?" You asked "when is your bday?" Sally said. You tilted your head, "....why does it matter?" Jeff groans at you "you've been her 7 years and I don't remember celebrating it ever." Sally said. "T-t-that c-can't be t-true!" Toby said, everyone thought hard. You giggle "don't worry about it, no we never celebrated it" Everyone gasped, "you knew and never told us!!!" they yell, "didn't seem important" you said with a poker face. "IT'S IMPORTANT!" Sally stood on the chair and shouts at you,  tears fall from her eyes. "It's  (hic) for you, (hic) t-the day you were born so you could (sniffles) be with us now" she cries. You frown, "I didn't realize it was that important to you", Jeff hugs sally "well, now that you made her cry at least tell her your birthday" Jeff says angry. You sigh "if you must know it's  (y/b)" Everyone's eyes widen "That's four days before sally's! " BEN shouts, you nod. "Why didn't you ever tell us?" Slender asks, you shrug "I don't like being the center of attention, don't like my birthday, didn't seem important, didn't want to bother anyone, and....you never asked" you stated. Slender glared at you, "we won't forget next year" clockwork growls. You shrug not caring, "never know you might get amnesia." Everyone glares at you.
You laugh. "Or I might just skip out on it." BEN tries to tackle you, you douged. Everyone huffs.

♡~time skip by BEN'S rage~♡
It was the night before your birthday, knowing they'd remember because of your failed attempt to make them loses their memories you go to your room and place a deco you on your bed and exit the room through the window. 'I am NOT celebrating my birthday' you thought.

The next morning Sally goes to your room giggling because it's your birthday but when she jumps on you to wake you up she sees a pillow, she shakes in anger "(Y/N)!!!!" she screams birds fly away. You hear the scream from your hidden place in a coffin, you chuckled "good luck finding me"

◇ who is gonna find you?
●A creepypasta pasta?
○Me?
●an OC?
○Death?
●No one?

Hehehehe tell me in a comment who YOU want◇