That's What You Get: Hayley Williams + Andy Biersack + Josh Farro (sequel to TOE)

Chapter 1

Hayley's P.O.V.

"Josh!!!" I felt my knees buckle, my body felt heavy, and all I remember was falling, and someone catching me.

I woke up, hoping it was all a nightmare. I was in my bed, as if I was sleeping. Andy stood over me, his eyes full of concern. "Hayley, are you all right?" I nodded feebly. I saw Josh leaning against the doorway, cleaning underneath his nails nonchalantly. All of the memories came flooding back. I leaned against the headboard, my knees pulled to my chest. "Andy! Get him away from me!" I hissed. Andy climbed on top of the bed, and grabbed my hand. "Shhh, shhh. It's okay darling." Andy soothed. "Darling? What kind of sick crud is that?!" Josh scoffed. I pulled myself under the covers, hoping to get away. "Andy!! Make him leave!!" I wailed. Andy coughed. "Um, Josh, would you kindly leave? Me and Hayley, have some... discussions to make." Andy said politely. "Fine." Josh grunted. I heard the front door slam. I poked my head out of the covers. "Is he gone?" Andy went under the covers with me. "He's gone, but... who is he?" I blinked. "My exboyfriend." Andy looked confused. "Then why is he here?" "Um.....We might not have been officially broken up...." I bit my lip. "Are you cheating on him?!" "It was a long-distance relationship, it never would have worked out!!" Andy shook his head. "Are you still leaving?" "Yes, I just don't like the look of this guy. He caught you when you fainted." Josh caught me?! I thought he hated me! Andy took my face in his hands. "Just don't talk to him, or hang with him. I'll probably get jealous." The thought of Andy getting jealous filled my mind. I giggled. "Same to you. And you KNOW how I get jealous." I giggled again. Andy pulled off the covers and stood back up. "Well, I guess I have to go." He yawned and stretched, I hugged him midstrech. Andy walked to the living room, gathered up his luggage and left. He blew me a kiss, and I caught it and put it in my pocket, saving it for later.

Andy's P.O.V.

Hayley pulled away from me. Her eyes got glazed over. She hasn't done this in a while. "Josh!!" Hayley shouted. I felt her collapse, but I didn't catch her. The man standing in the doorway raced over and caught her gently, like he has done this a thousand times. Who the heck is this guy??! How did he get in my house?! "Well don't just stand there! Show me a place we can let her rest." The man demanded, flinging Hayley over his back, like she was just a lifeless rag doll. "Don't swing her around like that! She's fragile." I scolded. "Don't you think I know that? I've held her before." The man said. I reluctantly led the man to my bedroom, and he tucked her into my bed. The man leaned against the doorway, is it his hobby or something? "Now excuse me, who the heck are you and why are you in my house?" I asked. "Josh. Josh Farro." The man snapped. Oh no. This is the guy who hurt Hayley. "How do you know Hayley?" I demanded. "She's my girlfriend, I think. I thought she would wait around, because I thought she was loyal. Apparently not, that sl-" I saw Hayley twitch. I leaned over her unconscious body. She opened her eyes, and with a pang of guilt, I asked her if she was alright. I knew she wasn't, but I had asked anyways. Hayley noticed Josh leaning against the doorway. Her face, was doused in fright, her eyes pleading. She curled up into a ball against the headboard of the bed. "Andy! Get him away from me!" Hayley cried. I turned around and glanced at the man standing in the doorway. He had his eyebrow raised, amusingly. "Shhh, shh. It's okay darling." I cooed. I heard Josh snicker behind me. "Darling? What kind of sick crud is that?!" Hayley retreated under the covers. "Andy!! Make him leave!!" She wailed. I cleared my throat. "Um, Josh, would you kindly leave? Me and Hayley have some...... discussions to make." I bit my lip. "Fine." Josh left, slamming the front door in his wake. "Is he gone?" Hayley poked her head out of the covers like a groundhog. I climbed into bed with her, pulling the cover over our heads. "He's gone, but.... who is he?" I sighed. Hayley looked appalled. "My exboyfriend." An exboyfriend?! "Then why is he here?" Hayley bit her lip. "Um.... We might not have been officially broken up..." Hayley guessed. Is Hayley cheating on him with me??!!!! This can't happen again. "Are you cheating on me?" I tried to regain my cool. I even wrote a song for her!! How could she!! "It was a long-distance relationship, it never would have worked out!" Hayley explained. I took a deep breath and shook my head. "Are you still leaving?" Hayley asked, whiny. "Yes, I just don't like the look of this guy. He caught you when you fainted." I cupped her small face with my hands and made her look me in the eyes. "Just don't talk to him, or hang with him. I'll probably get jealous." I admitted. Hayley giggled, sounding like the girl I knew was in her. "Same to you. And you KNOW how I get jealous." She giggled again. How could this beautiful girl cheat? I wouldn't believe it, even if she told me. I got out of the bed. "Well, I guess I have to go." I yawned and stretched my achey back. Hayley hugged me while I was still stretching. I walked to the living room and grabbed all of my stuff. Hayley watched me leave, sadly. I blew her kiss, and I watched her put it in her pocket, for later.