Warrior Cats: What If?

Pinestar the Kittypet

(Yes, this question has been asked many times, I'd just like to answer it myself)
___________________________
What if Pinestar never left ThunderClan?
---

Let's just think things out first.

One, Pinestar was the father of Tigerclaw (I refuse to call him a -star), and had a huge affect of Tigerclaw becoming evil (in my opinion) because his father abandoned him. How would you feel if that happened to you?

So, if Pinestar never left, Tigerclaw would probably be a good, loyal warrior that doesn't kill random cats just to become leader. Of course, with Thistleclaw as his mentor, it might corrupt him a bit, but Pinestar would have solved that problem eventually. With the help of Bluestar of course...

Now, with Tigerclaw not evil, there would be no need for Rusty's (later on Firestar) assistance. He would have NEVER came to the forest!

Mind blown

Without Firestar, Spottedleaf would still be alive, Sandstorm would probably end up being mates with Dustpelt. Cinderpelt would have never broken her leg, Yellowfang wouldn't have died in that fire, and Runningwind wouldn't have died. I know there's more, but do I rlly have to type all of those poor dead cats?

My StarClan, Pinestar, you've got a lot to hold on your paws :I

That's not even it! Without Firestar and Sandstorm becoming mates, there'd be no Squirrelflight or Leafpool!

(Guess that's a plus for Ashfur)

And without Squirrelflight and Leafpool, no Power of Three!

Buh-bye Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze :(

And no Ivypool of Dovewing... (yay...no Dovewing...)

Oh, and with Squirrel gone, they wouldn't have found Midnight and wouldn't have left their clans

No biggie

They could have of course chose another cat, but who could they find to top Squirrelflight?!

Oh, almost forgot. Tigerclaw would have stayed with Goldenflower, which means Hawkheart and Mothflight wouldn't have existed. Which means Ivypool wouldn't have been Dark Forest! Yay!

Well, let's give Pinestar a round of applause for being the cause of the many death of cats :3

Why couldn't you just be a loyal leader Pinestar...?

But hey, we have Squirrelflight!

       0                                0
                      3