Eaden's point of view
"Truth" Henry said when Owen gave him the two options. Owen thought for a moment.
"What is the name of the hottest girl you've had sex with?" Owen said, prying. Henry didn't like to share this stuff.
"Your mom."
I rolled my eyes. "Dude. Couldn't think of anything better for a comeback?" I said, sighing after. This game is lame with no girls.
"Fine, truth or dare Eaden?" Henry retaliated.
"Dare, dumbass."
"I dare you to go knock on the doors down the hall until you find a girl who will join our game." I guess he had the same thought I did. I stood and walked out into the hallway of the apartment building. The boys stood in the doorway and watched, giggling. I walked down to the very other end for no reason and knocked on door 507. A middle aged woman answered the door. Probably 35 or 40 years old.
"Hi," I said confidently, "my friends and I are playing truth or dare and I was dared to find someone to join our game. Would you care to-" she flipped me off and slammed the door shut. I mumbled to myself, "I didn't want you there anyway, Jesus."
I went to the next door as Matthew yelled, "Come back Eaden, it's fine, just take your loss."
I knocked on 506. No answer. I turn to walk away but the door opened and a beautiful girl stood there in front of me, hair tucked in a messy bun and phone in hand. She wore a snug flower dress and no shoes. She stared right at me.
"Can I help you?" The beautiful voice came from that beautiful girl. I struggled to remember why I was here.
"Uh-uhm, well, I'm playing truth or dare and I'm supposed to find a girl to join us.. would you care to help me keep my pride and let me get past this crappy dare?" I stumbled out my words.
She looked like she was actually considering. A moment passed.
"I've got nothing better to do," she shrugged, "One second." She closed the door and went back inside. I got excited that she was coming, then extremely nervous. Why? Good question.The boys were giggling again. "Bro! Just give up!" Owen yelled, but I knew she was coming.
Clarissa's pov
I hurried to fix my hair and grab my keys. Hot boys, truth or dare, Saturday night? Feels like a hell yes to me. I opened the door and smiled at the nice hunk of meat standing in front of me. "Okay. Let's go." He lead me down the hall to the group of boys leaning out the door. "Hiya boys. I'm Clarissa, but please call me Claire or something." I went right over to the couch and sat. The boys sat too. Silence. Could they not believe I came? "Do we need an icebreaker? Go around the circle and say names and favourite dessert?" I smiled at them all. "Hi, my name is Claire and I like brownies. Not the kind with weed." They laughed at my joke. Phew.
"I'm Henry," the boy sitting next to me on the two seater said, "and this is Owen, Matt, and Eaden." He said while pointing at each boy.
"Home." I said. They looked confused. "It's the first letter of each of your names..? Nevermind. You said you were playing truth or dare?" I inquired while making eye contact with Eaden. He nodded.
"I'm sick of that game." Matt whined and went and grabbed 5 bottles of beer.
Henry sighed when he saw what he was doing but Owen got excited.
"Never have I ever!" Owen shouted and helped set up. I smiled not having played since 10th grade...
Eaden started to apologise but I stopped him. "This will be fun. I haven't done this in a long time." A smile crept on his face.The game began.
Beer in hand, we sat on the two couches all squished together. The love chair had me and Henry and the three seat had Owen, Eaden, and Matt.
"I wanna start!" I said getting hyped for the game. They agreed to let me. "Never have I ever made out with someone with more than a 5 year age difference."
Owen took a swig. Matt nodded in appreciation.
Henry was next. "Never have I ever done anything sexual with the same gender." This made me take a swig of the beer and I saw Owen hesitate.
"Come on, I can tell you have. Drink up." I told him. Embarrassed, he took a swig.
"Story!!!" Eaden yelled. I smiled.
"Who first?"
Eaden contemplated. "Claire."
"Well," I started, a blush already creeping on my face, "it was in eleventh grade, and I was just becoming friends with this girl and she came over to stay the night for the first time. The door was closed which made her more comfortable to grab me and then kiss me. I didn't know she was into girls and that's what was happening but she thought that's why I invited her over. I decided to not stop it because in high school you need to experience everything, right? So one thing led to another and in the morning we both woke up naked... under my mothers glare... your turn Owen."
He gulped, nervous most likely because of his friends. All he said was, "Sometimes you have to suck a dick to know you don't like sucking dick." We all laughed.
The game continued.
A few hours passed and we were all tipsy, having drunk more than one beer. My legs were swung over Henry and I kept making eye contact with Eaden... he was watching me. The embarrassing secrets had just started to come out and now we were mostly just story telling.
"And that's why I have teeth marks on my back." Matt finished. He pulled up his shirt to show us and sure enough, that horny girl did leave a scar.
"Never have I ever had sex." I said, remembering that after Matts story. The boys looked astonished that me, a 22 year old hasn't ever been laid. They all took a drink. "Well." I said smiling and we giggled.
A hour more of stories went by. Henry was asleep next to me, still clinging onto that beer.
"I should go home it's," I looked at my phone, "Wow. Late. Like, 3 in the morning late."
"You mean early?" Eaden corrected. I gave him a playful glare, then stood up and smoothed my dress down.
"Thanks for the fun night guys. See you around." I went for the door and Eaden came after me, stepping into the chilly hallway with me.
"Hello," I said.
"Can I get your number? This is Henry's apartment and I don't live around here..." he mumbled, making me smile. I took the phone out of his hands and entered my number under the name of 'Hot Girl ;-)' and handed back the phone. His face lit up and he blushed.
"Just give me a call. It'd be fun to hang out again. With or without all your friends." I leaned in and kissed his cheek. "Goodnight Eaden."
"Goodnight Claire."
With that, I went down the hall and back into my room without glancing back.
YOU ARE READING
I love you. ...What?
RomanceI don't quite know where this is going, but give it a chance, romance and smut are my best friends. (Also this is slightly based off 5SOS)