Peter Pan X Reader

Stories

(Ymn)- your middle name
---------------
Peter Pan's POV
We have to find her. She's a tough one. She could be quite useful to us. "Come on boys!" I yelled and we headed out. We all split up looking in different directions. I headed towards the Neverland Falls. There were mermaids, and mermen swimming everywhere. "Hey Lily." I called and a mermaid with blonde hair swam over to me. "Yes Pan?" She asked. "I'm looking for someone. I want to know if you've seen her. She has (Hc), and (Ec), she goes by the name Wolf. I never her got her real name which is unfortunate, cause it'll make this harder. But I will find her. After all Peter Pan never fails." I said. "I did see her... But I-I... Oh! Have you met our new Merfriend? Scarlet, come here I want you to meet someone!" Lily yelled. Then a mermaid with a red tail that faded to silver, hair that faded from black to red, and (Ec) eyes. "Y-you called Li-- w-who i-is this?" She asked. Shy? She doesn't look like she would be. I just smirked. "Hello love. I'm Peter. Peter Pan." I said.

Your POV
I was hidden under the disguise and name of Scarlet a mermaid I created in my head. Pan had just introduced himself. "I-I-I'm..... I'm Sc-Sc-" I stuttered, whimpered and looked down as part of an act so he wouldn't recognize me. "Scarlet. So I've been told. Where are you from?" He asked. "I-I." I stuttered then pretended to have a headache and I started forcing myself to breath heavily. "Hey, hey. Scarlet, look at me. Breath in. Breath out." Lily told me. She was part of the act. I did like she told me. "What's wrong with her?" Pan asked. "She gets a terrible migraine every time she tries to remember something from her past. We found her laying against the rocks almost dead. She couldn't remember anything but her name." Lily said not looking at Pan. "That's quite believable," Pan started. Uh oh. "Unfortunately for you I know it's not true." He finished. Lily pulled away from me. She turned toward Pan. "Come on Wolf. Change back to normal you're not fooling me." Pan said to me. I slowly changed back. "Now what should I do with you for lying to me." Pan said looking at Lily. "Take your heart perhaps?" He said reaching his hand toward her chest to rip out her heart. "Stop! I'll come with you if you don't hurt her." I said. He smirked. "Deal." He said. I climbed out and walked away with him.

Peter Pan's POV
"W-what are you going to do with me?" She asked. I just stayed quiet and kept walking. After awhile we made it back to camp and all the Lost Boys were there. "Found our little Wolf." I said. "What are you gonna do with me... I ran." She said again. "Felix, put her in the cage." Pan said. "No. You don't have to put me there. I'll just... I'll just go." She said and walked toward the cage, got in and shut the door. Then she went up. "Why was she so... Willing?" Felix asked me. "She's trying to protect a friend. Too bad, love is weakness." I said. "Be careful what you say Pan. It wouldn't be the first time you've said that and fallen. What--" Arrow (idk any other Lost Boy names from the show. I don't remember them so I made this one up, sorry!) started. I looked at him and glared. "You will never speak of that again, unless you want your heart ripped out." I threatened. He nodded

Your POV
"You will never speak of that again, unless you want your heart ripped out." Pan said. Speak of what? "Do you really think love is weakness?" I asked. I immediately regretted it. "Yes." He replied simply. "Why?" I asked and once again regretted it. "Boys. Leave us." He said, and lowered the cage. He opened the door. "I'm sorry, the question slipped I--" I started. He snapped his fingers and I stayed quiet. "I think--- I know love is weakness because last time when I thought someone loved me... She betrayed me... All of us." He said. "She was working for my greatest enemy besides Rumplestiltskin... Hook." He said through gritted teeth. I looked away. "Can I tell you something and then hope you don't kill me." I said still not looking at him. "No promises but I can try." He said. "From what I've been told you know Emma, a-and Henry." I said. "The truest believer and his mother, yes I know them." He said. I was still looking away. "I know you know Hook. Hook and Emma eventually got married... And they had a kid... A daughter, her name was (Yn) she didn't know her mother for years. After she finally when Emma was revealed as her mother the celebrated. Not long after that, the house they were in caught fire. She just so happened to be losing control of her powers... They were in there Blackbeard started the fire..." I trailed I had tears in my eyes at this point.

Peter Pan's POV
She looked at me with tears in her eyes I looked back at her. "No." I whispered. Did I just make Hook's daughter... A Lost Girl? "Hi Pan... I'm (Yn) "Hookette" (Ymn) Jones. It's a pleasure to meet you."