My Acting Nightmare

A forgotten friendship

Sabrina's P.O.V
The next day I walked into Southside feeling amazing! I was finally a part of a real group of friends! Sure they don't know everything about me but I'll tell them when the time is right. "Oh hey there Sab!" Said Toni who was the last person I wanted to see right now. "What do you want Toni?" I asked but secretly hoping she'd just leave. "I was wondering if you'd seen Jughead around lately? Oh are you two still dating or did he leave you for the bimbo again?" She asked. "He's not dating anyone." I said I didn't want to be the one to tell her about Jughead. I didn't think he wanted the whole of Southside knowing about it. "Oh he isn't is he?" She said. "He's not going to date you Toni!" I said "Oh wow really someone's jealous. You know he's kissed me before." She said smirking. "Oh yeah when? I haven't seen him talk to you in weeks." I said "Oh the first day we meet. It was in the dark room. Let me tell you he wanted me that day,until you." She said "It wasn't my fault. You shouldn't have done that he had a girlfriend at the time." I said "Ha that didn't stop you!" She said. "I didn't date him until after Betty dumped him for Archie!" I screamed. "But you wanted him all along." She said "Now I'm gonna date him so." She said "Good luck with that!" I said. She's so annoying!
Betty's P.O.V
I was in the hallway talking to Veronica, when Cheryl walked up to us. I could never tell when Cheryl was going to be mean or nice? My usual guess was mean though. "Hello friends!" She said "So that's what we are now friends?" I asked Cheryl. "Oh yeah of course! You guys saved my life! What could bond people more?" She said. "Um okay?" I said unsure. "Oh and Betty as your friend I should probably tell you about Sabrina." I said "What about her?" I asked "Um duh the fact that you were so blind and didn't realize that her and Jughead are still together?" She said. "What no you're lying he's--" I started. "Oh what asexual I know he told you that. It's clearly a lie!" She said. "Think about it he's alone in that Serpent school all day with her. You would never know if he's with her or not? I don't trust her and I don't know why you two do so much?" She said. "That's cause she's our friend. She's never done anything to us?" Said Veronica. "Oh really so you know everything about her?" Said Cheryl. "Yes!" I said confidently. "So you know that she's a witch?" She asked. "What? That's ridiculous there's no such thing? You could've come up with a more realistic thing for her to hide?" Said Veronica. "Just look at the facts. She's never around you guys late at night. She beat up Reggie for picking on Jughead whose twice the size of her. For all you know she could be using her magic to make him fall in love with her. Even if our dear friend Jug was telling the truth she could manipulate him!" She said "It does kind of make sense? But I still want to see this for myself." I said. "Ok I have a friend named Toni over at Southside. We can meet her there and she can see what's going on with those two. I'm only trying to look out for you Betty. Now let's go deal with the real Serpent Slut!" We left Riverdale going to Southside. I had only been there once before but the place scared me. I needed to find out the truth though!
Sabrina's P.O.V
I ran to find Jughead. "Hey are you okay? Has Toni been here?" I asked. "Um yeah she just walked past me? Why?" I asked "Juggie did you kiss her before?" I asked "Well yes and no. She kissed me in the dark room my first day at Southside. But I didn't have feelings for her obviously." I said "Ok I believe you!" I said as I hugged him. As I was hugging him Toni walked by and pushed me so Jug and I were kissing. Just then Betty, Veronica and Cheryl walked in. Well shit I have some explaining to do!
Betty's P.O.V
"What did I tell you?" Said Cheryl as we watched Sabrina and Jughead kiss. "Wow Jug I didn't think you were going to make up a lie like this to be with Sabrina!" I started walking away. "Tell me the truth. Are you a witch Sabrina?" I asked. "Yes how did you--" I started "Save it! You're manipulating Jughead to like you! You can't accept him for who he is so you use magic to have a fake relationship with him?" She asked. "What that's ridiculous Toni pushed me into him. That's why we were kissing." I said. "Oh yeah a very likely story. Sabrina you didn't tell us the truth before. Why should I believe you now?" I said "Betty I'm me. She's never used her magic on me before, ever?" I said. "Oh and you knew this entire time she was a witch and didn't tell us?" She said. "It wasn't my job to tell it was Bri's secret!" He said. "Sabrina I'm sure you guessed since you lied to all of us enough that you're out of the inner circle!" I said "What but I didn't-" I started. "No you kept the biggest secret from all of us!" I said "Jug you need to choose it's us or her!" I said. Jughead looked like he was going to cry. "I'm so sorry Sabrina." He said. As he walked out with Veronica and I.
Sabrina's P.O.V
"Payback sucks doesn't it?" Said Toni. "Why did you have to ruin my life!?" I yelled at her. "Cuz you ruined mine! Everyone wanted me until you came to school in your short skirts and heels!" She said. "I tried to be your friend and you kicked me to the curb and stole my one best friend! You even played me into thinking that YOU liked ME!" She yelled. "I-I never realized that?" I said. "Well now I have Cheryl. She's helped me get my revenge!" She said. "Congrats to you!" I said almost crying. "Hey I didn't keep the biggest secret from my best friends. You made that mistake on your own. Now you get the payback you deserve!" She said walking away! "You don't know me Toni! You don't know that I think of myself as completely worthless and ugly! You don't know the real me! I starved myself and was evil to everyone before Jughead! I need him in my life, to live." I said quitter. "I'm so sorry that you never got to meet the real me...and that you never will! I said as I hugged Toni. She looked a bit confused but listened to what I said. "Why should I believe any of this? You just want pity?" Said Toni. "Why would I open up to you again? Now!?" I said. "But you aren't dating Jughead? How can he help you live?" She asked. "Were each other's support one can't live without the other? It's just how we work! Please Toni I need him back!" I was crying on her now. "Wow you're serious! I've never seen you like this? I didn't know he meant that much to you?" She said. "Toni what are you doing?" Asked Cheryl. "Your friends saved your life. Now I have to go save my friends life!" She said. We both walked out of Southside together to go find Jughead!