Secret Wish
WARNINGS: Two men, multiple orgasms, double penetration
“Why on earth would you want to know that?!” I ask, shocked at the inquiry made by my long time boyfriend.
“Because we have played out every single one of my fantasies, let’s play out yours."
"But… Mine isn’t like your fantasies, Cas, mine aren’t biblical… At all…”
“I don’t mind.”
“Cas, mine involves kinky sex.” I say bluntly, trying to get him off the topic.
“I’m sorry, I do not understand that reference.”
I groan, “It means strange sex. Like… Being tied up while having sex and stuff…"
"So you want me to tie you up during our sexual intercourse?” He asks slowly.
I blush and bite my lip, “Not exactly… I umm… I want to have… Sex… With you… And another guy…” I close my eyes, “At the same time…” I whisper.
________________
I come back to the bunker after an annoying Vengeful Spirit ruined my day. I go upstairs to Cas and I’s bedroom hoping he’d give me a back massage before bed.
I get to our room and see both a naked Dean and a naked Cas…
I quickly begin to back out of the room but with the sound of wings I feel Castiel’s warm body behind me.
“We’ve been waiting for you, Love.” He whispers in my ear.
“What’s going on…” I ask softly, my breathing heavy and my senses VeRy aware of both Cas’s body pressed against my back and Dean’s smirking in our direction.
Castiel nibbles on my ear lobe before moving to my front and pulling me to our bed. He kisses me as he unbuttons my flannel shirt. A shirt borrowed from Sam to be honest.
As my shirt is removed and my bra unclasped I watch Dean wearily. He’s watching Cas and I hungrily with lust blown eyes. Unsure of what to do or say I just stare then look down at Cas who is now removing my pants. He gives me a small reassuring smile and says, “It’s ok. He’s agreed to accompany me in pleasuring you sexually tonight.”
“Oh…” I say softly.
Dean gets up and comes over placing his lips on my own, igniting my stomach with butterflies. I lift my hips up as I feel Cas’s mouth at my pussy. He spreads my outer lips with two fingers before using his tongue and going to town causing a long drawn out moan to leave my mouth.
Dean looks down to Cas, “Can we get to the fun now?"
Castiel smiles ruefully, knowing he’s in charge before nodding and moving his body so Dean can position himself at my entrance.
Dean pushes in and I scream out in pleasure before Castiel shirts my scream with a kiss.
While Dean finds a rhythm that drives me wild I moan and meet his thrusts with my own. Cas has long since removed his lips from mine and is just watching.
"Castiel, please….” I moan.
He pats my hair back and whispers, “What? What is it that you want?”
“I need you in me…” I moan out as Dean hits my g-spot.
“Dean, move."
"No.” I say quickly.
“Then how?” Cas asks.
Jesus! I can’t form words while I’m like this. “Together… Same hole… God please!” I moan out loudly as Dean hits my spot once more.
“Same hole?” Dean stops. “[YN] that’ll hurt like son of a Bitch.”
“I know.” I say squirming to get him to move.
“Ok, slowly Castiel. Very slowly.” Dean instructs.
Cas nods stiffly, I can see the worry etched on her face. He positions himself as Dean moves to enlarge my hole, the stretching hurts slightly but it’s fine. Cas pushes in and I scream in pain.
“Its ok, it’s ok. I’m here.” Cas murmurs in my ear as he stills, allowing me to adjust.
“Just. Move.” I gasp out.
Cas moves slowly while Dean continues to remain still. The pain overrides my senses. Castiel puts two fingers to my forehead and I relax as warmth spreads everywhere. Then immense pleasure spreads. Dean starts moving with Castiel and I’m automatically a moaning mess.
I feel the clenching in my stomach the means I’m close when I feel Dean’s cock shudder, signalling he’s close too.
As both boys tips hit my g-spot I come undone in whirlwind of pleasure. Dean then spurts his sead into me then pulls out.
Cas moves so he’s hovering over me and starts pounding into me with a force that no human could produce. I feel myself fall over the edge again and again until I can’t tell how many orgasms I’ve had.
Soon I’m spent and Cas hasn’t even cum once. “Cas… I can’t anymore…” I say weakly.
He slows so he’s barely thrusting, “Once more babe, just once more.” He begs. I nod and he speeds to a normal human pace and I’m gone again, and this time he’s gone with me.
Once I’ve come down from my high, I look around, Dean is gone and Castiel has me curled up next to him, holding me in a warm protective hug.
He kisses my forehead and whispers, “Sleep, my human.”
