BLOOD is my Favorite Color (Bloody Painter/Helen Otis X Reader)

Chapter Twelve

YN POV:

"Glitchy Red!" He waves shyly.

"I'm here t-too." Lost Silver says, peeking his head over Red's shoulder.

"I still feel so privileged to be here. All my life I've read about Creepypastas, and now they're all right here in front of me. And to top it off, I'm going to be a Creepypasta. Are you sure I'm not dreaming?" BEN, Jeff, Red, and Silver shake their heads, grinning. I squeal, grabbing Jeff's hand and pulling him to his feet. I jump on his back again, throwing him a bit off-balance.

"Neigh." BEN, Red, and Silver burst out laughing. I smile at them and point to the kitchen.

"I'm hungry. Onwards, Jeffery!"

"I was about to ask how you knew my real name, but then I remembered you're a fangirl." I nod, grinning stupidly.

"Food."

Jeff POV:

This girl is light. She's practically a feather. Either that, or I'm just really strong.

I'll go with the latter.

"What do you want, kiddo?" She thinks for a moment before pointing to the fridge.

"Cheese." I stare at her (like I have a choice), extremely confused. "Did I stutter? I said I want cheese." She says playfully. I walk over to the fridge and open it.

"We have swiss, provolone, cheddar-"

"(Choice), please. By the way, where's Toby?"

"R-Right here, why?" He says, walking over to us.

"I want a waffle. And you make the best waffles." That twitching time bomb practically flies to the cupboards, pulling out the ingredients for his waffles.

I however, am very confused.

"You want waffles and cheese?" She nods, nibbling on her (choice) cheese. "You're weird."

"So? You are too."

Can't argue with that.

"At least I'm beautiful."

"You might be beautiful, but I'm fabulous." She says, trying to do a sassy hair flip.

It just flies, landing in her eyes. AN: Sorry if you have short hair, I couldn't think what would happen if you failed a hair flip and had short hair.
Also, I rhymed!

"Don't judge me."

Toby POV:

Waffles!

This new girl, Insomnia I think her name was, is automatically a person I think I'll like.

If you like waffles, then you're instantly my friend.

Anyway, I grabbed all the waffle ingredients, and now I'm making fresh waffles.

My recipe is the best.

Insomnia said so.

If I remember correctly, Slendy said her real name was YN.

I think it's a nice name.

"Waffles." Insomnia says, still on Jeff's back. I turn to them, and she has a panicked expression on her face. She just points to something behind me.

My waffles!

I unplug the waffle iron immediately, letting out a sigh of relief.

"Toby, you should be more careful! What if the house burnt down? The waffles would be ruined!"

"J-Just take the waffle." I say, grinning a bit. She practically snatches it from my hand. It's still warm, so she puts a slice of (choice) cheese on it and watches as it melts.

"Cheesy Waffle Supreme! My favorite!" She says, taking a bite. Jeff and I stare at her like she grew a second head. "Don't knock until you try it." I shrug, turning around to make more waffles.

YN POV:

Cheesy Waffle Supreme is actually quite tasty! And Toby's waffles make it taste ten times better!

Jeff carried me to BEN's room while I'm still eating. He drops me on the bed, causing me to drop my delicious delicacy.

"MY CHEESY WAFFLE SUPREME! NUUUUUUUUU!"

"Sorry. I'll make you another one." I shoot my head up to stare at him with flaming eyes.

"You better." And with that, Jeff picks up my deceased treat and runs out of the room while BEN, Red, and Silver walk in. "Hey guys!"

"Hey." They answer simultaneously. I grin, crossing my legs and putting my hands in my lap.

"Games. Now."

BEN POV:

"Ok." I turn on the (console),  popping in FG. When I turn around, YN is leaning forward, her EC eyes glistening in excitement. Jeff walks into the room, holding a plate of five waffles covered in (choice) cheese.

"MY CHEESY WAFFLE SUPREME!" YN shouts, jumping up and snatching the plate.

"I made extra for everyone else to try." Jeff says, staring at the plate.

"Great! Everyone, take one while they're still warm!" She grabs two and walks over to Lost. "Open up." The rest of us snicker as he blushes, shyly taking a bite of the 'Cheesy Waffle Supreme'. YN beams, taking a bite of her own.

"I-It's good..." Lost says, still blushing. Jeff takes one next, then Red and I. We all munch on our food as YN keeps feeding Silver.

Poor guy; he has no arms.

"YN!" I turn around, seeing Bloody at the door. YN turns her head, glaring.

"Helen, what did I tell you about family?" He seems taken aback, recoiling a bit.

"Sorry..." we're all confused on what's going on.

"It's not my fault he has no arms. I'm just being nice. Don't jump to conclusions." She says, giving Lost the last bite of his food. She walks over to Bloody and pulls him down by his collar. "If you keep assuming I'm flirting with other guys just because I'm spending time with them, I don't think we'll work." She lets go, smiling.

"Now let's play some videogames!"