Dean Winchester x Reader

That's my pie

You couldn't believe you were doing it. You were eating the pie that has made you drool for two days now. Dean's pie. He was certainly going to kill you, but it'd worth it.

It was definitely the best pie you had ever tasted. At first you had decided to go for a little slice, thinking that Dean wouldn't even notice it. But this little slice turned into two big slices. You had now eaten half of the pie, and couldn't stop.

But then, you heard them. Footsteps. It was so early you thought it would be Sam. But you almost choked on the pie you had in your mouth when you heard his voice.

"Good morning, sweetheart."

Dean, shit.

You tried your best to swallow the food in your mouth and hide the pie, but it was too late.

"Cassie..."

You looked up to see a very disappointed Dean glaring at you. A disappointment that soon turned into anger.

"I can explain." You said, some food falling from your mouth.

He crossed his arms on his chest, waiting for it.

"I, uh, well, you know, uh." You stammered, trying to think of a good excuse.

"I'm waiting Cassie. And you better have a great excuse to why you ate my pie."

He wasn't yelling, but you could hear the anger in his voice.

You sighed and looked at your hands.

"I'm sorry Dean, it's just, it looked so tasty, I had to."

You looked up at him, trying to put on your best puppy eyes, something you had the chance to practice a few times, thanks to Sam. It was the only thing that you could maybe calm down Dean a little, and if it wasn't working, you'd better have to run.

Dean tried to stay stoic but you could see on his face that he could not be mad anymore.

"I'm really sorry, won't happen again."

You stood up and gave him a big hug. At first he stayed rigid, but soon he melted into your embrace and hugged you back.

"It's okay, just ask me next time. So we can share it." He looked down at you, a smile warm showing on his face.

"I will, promise." You kissed his cheek, getting a slight blush from the hunter.

You pulled away from the hug and gave him a cheeky smile, before leaving the kitchen.

Like you thought earlier, eating Dean's pie was totally worth it.