Andy-He loves your smile, and the way it's almost always real and he knows the difference between your real and fake smile. (I DID NOT MEAN TO USE AND SO MANY TIMES I AM ACTUALLY SORRY).
Rye-Your eyes, somehow no matter what time or place he always can get lost in them.
Brook-Everything, there's not one thing he could flaw on you. To him your perfect even if you can't see it.
Mikey-Your personality, in some ways you can be a complete idiot with him but you also have your serious caring side.
Jack-Your style, he loves everything you wear because. Well. Literally everything suits you.