I can't do anymore readers guys I'm sorry 😣 they make me uncomfortable to write, i really hope you understand. Someone requested me to do a ben x Jeff x reader and I couldn't do it, so I'm going to do the ben x Jeff but with out the Reader, if you'd like you can use your imagination to put yourself into it but other then that I can't do x readers. I find it weird and uncomfortable I apologize. I'm so so sorry guys
(It's winter btw) BEN: I thought a few drinks would be ok, but next thing you know I'm in a guys truck, letting him fuck me. I'm getting ahead of myself aren't I? Well I'll start from the beginning. Well, my story that is.
Jeff: This'll be good.
BENS SIDE
8 hours earlier
"Yes I heard you dad, don't drink and drive ok ok, you treat me like I'm 14. I'm 18!!!!" I shouted as I stormed out of the house through the dumb ass snow we get. Fuck I hate winter. I got in my car and drove down the streets. I stopped and pulled out my phone, putting this- oh yeah..I'm going to a party, I forget to mention somethings sorry- putting this guys address in. I cannot believe Jane talked me into going. She's such a bitch sometimes you know? After a few more twists and turns I was finally at the house. I put my beanie on and checked my hair one last time before getting out.
I walked up the icy walk way to their house, going up the stairs to the door. Thennn i slipped.
"OH COME ON!" I sat on the ground, about to cry because of how much I hated winter. All the snow and fucking ice, and don't even get me started on how cold it gets.
I heard a truck pull up so I turned my head to look. Out of the truck stepped a tall guy with beautiful blue eyes and brown shaggy hair...and another guy with like what greenish eyes with gross hair ew. They walked up to me and the blue eyed man asked if I needed help. I said yeah of corse because well, I don't wanna fall trying to get up on my own. I gave the man a smile and he asked for my name.
"Benjamin But you can call me Ben," he smiled.
"Im Jeffrey But You Can Call me Jeff," i was about to respond back when the other guy blurted in and ruined the moment.
"Stop flirting let's go inside" he opened the door and pushed through the crowd of people.
"Wanna..have a few drinks with me?" I nodded, what a gentleman. He walked inside the house and I followed, shutting the door, then clinging on to the back of his shirt, cuz well..im small. We got to the table with all the drinks and snacks laid out on it. I grabbed a drink that looked like punch and took a sip. Yuck. I wanted to look cool so I pretended it was good.
Jeff led me to a couch and sat down. I kinda stood there not knowing if he wanted me to sit by him or if like he wanted me gone or-
"What are you waiting for? An inventive? Sit you weirdo," he patted the couch next to him and smiled. I chuckled slightly and sat by him.
We were handed a few more drinks by this girl- Wait a second it's Jane. She winked at me as she walked by. Should I be afraid? I checked my drink then smelled it. What'd she do? I grabbed Jeffs drink and inspected it. He watched me and raised an eyebrow at me.
"I know her, she could be up to something," I narrowed my eyes at the drink and he snatched it back.
"Its a drink, dude, chill," he laughed and took a swig- that is what's the cool term for drink now right?- a swig of it. I shrugged and drank some too. It was better this time,maybe because I'm tipsy. Who knows.
After a few more drinks and bullshitting, we were both smashed. Jeff grabbed my face and turned it to his face. He looked like he was like deeply inspecting my face, then he pulled me closer and..kissed?!??! Me?!??! I- being shocked kissed back. We made out on the couch.
His tongue slid across my lips so I opened my mouth slightly. He slipped it in my mouth and leaned into me. He explored every inch of my mouth with that taste bud infested thing. Pretty soon he picked me up and carried me out to his truck.
Jeff unlocked it, then threw me in. Practically begging me to ride him-
Jeff: Bullshit!
BEN: DONT RUIN MY AIDE OF IT! YOU CAN HAVE YOUR SIDE SOON YOU SONOFABITCH
-He sat in the passenger seat and slipped his sweatshirt off. I got on his lap and began to grind hard but slow. His breath hitched each time. It was hot. He unzipped my boxers and pants and slipped then down enough to expose my ass and dick. He unzipped his pants and took his dick out I lowered myself onto him and let out small gasps and moans. I went soft but fast up and down on him. It was great. Especially when Jeff flipped us and made the seat go down, slamming into me with all his force.
"JEFF!" I moaned out as I came all over his tummy. He thrusted one last time and came inside of me. I could feel his cock throbbing on my walls. God it feels so good....
Jeff: Oh please. I'll tell you how it really went down,
BEN: Yeah uh-huh
JEFFS SIDE
Ben was drunk as fuck and all over me. In my lap on the couch, grinding against me and biting my neck. I was enjoying it don't get me wrong, but it was weird infront of all my friends. Not that I was ashamed! I'm actually openly gay. But, it was uncomfortable with all the eyes. I picked him up and stumbled to my car, setting him in the passenger seat. I went to the other side and got in the drivers seat. I watched ben as he unzipped and took his pants and boxers off. So I did the same, but not taking my pants and boxers fully off, just exposing my dick.
Ben got on top of me and began to kiss me, then sat down on me. I let out a gasp at the new tight feeling around me. Ben moaned pathetically and began to move up and down sloppily. I got tired of how sloppy it was and flipped us, reclining the seat and slamming into him.
"Like that?" I growled in his ear. He nodded and whined out something I couldn't understand. I pounded into him with all my will and power. Watching his little body under me shake and bounce with my movements. He was so hapless it was sexy. I gripped his hips. And bit his neck, leaving my mark to let anyone know, he's mine.
"I'm gonna cum!" Ben slurred out along with moaning my name. I slammed one last time into him and came at the same time as him.
Jeff: that's what really happened
BEN: Whatever
Jeff pulled down BENS collar neck and showed the hickeys and bite marks.
BEN: THIS PROVES NOTHING
Jeff: what do you think Y/N?
What side do you believe??? Leave your side in the comment along with non readers x a creepypasta :)
PS IF YOU WANT TO MESSAGE ME MESSAGE ME ON KIK: 2_ben_drowned_2
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
