Our Creepypasta Story

Chapter 24

(unedited)  

~Selena's P.O.V~

I woke up the next morning not bothering to open my eyes, I just rolled around trying to get comfortable again to fall back asleep before I feel a hand draped over my waist and pull me closer to someone, I peek my eyes open and look at my shoulder to find Ethan's face laying on my head trying to go back to sleep as well. I just laid my head back down and went back to sleep, when I woke up the second time it was to someone opening my window, I sat up making sure not to disturb Ethan and found a black and white arm with claws on my wall near the window, I knew right then and there it was LJ... He got in and I was sitting up with a bored face and easy to throw knives in my hand. Ethan was facing the other way sleeping, he spotted me and that's when he knew he had fucked up. He raised his hands up

"I just came here to talk." I put a finger over my mouth with a glare before checking and making sure Ethan was still asleep, I smiled a bit to myself, I couldn't help it he was just really cute when he slept, and really hot when he was awake. I got out of bed carefully and LJ followed me to the kitchen, I stood a good distance away from him with my arms crossed and glaring.

"Ok now spill."

"Look, I'm sorry about everything that happened between Me and Ethan-"

"Ethan and I, use proper grammar." I corrected him and he just sucked in a breath

"Ethan and I, but I wanted Emma back and Ethan was now underage and it was illegal, and then Jen came along, she reminded me so much of Emma and she was an ok age, and she was hot, and nice and I fell in love with her. I'm sorry about calling you names and having Jen gang up on you as well in school-"

"Wait what?!" Both LJ and I turn our attention to a very pissed Ethan "How come I was never told that this was happening?" LJ turned his attention to me

"You never told him?" I shook my head

"I didn't want to add to anything so I just kept my mouth shut." Ethan looked like he realized something and went over to me standing beside me

"LJ, I think it's time for you to leave."

"But-"

"No, no but's, I have to talk to Sel about something and you don't need to be here, Just go away." LJ nodded and left through the front door before Ethan turned his attention to me. "Is that why you did this?" he lifted my shirt so my cuts were visible... and honestly I did it because of the stress, hate, and everything that had happened, first I found out I was supposed to be someone else. Second I was compared to that person all the time, third Schoolwork. Fourth adjusting to the death of my love ones. Five the war and finally the hurtful things that Jen and LJ would tell me on top of the other's at school, It felt like I never got a break...

"Not fully..." He had me explain and then I wouldn't tell him who the others were in school and just brushed it off as not mattering, and that they didn't mean any harm by it just trying to get him to drop it and not kill any of them. He wouldn't let it go though and for the rest of the day brought it up at random times, to the point where I was now not telling Kylie, or Sage and they were all asking me. We were out on the couch and they were trying to get it out of me, so I made up the excuse that I was going to go get a snack from the kitchen and just sat in there for a little while making sure the knives and everything were placed away from me so they wouldn't get the wrong idea. After a while of just sitting on the counter with my head up against some cabinets with earbuds in, my music up loud enough I couldn't hear anyone, and just staring out the window I sense someone walk into the kitchen, out of the corner of my eye I can see Ethan and I see his lips moving but I can't hear a word he's saying before he rips my one earbud out of my ear and dragged me back to the living room where we all sat there watching the 'Nightmare Before Christmas' and going to bed, Ethan and I were just sitting there scrolling through stuff and I was getting tired so I set my phone on my bedside table