( you have chosen to leave the group and go after Hannah and Beth )
————————
Y/N POV"You're all jerks!" Beth yelled running after Hannah
You run past the group into the storm on the search for Hannah and Beth. "Beth!" You shout "shit" You mutter sewing fire through the trees, your eyes widen and keep running you were shivering but you just continued on "Beth! Hannah!" You screamed out nothing only echos through the mountains, you hear a branch snap and you freeze up stopping in your tracks and slowly turn around you saw something, something in the shadows you just stood there for a second and breathed out and continued you ended up at this wooden bridge you saw something glowing in the water it was stuck in a rock you got it out.. it was Beth's phone , you turned on the phone for some reason still worked the lock screen popped up it was a picture of you, Hannah, Beth and Josh you started running again now that you have a light "Hannah! Beth" you got near a cliff and looked down 'greeaaaatt' you thought you didn't see anything but you started running back you heard loud screeches from behind you in the distance your eyes widen and you run faster you looked behind you, being clumsy you trip over a rock and smack your head on something. 🦋(<—— butterfly effect)You woke up to shouts in the distance your head was throbbing, you were lying in the snow freezing your ass off you. You tried standing up and nearly tumbled over you grabbed onto a tree and start walking towards the voices
"H-help" your voice raspy and shaky from the cold
"Y/N oh my god" Josh ran over and hugged me tight his warmth making me feel a bit better I hug back "we need to get you back" I nod "Can you walk?" He asks you just shake your and he picks me up bridal style and carries you back to the lodge[ time skip to a hospital ]
You woke up to someone shinning a light in your eyes you wave your handing for the person to stop ,they stop.
"Good you're up" a woman says she's wearing scrubs 'I'm in a hospital!?' I think to myself "You were in a bad accident, you hit your head pretty bad" she says I shrug "w-where's Josh?" Are the first words that come out of your mouth "he's fine dear now please rest" she says and I lay back down and fall into a deep sleep.
( time skip to police station )
I sit down in the chair in front of a woman
"Hello Y/N I'm going to be asking you a few questions today" I slowly nod
"So Y/N what exactly happened?" She asked
"Hannah was Pranked by Mike . Me and Hannah were in the kitchen we found a note from Mike it was obviously a prank and he's dating Emily so. Hannah was upset and ran out of the house Beth followed, than I did but I was To late they disappeared, poof gone. Something or someone chased me and I fell and smacked my head," I say a hint of sadness in my voice "I found Beth's phone it's broken now the water destroyed it but I found it in water.." I pull the phone from my pocket and set it in front of her a tear rolled down my cheek " I couldn't find them anywhere"
I finished.🦋Hey guys and gals I hope you liked it! If you chose this choice great. There will be choices throughout the story so hope you like this. I wanted to make it scary Ish and interesting. Like the game you decide. Hope you liked chapter one I'd love feed back from y'all!
You made a butterfly effect. :)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e57f0/e57f05d23e2b08f405555c7e55a338c98ea06e7f" alt=""
YOU ARE READING
Until Dawn X reader
Horror(This story allows you to make your own butterfly effect, your own choices there will be notes telling you to stay or go to the next chapter to show the choice you have made no going back... there will be a butterfly at the top of the page when you...